The Mark of Athena (The Heroes of Olympus, #3) The Mark of Athena discussion


1346 views
WHO WOULD WIN IN A FIGHT???!!!

Comments Showing 1-50 of 3,668 (3668 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 73 74

notyourfriend So here's how it works: I will put down two characters from either PJO or HOO and then the person below will say who they think would win and then start a new battle. Try to keep it with the characters from PJO & HOO but if one of those characters versus a character from another book it's fine. ENJOY AND MAY THE BEST WIN! ;)


notyourfriend Percy v.s. Frank?


J.J. Lair Paigetwo wrote: "Percy v.s. Frank?"

I think Percy has more experience and knowledge


notyourfriend ok now make another one. ___v.s.____


notyourfriend ok lets try this again!

Frank v.s. Leo?


notyourfriend Paigetwo wrote: "ok lets try this again!

Frank v.s. Leo?"


come on people! answer! & start a new one!


Leah Leo.

Piper vs. Octavian?


message 8: by Melissa (last edited Dec 28, 2012 03:57PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Melissa Leo will win. Frank would be too scared to even get close to Leo in fear of Leo's fire. Remember in MoA, when Leo burst on fire, even when the piece of wood was safely with Hazel, Frank still went cowering in the corner.

Annabeth vs Reyna


notyourfriend Piper.

Reyna v.s. Annabeth?


Breanna Annabeth would win because of her skill and experience. As a daughter of Athena she is a great warrior.

Percy vs. Jason?


Lauren I think percy because he could drown jason and no problem for him but jason could electrocute him... But then again percy is used to that so Percy would win.

Hazel Vs. Nico


message 12: by Leah (new) - rated it 5 stars

Leah Nico, because he's had more experience.

Frank vs. Hazel?


Evelyn hazel she a daughter of the big 3 and she has the land advantage
Ethan Nakamura Vs. Octavian


message 14: by [deleted user] (new)

Ethan.
Frank vs. Luke.


message 15: by krysta (last edited Dec 29, 2012 02:57PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

krysta Luke. He is ruthless and will stop at nothing to win. He makes smart moves in a fight and has also had more experience.

Zeus vs. Athena


notyourfriend Athena because she is Wisdom!

Nico v.s. Percy?


message 17: by Leah (new) - rated it 5 stars

Leah Percy... because... awesome.

Frank vs. Piper


notyourfriend Frank because he can turn into anything...

Annabeth v.s. Piper?


Weiting Annabeth! One, she has more experience with combat, two, she's smarter than Piper, but that charmspeaking of hers probably'll distract her.

Kronos vs. Gaia (Gaea, whatever, evil in both sides)?


Maddy Gaia. She is like this great mysterious force that seems to hold all power.

Zeus vs Posiden


message 21: by Jude (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jude sadly, i think zeus but i like posideon better

reyna vs. tyson


Maddy Reyna

Zeus and Percy vs. Posideon and Annabeth!


message 23: by Jude (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jude thats not fair. percy and posideon should be together. they can't fight each other. if you wanted me to make a decision, though, i would go with zeus and percy because percy is a son of one of the big three and zeus IS one of the big three and the big three are what they are because they are the three most powerful gods, being the sons of kronos. also, i think lightning and water would be very powerful together so percy and zeus would be the victors of that fight.


Django Well?


message 25: by Jude (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jude oh. ummmm.........

aurum, argentum, and reyna vs. frank, leo, jason, and nico


notyourfriend Frank,Leo,Jason,and Nico! Thats a cool team right there!

A fight in the underworld: Luke v.s. Bianca?


Weiting (Actually, depends on WHERE in the Underworld, but whatever)

In that case, Bianca, her territory, but in any other place, Luke.

Chrysaor (plus his dolphin army) vs. Triton (only him)


NataliaG chrysaor

Chiron vs. octavian


notyourfriend chiron

Ares v.s. Apollo


NataliaG Ares

Grover vs. Selena


message 31: by Leah (new) - rated it 5 stars

Leah Silena. Sorry, Grover


Juniper vs. Hera


message 32: by Jude (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jude hera!!
what makes you think juniper would stand a chance?

annabeth vs octavain


NataliaG Annabeth

narcissus (and his fans)vs. Chrysaor (and his dolphin army)


message 34: by Isaak (last edited Dec 31, 2012 11:47AM) (new)

Isaak Chrysaor ( just get narcissus distracted with a mirror)

Nico Vs a mortal ( assuming the mortal could get hurt by and see everything that Nico does including his sword)


Lauren Nico. That's kinda obvious...

Rachel vs. Octavian


message 36: by C.R. (new) - rated it 5 stars

C.R. Octavian... only because he's so rutheless unless Rachel has her blue hairbrush with her... :) :) :)

Okay here's one
Octavian vs Luke and remember Octavian is actually a decent fighter...


Django Luke. He was the greatest sword fighter in Camp Half-Blood remember?
Lares V.S. Eodelins (I don't know how to spell them)


message 38: by Isaak (new)

Isaak Hand to hand and not using Percy or Jason
Lares

Nico VS Clarisse


Clara Clarisse.

Jason VS Chiron


message 40: by Isaak (new)

Isaak If Chiron wasn't immortal Jason

Bianca ( resurrected ) VS Hazel


notyourfriend hard one... Bianca cause she is older...

Now this is a argument between me and my sister so i want 2 see what u guys think.... :

Percy Jackson v.s Harry Potter???


message 42: by Isaak (new)

Isaak I would have to go with Percy Jackson

Piper VS Queen Hylla


notyourfriend Isaak wrote: "I would have to go with Percy Jackson

Piper VS Queen Hylla"


THANK YOU, THATS WHAT I SAID BUT MY SISTER IS LIKE " NO HARRY POTTER IS BETTER!"

who is queen Hylla?


Sheila I'd have to say Queen Hylla. She has had more experience and got used to the tricks of charmspeak due to all of her time with Circe. For the next person:


Reyna vs. Luke


notyourfriend Paigetwo wrote: "who is queen Hylla?"

oh, nevermind i remember!

well luke is dead so if it was him as a ghost he would win but if it was when he was alive....nah i still think he would win!


notyourfriend Paigetwo wrote: "who is queen Hylla?"

oh, nevermind i remember!

well luke is dead so if it was him as a ghost he would win but if it was when he was alive....nah i still think he would win!


notyourfriend Nico v.S. Leo?


Sheila I'd have to say Nico, since he has a sword that can like suck in things and kill them. But I don't want Leo to be sucked into his death sword.


Sheila Piper vs. Hazel????


notyourfriend Sheila wrote: "I'd have to say Nico, since he has a sword that can like suck in things and kill them. But I don't want Leo to be sucked into his death sword."

thats ok I love both of them so i NEVER want them to fight! :0

Hazel would def. win!

Charlie Beckendorf v.s. Luke ( when BOTH were STILL ALIVE) ?


« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 73 74
back to top