David Estes Fans and YA Book Lovers Unite! discussion
This topic is about
Requiem
Buddy Reads!
>
Requiem Buddy Read!
message 51:
by
Jenny, Always smiling! :-D
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Mar 18, 2013 03:34PM
Mod
reply
|
flag
I didnt read them in order, i read in this order :Delirium, Pandemonium, Alex,Raven, started Requiem, Hana, finished Requiem, and i now have to read Annabel
The Cover Contessa wrote: "So who read the short stories in order? Did anyone read Raven before reading this? Just curious if you have the same questions as me."
I haven't read any of them, oops!
I haven't read any of them, oops!
Dalu wrote: "I didnt read them in order, i read in this order :Delirium, Pandemonium, Alex,Raven, started Requiem, Hana, finished Requiem, and i now have to read Annabel"So, what do you think about Raven's story not being addressed in Requiem? Did it seem odd to you?
Jenny wrote: "Okay I'm now 57% of the way in.
Okay, I here you all about Alex, it made me feel really bad for Lena...but on the other hand, she's now in a new relationship, so he's probably trying to protect hi..."
Yeah, I hear you. No one's in a position to be in relationships considering what's going on. Everyone's too fragile. But it still sucks that (view spoiler)
Okay, I here you all about Alex, it made me feel really bad for Lena...but on the other hand, she's now in a new relationship, so he's probably trying to protect hi..."
Yeah, I hear you. No one's in a position to be in relationships considering what's going on. Everyone's too fragile. But it still sucks that (view spoiler)
OK, I'm at 72% and I'll post my thoughts to this point a little later on. But I just had to post my thoughts when I was at 42% because no one has mentioned it (view spoiler)
David wrote: "OK, I'm at 72% and I'll post my thoughts to this point a little later on. But I just had to post my thoughts when I was at 42% because no one has mentioned it [spoilers removed]"Nope, we didn't know it before this book.
I agree, David, it did totally suck! At times, this trilogy makes me think a little of The Hunger Games...just in the fact that all these good characters are stuck in a hopeless situation, and trying to do the best they can with it...no one is going to end up truly happy IMO!
The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "I didnt read them in order, i read in this order :Delirium, Pandemonium, Alex,Raven, started Requiem, Hana, finished Requiem, and i now have to read Annabel"So, what do you think a..."
It was very odd whe i finished Requiem because i thought (dont read this if you didnt finish Requiem) (view spoiler) The thing abour reading Raven before Requiem was that i felt both Raven and Tack more human, like Tack is not this always angry guy i thought he was. I hope that was your question, i had trouble trying to understand it because of my maybe not that good English
David wrote: "OK, I'm at 72% and I'll post my thoughts to this point a little later on. But I just had to post my thoughts when I was at 42% because no one has mentioned it [spoilers removed]"The Cover Contessa and David:
If you read Hana, she says that at the end of her book
Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "I didnt read them in order, i read in this order :Delirium, Pandemonium, Alex,Raven, started Requiem, Hana, finished Requiem, and i now have to read Annabe..."Yes, the spoiler was my question. I just find it odd that it was never even addressed in Requiem. I mean why bother writing something like that in a novella. I loved seeing Raven's POV, tho.
Dalu wrote: "David wrote: "OK, I'm at 72% and I'll post my thoughts to this point a little later on. But I just had to post my thoughts when I was at 42% because no one has mentioned it [spoilers removed]"The..."
Ugh, I read it, I don't remember. It was SO long ago.
The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "I didnt read them in order, i read in this order :Delirium, Pandemonium, Alex,Raven, started Requiem, Hana, finished Requiem, and i now have ..."And it wasnt something small it was like WOW i spent the whole Requiem waiting for her to bring that up
Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "I didnt read them in order, i read in this order :Delirium, Pandemonium, Alex,Raven, started Requiem, Hana, finish..."I didn't read it until after I read Requiem. I think I'm glad. I was already upset enough with Requiem, I think that would have made it worse for me! LOL! Not even anything from Lena's POV to show it to the reader in some way, shape or form. So much left unsaid. That's what bothered me about this book.
