Christina's Reviews > The Windup Girl

The Windup Girl by Paolo Bacigalupi
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Mar 09, 2010

liked it
bookshelves: henriks-books, fiction, 2011, sci-fi
Recommended to Christina by: Henrik Harksen
Read from September 28 to October 03, 2011

I like long books. I like diving into a thick book and staying there for days, getting to know the characters and the world they live in. I like to spend some time with them - which is why I don't read that many short stories and why I often prefer watching TV series rather than movies. This book is only 329 pages so it's a rather quick read. Too quick. And not just because I got through it rather a few days. Mostly because it could have used more pages to really introduce and explain the world, it's set in. I felt confused for quite a large part of the book and that's a shame.
It takes place in Bangkok, but not the Bangkok we know. This Bangkok is in a world where the foodstuff have been largely ruined. The scientific advances have been great but have unfortunately cost the world a very high price. One example is a father who wanted to please his daughter and therefore, he has a Cheshire cat made for her since she loves Alice in Wonderland. But this cat is superior to regular cats so it mates with a lot of other cats and their genes are suppressed so quickly, there's nothing but Cheshire cats. Food companies are desperately trying to find some kind of food thought to be extinct - or even better, seeds. Good ol' fashioned seeds you can actually sow and grow something real from.
In Bangkok, the Environmental Ministry have their White Shirts to try to protect the Kingdom from all the infections of the natural world. A line of work, that's not exactly popular with the Trade Ministry who of course wants to trade with the world outside Thailand.
This is also a world where war has become more commonplace, and ethnic cleanings ditto. There's a huge population of Chinese refugees living in Bangkok. Most of these are living in absolutely horrendous conditions.
Japan is on the forefront of things and have managed to create artificial people. Unfortunately - or so some think - these people came after the Cheshire cats so they are not able to reproduce and are not able to move fluidly but move kind of joltingly. Therefore, they're called Windups. Windups are not common in Thailand but some have managed to slip in, accompanying their masters but they are looked down upon.
In this confusing world, we follow several characters. An American, Anderson Lake, trying to find seeds and new foodstuffs in the streets of Bangkok. A Chinese refugee desperately trying to carve out a new life for himself after having lost everything. A Japanese Windup Girl left on the streets in Bangkok, horribly unsuited for the heat and only able to survive as a prostitute. A White Shirt, the Tiger of Bangkok, Captain Jaidee and his second in command, Kanya.
The story is being told from the point of view of all these characters, and while it add a bit to the confusion, it's also an incredible way of telling this story. So much is going on all the time. The political scene changes constantly, Trade and Environment is in a constant battle, the city of Bangkok is constantly fighting to avoid being overtaken by the ocean surrounding it.
This also means, that this is not a gentle book. Not only have people had very tough lives with devastating losses before we even meet them, they also have those lives in this book. Particularly Emiko, the Windup Girl, the book's title character. Emiko has a harder life than most. Just because she's a Windup, it doesn't mean she doesn't feel. She feels a lot - mostly hot, but also other feelings. She's being abused daily in the worst way by someone who despises her and has no one to lean on.
Everything changes of course, as these person's lives interfere more and more. And as the world blows up in their faces.
I had a hard time writing this review. When I finished reading it, I thought it was a 4 stars read. But now it's been a little while and although I really liked it when reading it but afterwards, it hasn't left much of an impression on me. And I've had the hardest time writing this review. And not just because I accidentally closed down the window I was writing in it, so it all disappeared. I'm not sure why this is since I got really caught up in this while reading it and it was so exciting when things really started happening. I think a lot of my issues with this book are connected to the confusion I felt and then we're back with the length of this one. This would have benefitted from maybe 100 pages more.
2 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Windup Girl.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

09/28 page 21
6.0% "Confusing so far."
09/29 page 36
10.0% "Poor Emiko, the windup girl."
09/29 page 86
24.0% "Still a bit confused by this. 4 different POVs. A Bangkok and a world very different from ours."
09/30 page 101
28.0% "Still not quite sure what I think about this one."
09/30 page 117
32.0% "I really like - and feel for - the windup girl."
10/01 page 153
42.0% "Liking this more and more."
10/02 page 207
58.0% "Okay, the action has started for real!"
10/02 page 228
64.0% "Some of the characters reveal new sides. I'm confused about a fee things though: did Jaidee know? And what happened to Chaya?"
10/02 page 274
76.0% "Pretty darn exciting now!"
10/03 page 317
88.0% "Some scary scenes as the tanks and the war megodonts move through the city of Bangkok. And I suddenly understood why Emiko's former owned said he was doing her a favor when he left her on the streets and didn't take her with him. (cf. p. 299)"
01/11 marked as: read
show 2 hidden updates…

Comments (showing 1-5)

dateUp arrow    newest »

Henrik Starting to get the hang of the story?

Christina Yeah, I think so.

message 3: by Lisa (new) - added it

Lisa Vegan Really interesting review, Christina.

Henrik Another fine review:-) Seems you and I agree a long way on where the novel works well and where it could improve. It did leave a more lasting impression on me, though, which may explain why I ended up rating it 4 stars.

Christina Lisa - it's an really interesting book! It has flaws, definitely, but it's strengths makes it worth reading.
Henrik - I think part of the story are rather banal while other parts, particularly Emiko's story line and the whole setting of the book, are really fresh and original. But after a few days, not much of it really stayed with me. I think the author is one to watch, though.

back to top