Midnight
discussion
Does anyone else think this book would be better if it was focused on Firestar still?
date
newest »






whats the chosen 4



message 11:
by
yojharobed || I have no sword. I don't need a sword. Because I am the Doctor and this is my spoon. En garde!
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars

no willowpelt wasn't killed by a badger, tigerstar killed her and left her body at the top of the ravine as bait for the dogs.

NO! Firestar should die!



I totally agree. It was good wen it was still focused on Firestar, but adding all these new cats in a bunch of new books just became too much.

I agree with Max. :)

Annie/Soul wrote: "((Sorrelpaw WAS ran over by a monster/car. It says so in Midnight. But it wasn't mentioned in Firestar's quest.)) "
She was HIT by a car, not ran over by a car. :)
She was HIT by a car, not ran over by a car. :)

true

agree

1: I really did like the books that were focused on Firestar, they were a much easier read and easier to stay on top of reading. I would've liked to have read a little more about Firestar, but he grew up, and HIS purpose was fulfilled, and needed no further depth.
but 2: I feel like if it had stayed focusing solely on Firestar, the story would've become boring and would lose interest. I think that it also has to do with the 2nd part of the series being about the other 6 cats, it needed to be split into 1 of each cats perspective in that series, and was very necessary to grasp the true point of the story and make it a better read.
So, hopefully you find this somewhat good of an answer. :)
I don`t think the novel would have been any better. Still, Firestar had saved ThunderClan so a new prophecy would be needed.
Kendra wrote: "Honestly, I have two opinions.
1: I really did like the books that were focused on Firestar, they were a much easier read and easier to stay on top of reading. I would've liked to have read a littl..."
"Somewhat"? In my opinion, this is great answer since I`ve read and read really poor answers somebody just came up with in a few seconds.
1: I really did like the books that were focused on Firestar, they were a much easier read and easier to stay on top of reading. I would've liked to have read a littl..."
"Somewhat"? In my opinion, this is great answer since I`ve read and read really poor answers somebody just came up with in a few seconds.



Those stuff happened in the super edition, Firestar's Quest.


Willowpelt was killed by a badger, you're thinking of Brindleface

Brambleclaw, however, is a much better main character than Firestar and I don't miss the ginger warrior's input.

all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
Erin Hunter did a good job on this book but i feel she should of at least explained more things, possibly by a #7. I was also disappointed when i realised that the focus was now on Brambleclaw, Leafpaw and the chosen 4.
Please comment with your thoughts.