The Cover Contessa wrote: "David wrote: "OK, I'm at 72% and I'll post my thoughts to this point a little later on. But I just had to post my thoughts when I was at 42% because no one has mentioned it [spoilers removed]"
Nop..."
Cool, thanks, I didn't think so :)
Nop..."
Cool, thanks, I didn't think so :)
Dalu wrote: "David wrote: "OK, I'm at 72% and I'll post my thoughts to this point a little later on. But I just had to post my thoughts when I was at 42% because no one has mentioned it [spoilers removed]"
The..."
Ohhh OK, thanks, that makes sense :)
The..."
Ohhh OK, thanks, that makes sense :)
Jenny wrote: "I agree, David, it did totally suck! At times, this trilogy makes me think a little of The Hunger Games...just in the fact that all these good characters are stuck in a hopeless situation, and try..."
Exactly, great writing but somewhat painful to read!
Exactly, great writing but somewhat painful to read!
David wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "David wrote: "OK, I'm at 72% and I'll post my thoughts to this point a little later on. But I just had to post my thoughts when I was at 42% because no one has mentioned ..."Wait, someone says that in the hana story she mentions it at the end, I don't remember reading it tho. my mind is a sieve!
The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "I didnt read them in order, i read in this order :Delirium, Pandemonium, Alex,Raven, started Requiem..."What upseted (i dont know if that word was ok) you about Requiem? I would have wanted to see mor of Alex's POV and of course Raven's. I also would have wanted to know what was Tack thinking.
Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "I didnt read them in order, i read in this order :Delirium, Pandemonium, ..."I felt that Hana's POV took away from Lena's story. I didn't feel there was any closure. And I felt like Lena was less strong in this book than Pandemonium. The end of this book reminded me very much of Mockingjay. I wasn't looking for a HEA necessarily, but I needed some stuff rapped up that just kind of hung there. And there's no epilogue for closure at all.
The Cover Contessa wrote: "David wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "David wrote: "OK, I'm at 72% and I'll post my thoughts to this point a little later on. But I just had to post my thoughts when I was at 42% because no one ..."Do you remember (view spoiler)
The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "I didnt read them in order, i read in this order :Delirium,..."I know that upset me too! and left me with a lot of questions also: (view spoiler)
Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "David wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "David wrote: "OK, I'm at 72% and I'll post my thoughts to this point a little later on. But I just had to post my thoughts when I..."HA! I can't remember. I read it right after Delirium. It was so long ago! LOL!
Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "I didnt read them in order, i rea..."YES!!!! all of the above! LOL! And while I LOVED Oliver's writing and can appreciate that she couldn't tie things up in a pretty bow, I just felt like I was left hanging.
The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "I didnt read them i..."what would you recomend for me to read now in the same genre?
I just read Hana, and it does mention it at the end of her story, that she's jealous of Lena. Hana has a short affair with that guy Steve, then realizes he's being a total guy, just trying to get in her pants, and she's really jealous that Lena found the real thing. She she's a poster offering a $500 reward for info, then thinks, "Sorry, Lena," then the story ends.
LOL thanks for the summary of Hana, that helps explain some of the backstory I didn't really understand :)
Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu ..."
I've heard good things about Shatter Me, which I bought a few days ago. You might like Legend or Under the Never Sky too, they're pretty good :) And Divergent was awesome for me :)
I've heard good things about Shatter Me, which I bought a few days ago. You might like Legend or Under the Never Sky too, they're pretty good :) And Divergent was awesome for me :)
David wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa ..."Thanks! i already read Divergent, cant wait for the third book!
Dalu wrote: "David wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The C..."I would go with those that David mentioned. There's also the Matched series, which is complete so no waiting on any books for that. It's fairly good, although not as good as some of the other dystopians I have read.
David wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa ..."Shatter Me is amazing, but it is fairly heavy on the romance with a bit of craziness side in the first book. More of the dystopian stuff in Unravel Me. Legend was ok for me, not great. I have Prodigy but haven't read it yet. LOVE UTNS
hey everyone i'm so pissed off! I was told like 5 minutes ago about the tv show that will be based on Delirium and. This is for whoever wants to read it. this are just rumors that came to me in a fb chatroom (view spoiler)
I agree with CC - Shatter Me is good until the end (view spoiler). Destroy Me was very, very good for a short story - and if that's any indication of Unravel Me, then I'm looking forward to reading it. It's on my list.
Dalu wrote: "hey everyone i'm so pissed off! I was told like 5 minutes ago about the tv show that will be based on Delirium and. This is for whoever wants to read it. this are just rumors that came to me in a f..."
URGH! Doesn't sound promising!
URGH! Doesn't sound promising!
Jen wrote: "I agree with CC - Shatter Me is good until the end [spoilers removed]. Destroy Me was very, very good for a short story - and if that's any indication of Unravel Me, then I'm looking forward to re..."
Cool, that makes me excited to read it, I've been struggling with whether to read it and then it was on sale so I went for it!
Cool, that makes me excited to read it, I've been struggling with whether to read it and then it was on sale so I went for it!
The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "David wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu ..."
Yeah, I'd say Matched is pretty similar to Delirium but Delirium is better. I haven't read the second and third Matched books though, are they any good?
Yeah, I'd say Matched is pretty similar to Delirium but Delirium is better. I haven't read the second and third Matched books though, are they any good?
David wrote: "I haven't read the second and third Matched books though, are they any good? "I liked the second one (Crossed). But the third one gets kind of dragged out. It's a lot of war and things needing to be done such-and-such a way because of the war, etc. I will say, though, that the ending is really good. She ties it all up really well. I wish Lauren Oliver had chosen to do the same. BTW, are you done yet? Are you done yet? Areyoudoneyet? How about now? How about now?
Dalu wrote: "hey everyone i'm so pissed off! I was told like 5 minutes ago about the tv show that will be based on Delirium and. This is for whoever wants to read it. this are just rumors that came to me in a f..."Yes, I had hear they are totally changing it. So I probably will not watch it at all.
Dalu wrote: "hey everyone i'm so pissed off! I was told like 5 minutes ago about the tv show that will be based on Delirium and. This is for whoever wants to read it. this are just rumors that came to me in a f..."Actually, I think it does sound promising. It will be a departure from the book, using some of the same characters. Remember how Julian had a brain tumour? I think that will play into it. And honestly, I thought from the get-go that Julian and Hana ought to have had some kind of relationship. I was hoping in Requiem that her cure wouldn't have worked, and he'd find her, etc. Uh, no. THAT didn't happen. So if they want to do something completely different with the tv show, at least it won't be the big disappointment that Requiem was.
Jen wrote: "I agree with CC - Shatter Me is good until the end [spoilers removed]. Destroy Me was very, very good for a short story - and if that's any indication of Unravel Me, then I'm looking forward to re..."I actually liked the end of Shatter me (view spoiler). I LOVED Destory Me. AMazing POV from Warner.
David wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "David wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The Cover Contessa wrote: "Dalu wrote: "The C..."Yes, matched is similar to Delirium, but you're right Delirium is better. I preferred Crossed to matched. I haven't read REached yet, it's been sitting on my shelf since it was released. Another series to try is Eve.
Jen wrote: "Dalu wrote: "hey everyone i'm so pissed off! I was told like 5 minutes ago about the tv show that will be based on Delirium and. This is for whoever wants to read it. this are just rumors that cam..."You have a point about it not being disappointing if they change things up.
Jen wrote: "David wrote: "I haven't read the second and third Matched books though, are they any good? "
I liked the second one (Crossed). But the third one gets kind of dragged out. It's a lot of war and t..."
Cool thanks ;)
Nope still stuck at 72%, took a break to watch Downton Abbey with the Adele ;)
I liked the second one (Crossed). But the third one gets kind of dragged out. It's a lot of war and t..."
