The Hogwartians Group discussion

60 views
Discussion Points/Opinions > Sectum Sempra

Comments Showing 1-50 of 102 (102 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1 3

message 1: by Savannah (new)

Savannah Morrow (SCMorrow) | 377 comments Mod
So what do you guys think about when Harry cursed Malfoy with Sectum Sempra? Do you think Malfoy deserved it? Do you think that Snape's punishment was appropriate????


message 2: by Janeen-san (new)

Janeen-san  (misswannareadalot) Snape's punishment was wicked awsome! what makes it FUNNY is that Harry never completed it! hhhahahaha!


message 3: by Savannah (new)

Savannah Morrow (SCMorrow) | 377 comments Mod
Personally, I think that Harry should of been a little more careful about his choosing of spells, And Snape's punishment was a little over the top. I kind of feel bad for how bad Harry feel about injuring Malfoy so badly.



message 4: by Janeen-san (new)

Janeen-san  (misswannareadalot) Well, yeah. It was sorta harsh. I'd never thouht I'd say this...poor malfoy!! :(


message 5: by Savannah (new)

Savannah Morrow (SCMorrow) | 377 comments Mod
soooo.... Does anyone else want to comment? (hint hint)


message 6: by Janeen-san (new)

Janeen-san  (misswannareadalot) hint hint?


message 7: by Savannah (new)

Savannah Morrow (SCMorrow) | 377 comments Mod
as in other people besides us 2! Jonathan or Caroline or Jann or Swati


message 8: by Janeen-san (new)

Janeen-san  (misswannareadalot) oooooooooo ok! HINT HINT HINT HINT!!! lol, jk!


message 9: by Sarah (new)

Sarah | 30 comments I thought that Malfoy deserved for the things that he has done but still, it was a little bit much


message 10: by Janeen-san (new)

Janeen-san  (misswannareadalot) me too


message 11: by Sarah (new)

Sarah | 30 comments well, it wasn't my choice to write it, I guess JK Rowling had her reasons.


message 12: by Janeen-san (new)

Janeen-san  (misswannareadalot) yeah.


message 13: by Erica (new)

Erica (thppjfan) I think she wanted to show what it was


message 14: by Savannah (new)

Savannah Morrow (SCMorrow) | 377 comments Mod
It could have been her editors too, we can't all blame her for something she may have not wanted to put in there in the first place.



message 15: by Sarah (new)

Sarah | 30 comments true


message 16: by Janeen-san (new)

Janeen-san  (misswannareadalot) Yeah.


message 17: by Janeen-san (new)

Janeen-san  (misswannareadalot) :/


message 18: by Erica (new)

Erica (thppjfan) agreed


message 19: by Janeen-san (new)

Janeen-san  (misswannareadalot) totally agreed


message 20: by Savannah (new)

Savannah Morrow (SCMorrow) | 377 comments Mod
I'm glad you agree! :D


message 21: by Janeen-san (new)

Janeen-san  (misswannareadalot) Me to :D


message 22: by Sarah (new)

Sarah | 30 comments i guess you know my answer


message 23: by Janeen-san (new)

Janeen-san  (misswannareadalot) Yes?


message 24: by Sarah (new)

Sarah | 30 comments correct, you win but, I dont have a prize, sorry


message 25: by Janeen-san (new)

Janeen-san  (misswannareadalot) ...Hey, aren't we getting off the subject here? We are supposed to be taling about "Sectum Sempra". No spamming, remember?



message 26: by Sarah (new)

Sarah | 30 comments yes


message 27: by Janeen-san (new)

Janeen-san  (misswannareadalot) Poor Malfoy...he was crying in the bathroom :(


message 28: by Savannah (new)

Savannah Morrow (SCMorrow) | 377 comments Mod
I would feel bad if I was Harry or Malfoy!


message 29: by Janeen-san (new)

Janeen-san  (misswannareadalot) Yeah...I think I'd feel worst if I was Malfoy :/


message 30: by Sarah (new)

Sarah | 30 comments probably


message 31: by Swati , The HP fan that LOVES this group! (new)

Swati  (readerforevergmailcom) | 214 comments Mod
Sorry for not replying before Savannah!

It was so sad for Malfoy! I mean, he like, totally didn't deserve it. Wait, I forgot, what was the punishment that Harry was given? I don't remember..


message 32: by Janeen-san (new)

Janeen-san  (misswannareadalot) Snape made him re-write all the detentions all Hogwarts students ever got...it was so funny that he never finished!! :)


message 33: by Erica (new)

Erica (thppjfan) Plus he had to start and all the detentions his dad, lupin, Serius, and the mouse dude did (forgot his name, I know it starts with a P though!)


message 34: by Janeen-san (new)

Janeen-san  (misswannareadalot) Peter Pettigrew.


message 35: by Lorna (new)

Lorna i dont think the punishment was harsh! for snape it was quite tame in my opinion...and malfoy was innocent, but still a little git...


message 36: by Janeen-san (new)

Janeen-san  (misswannareadalot) Lorna wrote: "i dont think the punishment was harsh! for snape it was quite tame in my opinion...and malfoy was innocent, but still a little git..."

you didn't?? why????? Curious


message 37: by Lorna (new)

Lorna Well, it didnt involve physical pain for harry!
And snape was kind of right about harry's dad being an arse etc...


message 38: by Janeen-san (new)

Janeen-san  (misswannareadalot) arse?


message 39: by Lorna (new)

Lorna ...bully?


message 40: by Janeen-san (new)

Janeen-san  (misswannareadalot) oooooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh ok!!


message 41: by Lorna (new)

Lorna lol. sorry, im too aussie


message 42: by Swati , The HP fan that LOVES this group! (new)

Swati  (readerforevergmailcom) | 214 comments Mod
Oh right.


message 43: by Janeen-san (new)

Janeen-san  (misswannareadalot) ........


message 44: by Swati , The HP fan that LOVES this group! (new)

Swati  (readerforevergmailcom) | 214 comments Mod
.......


message 45: by Lorna (new)

Lorna I want a pigmy puff


message 46: by Swati , The HP fan that LOVES this group! (new)

Swati  (readerforevergmailcom) | 214 comments Mod
HAHA!!!


message 47: by Janeen-san (new)

Janeen-san  (misswannareadalot) pigmy puffs are so cuuuuuuuttteee <3



message 48: by Hannah (new)

Hannah (lettingtheinkdry) I want a blue pigmypuff


message 49: by Janeen-san (new)

Janeen-san  (misswannareadalot) Hmmm.....I want a green or blue or pink or PURPLE!!!! I love the color purple


message 50: by Hannah (new)

Hannah (lettingtheinkdry) OMG purple! Yay for purple.
Aha!A tidye pigmy puff! That's it! I'll get a tidye pigmypuff!


« previous 1 3
back to top