Christy's Reviews > No Talking

No Talking by Andrew Clements
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Jan 19, 2010

it was amazing

If No Talking hadn't been on the Oregon Battle of the Books list, I wouldn't have read it. Imagine my surprise. A 5-star book out of the blue... or rather, out of upper-elementary aged realistic fiction without a hint of high drama - no war, no death, no troubled homes. It's really a simple plot: Loquacious fifth-grader Dave Packer, inspired by Mahatma Ghandi, decides to stop talking for a full day. The incessant jabber of fifth-grade girls, however, thwarts his plan and draws the whole grade into a 48-hour "No Talking" boy-girl challenge. I mean, how good can that book be? Remarkable, as it turns out.

For starters, the story was well enough explained that my 2nd-grader could follow it, and timed so well an hour flew by as I read. Clements presented authentic adults (teachers and principal), and captured the vision of teetering-on-the-edge-of-growning-up fifth-graders marvelously. In the end, a beautiful moment of human triumph, as glorious in an elementary school scale, as Ghandi's.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read No Talking.
Sign In »

No comments have been added yet.