Cool thanks ;)
Nope still stuck at 72%, took a break to watch Downton Abbey with the Adele ;)
Jen wrote: "Dalu wrote: "hey everyone i'm so pissed off! I was told like 5 minutes ago about the tv show that will be based on Delirium and. This is for whoever wants to read it. this are just rumors that cam..."
I'll try it either way!!
I'll try it either way!!
Jen wrote: "David wrote: "I haven't read the second and third Matched books though, are they any good? "I liked the second one (Crossed). But the third one gets kind of dragged out. It's a lot of war and t..."
LOL!!!!!!
There are so many comentsssssssssssss!Matched:
i really liked the Matched trilogy, i read the last one in English, and i bought the hardcover unlike all the other books i read because they were in Spanish and in my ereader. I really liked Reached (the last book) because i saw Xander and Ky's POV. and like how de story ended with no cliffhanger ulike Requiem.
Delirium/tv show!:
I hope they dont chance that muuch when they do the tv show, i loved it the way it was, every single part of it and would hate to see the changes they're planning to do.
Okay, I've read Requiem two weeks ago. Mine's a Reader Edition (The First Edition might have some changes, the one you're about to buy.)Requiem is personally quite my favorite in the trilogy (Delirium made me cry, in all honesty when Alex sacrificed his own life for Lena to cross the border - that one really made me cry like...oh well. Try listening to a song, for instance, Run by Snow Patrol and read the last three chapters.) and for me the last book is Full On Resolution and that unexpected revelation that DON'T READ THIS IF YOU'RE STILL NOT SOMEWHERE IN THE MIDDLE OF THE BOOK! (view spoiler) I love Julian, but you know, we got used to Alex in Delirium and slightly in Pandemonium. Julian vs Alex? I really Lena to end up with Alex. Want a spoiler again? No, find it yourself. But Lauren gave me hopes for Julian. He can be a new leader of the SPOILER ALERT! (view spoiler) Wow, Hana Hana Hana, her character is strong in a more damsel way, I love her. Totes. Even though...gaaahh, I'm tired of giving spoilers. (view spoiler) Lena has become the reader's favorite since Delirium and even then, changed or not changed, she is still one of my favorite girls. The fact of being torn between Past and Present.
Requiem honestly, summed up what the two books wasn't able to tell. From the possibility of life outside, what is the feeling of being cured, what would happen to Julian, Lena and Alex, how they could stop the rising security measures in the locked state of Portland, what happened to Lena's foster family after Delirium, what happened to Alex in Pandemonium, how everything went to chaos...and how Lena finds her long time so-called dead mother. What happened to love, what happened to control. The book summed it all up to satisfy the readers and to answer our questions. The ending, my hope is that, you mustn't be disappointed of the resolution of the story. how it ends, one of the best ending of any Dystopian Books. I tell you, there is that point in the last paragraph Magdalena had said that you'll ask for more. The Last paragraph is the highlight of them all.
#Kudos in reading!!
Reymart wrote: "Okay, I've read Requiem two weeks ago. Mine's a Reader Edition (The First Edition might have some changes, the one you're about to buy.)Requiem is personally quite my favorite in the trilogy (Del..."
I really enjoyed your review, i agree with everything you said exept for the cheesy endings, i love them!
You could have known what happen to Alex while Pandemonium if read Deliroium stories: Alex
Dalu wrote: "Reymart wrote: "Okay, I've read Requiem two weeks ago. Mine's a Reader Edition (The First Edition might have some changes, the one you're about to buy.)Requiem is personally quite my favorite in ..."
Yes, I also love the way Lauren going in depth of the characters, between Lena and Hana. You really can understand what's happening inside and outside and that makes Requiem very much satisfying. Thank you for enjoying my review Dalu. :)
Books mentioned in this topic
Boundless (other topics)Boundless (other topics)
Boundless (other topics)
Boundless (other topics)
Boundless (other topics)
More...




