Betsy's Reviews > Foundling

Foundling by D.M. Cornish
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Nov 11, 2007

really liked it
Read in December, 2007

By this point I think the nation's readers of children's fantasy novels have hit a kind of boredom plateau. You get a new fantasy on your desk and you have to tick off the requirements. Alternate world? Orphaned hero or heroine? School for the extraordinary? To a certain extent, a lot of these tried and true stand-bys are essential to a good book. There's a reason they exist, after all. But after reading a bunch of them, reviewers like myself get a little jaded. Kids think everything's new, so they're more inclined to love the newest sparkly cover that comes down the pike. For us, finding something that is truly original and truly unique is almost impossible. I mean, it's not as if Harry Potter was the first boy to go to wizarding school even. So imagine my surprise when I encountered a truly rare and amazing fantasy world. A place so thoroughly thought out, planned, meticulously recorded, and imagined that it feels less like a fantasy novel and more like the factual memoirs of an alternate world. I'm not exaggerating here. Aussie D.M. Cornish has spent (according to his bookflap) "the last thirteen years bringing the Half-Continent to life." The result is a book that feels like the first true successor to Tolkien I've ever found.

His name is Rossamund Bookchild. Bookchild because he is an orphan raised by a Marine Society and given the same last name of all the children there. Rossamund, normally a girl's name, because that was the name pinned to him when he was left on the steps as a babe. Growing up reading exciting pamphlets recounting daring deeds, Rossamund has a dream of someday becoming a sailor (or vinegaroon) on the vinegar seas where high adventure awaits. He dreams of someday seeing the vicious monsters that constantly do battle with man around the country and must always be kept at bay. Yet instead of a glorious life on the seas, Rossamund is told that he is to be apprenticed as a lamplighter, lighting the roads of the Half-Continent. It's a disappointing blow, but on the way to his new job Rossamund hops the wrong boat and finds himself facing monsters, rever-men, teratologists, bogles, leers, wits, and a host of other characters and dangers. Moreover, has Rossamund always been told the truth about the monsters people fight, or is there more to some bogles than meets the eye?

Normally when an author wants to introduce you to a new fantasy world, the hero is a kid from our mundane universe who is pushed through extraordinary circumstances into a peculiar realm. Rossamund, however, inclines far more closely to the Bilbo Baggins mode of adventuring. He has led a nice sequestered life in Madame Opera's Estimable Marine Society and his journey turns out to be very much a series of adventures, both good an ill, that are new to him simply because he has only read about the wider world and has not yet lived in it. Yes. Fine. Our hero is an orphan as per a million fantasy novels before. But never have I had such a clear sense that a character's parentage is not the point of the series. Phew!

Really, Rossamund is a great hero. Like Taran in Lloyd Alexander's The Black Cauldron series he yearns for adventure. But unlike Taran he's not a brash young man with a braggart's tongue and a desire to enter battle. Rossamund seems to want adventure without wanting to ever hold a weapon in his hands. He's a rather gentle kid. He'd sooner say nothing than say the wrong thing, a tendency that causes the people around him to open up unexpectedly. Which, from a narrative perspective, is keen. Rossamund's growth in this book is not complete, a fact noticed by the sweet bogle that considers telling him the secret of his name. Still, you have confidence in this hero. He is kind and good and that goes a long way when you have to spend a whole book with him.

Another difference from your normal run-of-the-mill fantasy is Cornish's use of female characters. Strong female characters, that is. At first I figured that this would be yet another boy-boy-boy book. But then you meet the character of Europe and it's all up in the air. Europe is the fighting fulgar that meets Rossamund early in his travels and inspires both his respect and his disgust. She kills monsters for a living, which wouldn't be so bad if the first one Rossamund encounters with her weren't such a sweet but stupid fellow. Her moral complexity mixes with a personality that has enough pep and zazz to keep you guessing about her intentions for most of the book. Fighting women in fantasy novels tend to have no sense of humor, but Europe is quite the wit (inside joke) when her innards aren't trying to reject her new organs.

Maybe it's Cornish's Aussie roots, but he has a knack for language that exceeds the norm. His descriptions are nice and no question, but dialogue seems to be his bread and butter. "Don't give me a reason to remember yer name any further, me darlin' chiffer-chaffer." Or calling someone a "prattling hackmillion". That kind of thing. His easy-going language will strike you as almost cockney at first, but closer inspection of the words and phrases used put a very particular spin on the entire affair. His talent for names is nothing to scoff at either. You'll read titles like Sloughscab, Poundinch, Europe, and Licurius, which pour out of the author like mad wild things.

Regarding the sheer complexity of this world, here is my thinking: Cornish is so invested in this Half-Continent he has created, and so clear on every minute and tiny detail involved that you can't help but be swept up in the logic of it all. Even more amazing though is that Cornish describes everyday realities of the realm without making them sound anything but simultaneously routine AND amazing. Everything we learn about Rossamund's world is extraordinary, but Cornish has it so well-planned that it almost feels routine and logical. Not in the boring sense, of course.

