The Hobbit The Hobbit discussion


71 views
The Hobbit

Comments (showing 1-12 of 12) (12 new)    post a comment »
dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Dillan (new)

Dillan Gates I think this is a really good book and the movie is coming out in December.


flickr Dillan wrote: "I think this is a really good book and the movie is coming out in December."

It's a good book, a lighter and better read than LOTR (imo)and in December the first movie of three will be out :) Must see at some point. It might have been difficult to put everything in one movie (and apparently two wasn't enough)I hope all three are good.


Analise I thought they were only making 2 good to know that they are making three! hope they're good :)


Casey I'm so excited for the first part to come out. I can hardly wait! :D


Chris There are already at least two other threads discussing the movie (here http://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/1... and here
http://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/1...). Do we really need another one?


Mike flickr wrote: "Dillan wrote: "I think this is a really good book and the movie is coming out in December."

It's a good book, a lighter and better read than LOTR (imo)and in December the first movie of three will..."


I have to admit I am a bit reserved about the movies. I want them to be good, but with the Hobbit having been written first, for Tolkien's children, it's definitely a lighter book and my fear is that it's going to come off as too childish in the movie. I want to trust Peter Jackson to set the proper tone and do a good job transitioning from an appropriately lighter Hobbit to the more mature LOTR series.

I suppose we'll all just have to wait...


Chris Chris wrote: "There are already at least two other threads discussing the movie (here http://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/1... and here
http://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/1...). Do we really need another one?"


The answer is obviously 'yes'...


Ali I LOVE ALL THESE BOOKS WITH ALL MY HEART AND SOUL. I NEVER WANTED ANY OF THE BOOKS TO END. MY IDEA OF A BEAUTIFUL BOOK.


Abel Casey wrote: "I'm so excited for the first part to come out. I can hardly wait! :D"

yea I'm going to see it in theaters for my birthday:)


Ali Abel wrote: "Casey wrote: "I'm so excited for the first part to come out. I can hardly wait! :D"

yea I'm going to see it in theaters for my birthday:)"


SAME!


message 11: by Chris (last edited Oct 27, 2012 01:44AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Chris Flanigan Ive read that the movie is going to be having scenes of when Gandalf leaves the party to go and confront the Necromancer with his order....the Necromancer of course being Sauron...it should be EPIC


message 12: by CASI (new) - rated it 5 stars

CASI Black O.M. If not for this thread I won't be able to know that there's gonna be a movie already! *kill me now! But I am really looking forward to this, I finished reading the book just this month so the scenes are still fresh. If it's gonna be on December, well, I'll pretend that it's my birthmonth and watch it! *.*


back to top