The YA Book Club discussion

1371 views
Love Interests > Team Aspen or Team Maxon?

Comments Showing 51-100 of 187 (187 new)    post a comment »

message 51: by Naomi (new)

Naomi Maxon


message 52: by chinami (new)

chinami | 75 comments maxon


message 53: by Laurel (new)

Laurel (herpilgrimsoul) | 40 comments Maxon. Aspen puts America in way to many dangerous situations. He could get her killed by having anything to do with her at the palace. Maxon is a lot more concerned with America's safety, so he wins. No doubt they both love her, though.


message 54: by Leahxx (new)

Leahxx (heyitsleahxx) | 13 comments Maxon, Aspen's too clingy and desperate. Maxon's so sweet and he never asked for America to be chosen, and it's absolutely adorable that he fell in love with her anyway. But America treats him like crap constantly and I feel o bad for him. He definitely deserves a win. Maxon is totallyyy my favorite in this trilogy


message 55: by Gabby (new)

Gabby | 15 comments In book 1, I was set on Aspen, but after reading book 2, I'm definitely for Maxon. (I won't give away any spoilers) but I think that how Aspen acted in book 2 just wasn't an act of GENUINE LOVE for America.


message 56: by Molly (new)

Molly | 26 comments Totally MAXON MAXON MAXON! Aspen is way too... How do I say this... Perfect I guess? But not in a good way. He just acts like MAXON is this terrible guy. And also I like when guys are a little imperfect, like Maxon.idk there's just something not quite right about aspen. I feel like if he really loved America he would leave her alone, because she clearly wants maxon.


message 57: by Kaity (new)

Kaity (i-love-books-because-reasons) I haven't read the yet, but I'm gonna go with Maxon!


message 58: by Hannah (new)

Hannah (hannahsmanyhobbies) Maxon, because Aspens mostly a jerk.


message 59: by JustLetMeRead (last edited Apr 05, 2014 05:47PM) (new)

JustLetMeRead | 1 comments Maxon! The thing about Aspen is that if you truly love America and don't want her to get hurt, why are you kissing her if you (view spoiler)


message 60: by Erin (new)

Erin Vastag JustLetMeRead wrote: "Maxon! The thing about Aspen is that if you truly love America and don't want her to get hurt, why are you kissing her if you [spoilers removed]"

So True!


message 61: by Akemi (new)

Akemi Sato (akemi831sato) | 1 comments Are you seriously asking me that question? Team Maxon, of course!!!


message 62: by Doris (new)

Doris (dorisx) Team Maxon! Aspen really annoys me and I don't believe him because of his behavoiur sometimes.


message 63: by Melanie (new)

Melanie (booksaremychildren) | 6 comments Team Maxon all the way and I really need America to end up with Maxon or I'll scream or worse.


message 64: by Melanie (new)

Melanie (booksaremychildren) | 6 comments Team Maxon all the way and I really need America to end up with Maxon or I'll scream or worse.


message 65: by Melanie (new)

Melanie (booksaremychildren) | 6 comments I really am Team Maxon because he's sweet even if he made some... mistakes.


message 66: by Cinthia (new)

Cinthia (cinthiah) I was team Maxon until he was caught making out with that other girl. I just couldn't get past that. Even though I am team Aspen now, I think she will actually end up with Maxon. Maybe he will redeem himself enough in the third book.


message 67: by Melanie (new)

Melanie (booksaremychildren) | 6 comments Cinthia wrote: "I was team Maxon until he was caught making out with that other girl. I just couldn't get past that. Even though I am team Aspen now, I think she will actually end up with Maxon. Maybe he will rede..."
I think America will end up with Maxon but, sometimes authors like to be mean and do other things like Veronica Roth with Allegiant.


message 68: by Mik (new)

Mik Maxon because he rally cares about America and they have many cute moments together


message 69: by [deleted user] (new)

MAXOOON! I didn't know that there is team Aspen's somewhere out there until i met one of them xdxd


message 70: by [deleted user] (new)

I just finished the one and I liked the way it ended relationshipwisw


message 71: by [deleted user] (new)

Oh, you read The One? I was planning to wait until it's translation but im waiting for Alleginat for months so im not sure now, if it won't be translated in a week im gonna read it in English xdxd


message 72: by [deleted user] (new)

R u German?