Standing at a handsome 434 pages, this book may appear a bit daunting to your average reader. So you can well imagine my amazement when I hit page 312 and found the story to be over. Finito, as it were. The next 122 pages consisted of an elaborate and enticing Explicarium "Being a glossary of terms and explanations including Appendices". Sounds simple, right? Well, it begins with a explanation of pronunciations for certain terms in this book. Then an explanation of italics. And then a list of faux sources used to research this book (which is always fun). The glossary is extensive and you can basically learn quite a lot about the Haacobin Empire in which Rossamund lives, including history, characters, and different kinds of boats if you've an inclination to do so. Of course, at the same time you'll run across definitions like "muck hill: pile of poo", so make no assumptions. The glossary is followed by a guide to the 16-month calendar of the half-continent, detailed drawings of different occupations and what they wear, every boat from a gun-drudge to a main-sovereign, and enlargements of the Half-Continent terrain that is the most frightening and magnificent map I've ever seen in a work of fiction. Stranger still, all the pictures in this book (and there are many) were drawn by the author himself. Aye, me.

The age level is an interesting question here. Our hero is about fourteen, which puts this book squarely in the middle grade/YA realm. There is some violence (one nasty fellow meets his end by getting eaten alive) but it tends to go quickly. For the most part, I'd say that any kid who could handle the Harry Potter books, the The Amulet of Samarkand series, or any of the The Lord of the Rings would definitely enjoy this series and get into it.

But who thinks of these things? Who imagines a world where people bathe their eyes in chemicals to gain unnatural powers? Or who undergo dangerous surgeries to get superhuman abilities? Who imagines something as tiny and delicate as a spoor, a small shape that is blue or white and burned into the skin to denote a person's occupation? D.M. Cornish, obviously. Basically I just recommend this to anyone who wants something wholly new and never seen before. Cornish's imagination will fuel fans for decades to come, should they find this book. Consider it a little-known gem that you'll end up sucked into. Amazing stuff.

Ages 11 and up.
54 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Foundling.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

06/21/2016 marked as: read

Comments (showing 1-12 of 12) (12 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Dracolibris This review was excellent. Most excellent indeed. :-)
When I am trying to "sell" bored or voracious fantasy readers on this book, which I do as often as I see it on the shelf, I show them that incredible glossary. I can tell if I have them hooked by whether or not their eyes get wide and their hands begin reaching out for it, or their eyes just glaze over. LOL. Right there and then I know if I have a light fantasy fan or a serious reader who wants to fully immerse themselves in a new world.

I can not wait for the sequels.

message 2: by Trevor (new)

Trevor Did you by any chance enter into the Goodreads review contest? Man, this is one of the most comprehensive, and interesting reviews I've read around here (or anywhere else, for that matter). I can't wait to get to work and break this book out - I was doing some fantasy reader's advisory yesterday and the kid basically agreed with you, saying, "I love fantasy, but I'm kinda bored with stuff that's been out lately". He went on to explain to me that he feels authors are writing too many knock-offs. I hope this guy hasn't yet read Monster Blood Tattoo! I think he'll dig this. Thanks!

Betsy There's a Goodreads review contest? I should inspect that further. Thanks for liking what I wrote, guys! It's a book that definitely deserves more attention. I'm currently hooked on #2 and it's, oddly enough, even better than the first.

Dracolibris You're very welcome. :-)

Ooo, the second one is already out? Well, to be released May 1st- that's close enough for me.
*Rushes off to add it to the next book order*

message 5: by JM (last edited Apr 20, 2008 08:52PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

JM But never have I had such a clear sense that a character's parentage is not the point of the series.

I had the impression from the first book that his parentage was going to be hugely significant, actually ... with the pet theory that Europe is his mother, but I'll settle for any interesting explanation. I've not had a chance to read Book 2 yet, so I know nothing.

I agree that the world is entirely awesome; I hadn't heard that he spent so many years imagining it. I think I would love this book simply for the names. Madam Opera's Estimable Marine Society for Foundling Boys and Girls - so much love.

Betsy Well, as it turned out I couldn't have been more wrong about his parentage. Heck, the whole series may swing on it. Color me horribly, entirely wrong.

Diane I figured out something was VERY different about this boy early on, and the second novel has confirmed my suspicions. It's a remarkable series.

Betsy Whereas I am such an oblivious reader that it never even occurred to me until it was revealed. And even then, I did NOT see where it was going. Wowzah!

Diane In the first book there was a monster hunting dog that reacted strongly against him that tipped me off. Then his reaction to Europe's treacle was another clue, as well as his not wanting to get a tattoo, and his upset about the killing of the big monster. And Lamplighter made it much more obvious to the point where I was kind of frustrated that he didn't guess. But I have no idea where it's all going to lead from here, and, in fact, if it's actually what I think it is.

Robert Carter There's a reason why Ms. Bird's review is so good, but I'll leave that as an exercise for the reader.

(from a Betsy Bird fan)

Hilarie This is a great review!

message 12: by Sherry (new)

Sherry This book is not available on kindle (sad face). Looks like I will have to take a trip to the book store.

back to top