Popular Amish Mystery Books

(showing 1-50 of 148)
A Plain Death (Appleseed Creek, #1) A Plain Death (Appleseed Creek, #1)
by (shelved 7 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 3.98 — 2,665 ratings — published 2012
Rate this book
Clear rating
Gone Missing (Kate Burkholder, #4) Gone Missing (Kate Burkholder, #4)
by (shelved 7 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 4.10 — 14,386 ratings — published 2011
Rate this book
Clear rating
Suspendered Sentence (An Amish Mystery, #4) Suspendered Sentence (An Amish Mystery, #4)
by (shelved 5 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 4.19 — 828 ratings — published 2015
Rate this book
Clear rating
Rate this book
Clear rating
Breaking Silence (Kate Burkholder, #3) Breaking Silence (Kate Burkholder, #3)
by (shelved 5 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 4.08 — 15,464 ratings — published 2011
Rate this book
Clear rating
Material Witness (Shipshewana Amish Mystery #3) Material Witness (Shipshewana Amish Mystery #3)
by (shelved 5 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 4.24 — 1,289 ratings — published 2012
Rate this book
Clear rating
Assaulted Pretzel (An Amish Mystery, #2) Assaulted Pretzel (An Amish Mystery, #2)
by (shelved 5 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 3.90 — 1,379 ratings — published 2013
Rate this book
Clear rating
Blueberry Cupcake Mystery (Amish Sweet Shop Mystery #1) Blueberry Cupcake Mystery (Amish Sweet Shop Mystery #1)
by (shelved 4 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 3.80 — 844 ratings — published 2016
Rate this book
Clear rating
Rate this book
Clear rating
A Churn for the Worse (An Amish Mystery, #5) A Churn for the Worse (An Amish Mystery, #5)
by (shelved 4 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 4.18 — 732 ratings — published 2016
Rate this book
Clear rating
A Plain Malice (Appleseed Creek, #4) A Plain Malice (Appleseed Creek, #4)
by (shelved 4 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 4.32 — 605 ratings — published 2014
Rate this book
Clear rating
Hearse and Buggy (An Amish Mystery, #1) Hearse and Buggy (An Amish Mystery, #1)
by (shelved 4 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 3.90 — 2,763 ratings — published 2012
Rate this book
Clear rating
A Perfect Square (Shipshewana Amish Mystery #2) A Perfect Square (Shipshewana Amish Mystery #2)
by (shelved 4 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 4.19 — 1,628 ratings — published 2012
Rate this book
Clear rating
Shunned and Dangerous (An Amish Mystery, #3) Shunned and Dangerous (An Amish Mystery, #3)
by (shelved 4 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 4.06 — 1,109 ratings — published 2014
Rate this book
Clear rating
Murder Simply Brewed (Amish Village Mystery #1) Murder Simply Brewed (Amish Village Mystery #1)
by (shelved 4 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 3.86 — 2,511 ratings — published 2014
Rate this book
Clear rating
A Plain Scandal (Appleseed Creek, #2) A Plain Scandal (Appleseed Creek, #2)
by (shelved 4 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 4.22 — 1,533 ratings — published 2013
Rate this book
Clear rating
Plain Murder (An Amish Mystery #1) Plain Murder (An Amish Mystery #1)
by (shelved 4 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 3.80 — 1,369 ratings — published 2013
Rate this book
Clear rating
A Plain Disappearance (Appleseed Creek, #3) A Plain Disappearance (Appleseed Creek, #3)
by (shelved 4 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 4.27 — 1,444 ratings — published 2013
Rate this book
Clear rating
Pray for Silence (Kate Burkholder, #2) Pray for Silence (Kate Burkholder, #2)
by (shelved 4 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 3.99 — 18,127 ratings — published 2010
Rate this book
Clear rating
Vanish in Plain Sight (The Brotherhood of the Raven #2) Vanish in Plain Sight (The Brotherhood of the Raven #2)
by (shelved 4 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 3.91 — 1,690 ratings — published 2011
Rate this book
Clear rating
Murder in Plain Sight (The Brotherhood of the Raven #1) Murder in Plain Sight (The Brotherhood of the Raven #1)
by (shelved 4 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 3.85 — 3,748 ratings — published 2011
Rate this book
Clear rating
Sworn to Silence (Kate Burkholder, #1) Sworn to Silence (Kate Burkholder, #1)
by (shelved 4 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 3.99 — 42,976 ratings — published 2009
Rate this book
Clear rating
Plain Confession (An Amish Mystery #5) Plain Confession (An Amish Mystery #5)
by (shelved 3 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 4.22 — 111 ratings — published
Rate this book
Clear rating
Plain Missing (Amish Mystery, #4) Plain Missing (Amish Mystery, #4)
by (shelved 3 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 4.25 — 204 ratings — published
Rate this book
Clear rating
Secrets of Harmony Grove Secrets of Harmony Grove (Paperback)
by (shelved 3 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 3.99 — 1,308 ratings — published 2010