message 73: by [deleted user] (new)

Nope, I'm Turkish. So i gotta wait, i guess but it has already been translated and released into Spanish after 2 days that original has been.


message 74: by SAM (new)

SAM (77sam) Definitely Maxon. No Doubt About It!!!!!


message 75: by [deleted user] (new)

That stinks


message 76: by Erin (new)

Erin Vastag America and Maxon are just so perfect together!!


message 77: by Becca (new)

Becca (divergememockingjay) | 3 comments Maxon, there are just adorable together! So many feels! :)


message 78: by [deleted user] (new)

Yes I know. Perfection


message 79: by Emily.reads (new)

Emily.reads | 37 comments That's a tough choice i think I like Maxon better even though Aspen was her first love.


message 80: by Meagan (new)

Meagan | 171 comments I definitely prefer Maxon over Aspen because Aspen is really pushy trying to make America love him even after he hurt her so bad. I also think his "love" is quite insincere because after he pushed her away he decides its his mission in life to make America's life miserable and have to choose between him and Maxon. Especially since she was almost to the point where she could get over him and really love Maxon. Maxon was real with America from the start even when she told him that she didn't sign the Selection form because she wanted to marry him.


message 81: by Gianna (new)

Gianna Schiavone (thefaultinourgames) | 40 comments I'm in the middle of book two and I'm totally TEAM MAXON!


message 82: by Miriam (new)

Miriam | 12 comments Aspen he was always loyal to America


message 83: by Alice (new)

Alice Anna (alicethedemonkiller) | 356 comments Team Maxon!!!!!! He kept giving her chances, since day one. America was cruel sometimes (like the time she kicked his thigh (LOL)) he still kept her... I'm on the second book, and I'm almost done, but I hate Aspen for telling America, that the prince was a actor, he was tricking her into loving him (or something like that). But it was all a lie...


message 84: by Ria (new)

Ria | 16 comments After reading The One definitely team Maxon :) he's so sweet when he interacts with America


message 85: by Kimberly (new)

Kimberly Ferguson (kimberlyisashadowhunter) | 5 comments Team Maxon! After The Elite Aspen just became so selfish and was a jerk.


message 86: by Claire (new)

Claire Oliver (Robespierre101) | 6 comments MAXON! How the heck is this is a real question? He's so hot and sweet. Also Aspen's kind of a douche.


message 87: by Maegan Joy (new)

Maegan Joy (mjcbooklion) | 61 comments I know this isn't the right thread to ask, but is this book worth the read?


message 88: by Kat (new)

Kat YES!! it is like the bachelor but way better. It is kinda a slow at parts.... but it is one of my favorite series.:)) i definitely recommend this book i read the selection in a couple of hours:)) READ IT:))))))


message 89: by Supernova10 (new)

Supernova10 | 4 comments Team Maxon!! Aspen just really irritates the poop out of me... Also he broke America's heart and she shouldn't have forgiven him


message 90: by Miriam (new)

Miriam | 12 comments So did Maxon he kissed Celeste and Kriss, Aspen didn't do anything to her but risk being caught by Maxon just to see her for like five minutes


message 91: by Britt (new)

Britt | 40 comments Team Maxon!!


message 92: by Kitty (new)

Kitty | 4 comments who likes aspen maxon of course


AwkwardyetAwesome | 10 comments Team Maxon


message 94: by Sammy (new)

Sammy Zechman | 62 comments Definitely Maxon...he had to earn Americas trust and feelings while Aspen just had them...I don't really know how to word that...


message 95: by Adriana (new)

Adriana Vega Aspen is boring, team Maxon!


message 96: by Samantha (new)

Samantha Fenn (sammifenn) | 8 comments Maxon Maxon Maxon


message 97: by Lynne (new)

Lynne Stringer | 137 comments Yes, I was Team Maxon from the moment he appeared. I got quite angry with America in The Elite, actually. She was so flighty going back and forth between the two all the time.


message 98: by Isabel (new)

Isabel (isadoglover) MAXON!!!!!!


message 99: by Sophie (new)

Sophie | 45 comments Team Maxon because he's Maxon I mean he's nice,polite and him and America have a lot of chemistry not saying her and Aspen don't it's just I adore Maxon and what he stand for and who he is.


message 100: by safiya (new)

safiya MAXON


back to top