Andy's Reviews > On the Incarnation
On the Incarnation
by Athanasius of Alexandria, C.S. Lewis , Sister Penelope Lawson
by Athanasius of Alexandria, C.S. Lewis , Sister Penelope Lawson
I read this book with others in a lunchtime discussion group. Our meetings were led by a local Orthodox minister.
This book, at first glance, is easier to read than you might expect. The sentences (a translation from Greek) are in simple structures. The vocabulary is fairly ordinary, and the chapters are short - but the content goes much, much deeper.
This book is a logical, reasoned proof for the incarnation of the Creator God in the person of Jesus Christ. Athanasius moves through the objections against Christ as the son of God systematically, de-constructing poor arguments and burning straw men. This book will make you think. The more comfortable you are with logic, the better.
This is not a book that will necessarily have you flipping through a Bible. Because Athanasius was creating an argument for people, mostly, that did not believe in the Bible as a credible source he builds his arguments (in some chapters more than others) without using much of the Scripture.
The Orthodox minister who led my group was a wealth of encyclopedic information about the culture of Athanasius. I have no doubt this greatly enriched my reading experience. If you don't have someone like this at your disposal I would think having a text about the ancient Greco-Roman culture that you can easily reference would be handy. Occasionally Athanasius references items or beliefs current to his time that would be obscure to the average reader today.
I highly recommend reading this if you like to think, and if you like to be challenged. It's a well-thought argument. If you're a believer you'll find it enriching. If you're a non-believer you might look for holes in his argument, or who knows, maybe be swayed by it. It's a classic either way.
This book, at first glance, is easier to read than you might expect. The sentences (a translation from Greek) are in simple structures. The vocabulary is fairly ordinary, and the chapters are short - but the content goes much, much deeper.
This book is a logical, reasoned proof for the incarnation of the Creator God in the person of Jesus Christ. Athanasius moves through the objections against Christ as the son of God systematically, de-constructing poor arguments and burning straw men. This book will make you think. The more comfortable you are with logic, the better.
This is not a book that will necessarily have you flipping through a Bible. Because Athanasius was creating an argument for people, mostly, that did not believe in the Bible as a credible source he builds his arguments (in some chapters more than others) without using much of the Scripture.
The Orthodox minister who led my group was a wealth of encyclopedic information about the culture of Athanasius. I have no doubt this greatly enriched my reading experience. If you don't have someone like this at your disposal I would think having a text about the ancient Greco-Roman culture that you can easily reference would be handy. Occasionally Athanasius references items or beliefs current to his time that would be obscure to the average reader today.
I highly recommend reading this if you like to think, and if you like to be challenged. It's a well-thought argument. If you're a believer you'll find it enriching. If you're a non-believer you might look for holes in his argument, or who knows, maybe be swayed by it. It's a classic either way.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
On the Incarnation.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
| 07/01/2010 | page 120 |
|
100.0% | "Still slowly working through this in a discussion group. Great stuff." |
Comments (showing 1-9 of 9) (9 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Rachel
(new)
Feb 04, 2010 11:21AM
Athanasius!!
reply
|
flag
*
I'm really enjoying this book. A group of us at work are being lead through it by a local Fr. in the Eastern Orthodox Church. The discussions are really challenging me. Some of the most profound writing I've read in a long time.
Andrew, great to see your love for the book. I am curious if you have read anymore Eastern Orthodox material after encountering St. Athanasios?
Christian wrote: "Andrew, great to see your love for the book. I am curious if you have read anymore Eastern Orthodox material after encountering St. Athanasios?" I haven't yet. Do you have a recommendation? The group I read this with is no longer together, which is too bad . . . It was such a great experience to be led through this book with an Orthodox minister!
Yes, I have tons of recommendations, many can be found on my good reads Orthodox self. It depends if you want ancient or modern, but everything I have read has generally been fantastic, after reading Athanasios I began to ask more questions about the Eastern Church. Last year I was baptized into the Greek Orthodox Church. This experience within the Orthodox Church has brought new understanding to Athanasius. The best I can describe it is the theology is accessible in the book but you can experience that theology in the Orthodox Church.My recommendations are:
Modern:
Suprised by Christ - James Bernstein
Wounded by Love - Elder Porphyrios
Ancient:
On the Holy Spirit - St Basil
Against Heresies - St. Irenaeus
Sayings of the Desert Fathers
You could find all of those on my orthodox self. Also look up your local Greek, OCA, Russian, Antiochan, Romanian, or Serbian Orthodox Church they often will have inquirer classes that discuss such matters of theology and they in my experience always are enlightening. Good luck. Let me know if you come across anything intriguing.
OK I cheated and "read" the Athanaeus portion via audio book since there is so little time. It is a powerhouse of logic and Christology. I was inspired to read it after being exposed to Marcus Peter Johnson, George Dragas and Thomas F Torrance, the latter two being steeped in Patristics. One should also check out Gregory of Nazianzus. Athanaeus is the core of the best of Patristic writers on the doctrine of Christ.