Rate this book
Clear rating
Plain Dead (An Amish Mystery #3) Plain Dead (An Amish Mystery #3)
by (shelved 3 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 4.09 — 344 ratings — published 2015
Rate this book
Clear rating
Rate this book
Clear rating
Rate this book
Clear rating
Murder Tightly Knit (Amish Village Mystery #2) Murder Tightly Knit (Amish Village Mystery #2)
by (shelved 3 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 4.02 — 1,652 ratings — published 2014
Rate this book
Clear rating
The Dead Will Tell (Kate Burkholder, #6) The Dead Will Tell (Kate Burkholder, #6)
by (shelved 3 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 4.13 — 11,289 ratings — published 2014
Rate this book
Clear rating
Long Lost (Kate Burkholder, #4.5) Long Lost (Kate Burkholder, #4.5)
by (shelved 3 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 3.88 — 4,908 ratings — published 2013
Rate this book
Clear rating
Her Last Breath (Kate Burkholder, #5) Her Last Breath (Kate Burkholder, #5)
by (shelved 3 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 4.13 — 11,796 ratings — published 2013
Rate this book
Clear rating
Falling to Pieces (Shipshewana Amish Mystery #1) Falling to Pieces (Shipshewana Amish Mystery #1)
by (shelved 3 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 4.10 — 2,780 ratings — published 2011
Rate this book
Clear rating
Missing (The Secrets of Crittenden County #1) Missing (The Secrets of Crittenden County #1)
by (shelved 3 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 3.93 — 2,327 ratings — published 2012
Rate this book
Clear rating
Plain Pursuit Plain Pursuit (Paperback)
by (shelved 3 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 4.09 — 469 ratings — published 2013
Rate this book
Clear rating
Danger in Plain Sight (The Brotherhood of the Raven #3) Danger in Plain Sight (The Brotherhood of the Raven #3)
by (shelved 3 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 3.93 — 995 ratings — published 2011
Rate this book
Clear rating
Hide in Plain Sight (The Three Sisters Inn, #1) Hide in Plain Sight (The Three Sisters Inn, #1)
by (shelved 3 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 3.48 — 7,559 ratings — published 2007
Rate this book
Clear rating
Return to Grace (Home Valley, #2) Return to Grace (Home Valley, #2)
by (shelved 3 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 3.82 — 1,052 ratings — published 2012
Rate this book
Clear rating
Plain Jeopardy Plain Jeopardy (Paperback)
by (shelved 2 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 4.35 — 98 ratings — published
Rate this book
Clear rating
Premeditated Peppermint (Amish Candy Shop Mystery #3) Premeditated Peppermint (Amish Candy Shop Mystery #3)
by (shelved 2 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 0.0 — 197 ratings — published 2018
Rate this book
Clear rating
Kappy King and the Puppy Kaper (An Amish Mystery #1) Kappy King and the Puppy Kaper (An Amish Mystery #1)
by (shelved 2 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 4.28 — 756 ratings — published 2017
Rate this book
Clear rating
Down a Dark Road (Kate Burkholder, #9) Down a Dark Road (Kate Burkholder, #9)
by (shelved 2 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 4.12 — 7,175 ratings — published 2017
Rate this book
Clear rating
Lethal Licorice (Amish Candy Shop Mystery, #2) Lethal Licorice (Amish Candy Shop Mystery, #2)
by (shelved 2 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 4.31 — 1,393 ratings — published 2018
Rate this book
Clear rating
Amish Christmas Abduction (Amish Country Justice #3) Amish Christmas Abduction (Amish Country Justice #3)
by (shelved 2 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 4.40 — 130 ratings — published
Rate this book
Clear rating
Plain Retribution (Amish Country Justice #2) Plain Retribution (Amish Country Justice #2)
by (shelved 2 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 4.50 — 127 ratings — published
Rate this book
Clear rating
Plain Sanctuary Plain Sanctuary (Paperback)
by (shelved 2 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 4.19 — 103 ratings — published
Rate this book
Clear rating
Shadows of Lancaster County Shadows of Lancaster County (Paperback)
by (shelved 2 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 4.09 — 2,063 ratings — published 2009
Rate this book
Clear rating
Where Secrets Sleep (House of Secrets #1) Where Secrets Sleep (House of Secrets #1)
by (shelved 2 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 3.75 — 1,464 ratings — published 2015
Rate this book
Clear rating
Christmas Cookie Mystery (Amish Sweet Shop Mystery #2) Christmas Cookie Mystery (Amish Sweet Shop Mystery #2)
by (shelved 2 times as amish-mystery)
avg rating 4.43 — 138 ratings — published 2016
Rate this book
Clear rating
Rate this book
Clear rating


Murder Simply Brewed
1 chapters — updated May 13, 2015 06:36PM — 0 people liked it
Material Witness
1 chapters — updated May 13, 2015 06:35PM — 0 people liked it