Wealhtheow's Reviews > Skin Trade

Skin Trade by Laurell K. Hamilton
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Jan 05, 2010

it was ok
bookshelves: paranormal_romance, urban-fantasy, fantasy
Recommended for: fans of the early Anita Blake
Read in January, 2010

Hamilton burst into my awareness with Guilty Pleasures, a book that introduced us to a world where vampires were legal citizens, raising the dead was a viable career, and small women who collected penguin-themed tchotchkes could nevertheless be respected police consultants. Anita Blake was a young woman who just wanted to do the right thing, and although she could not deny her attraction to the sensuous vampire Jean-Claude (ahahahahahahah), she never let her personal life interfere with her job. The books were a little cheesy, but the plots were good and Anita's inner monologue was entertaining. But every book or so, Hamilton would introduce another magic power and another love interest--and by book 10, Anita had become the most Mary-Sueish Mary-Sue that ever Mary-Sued. Reading about her just wasn't fun anymore, and the plots themselves had turned from gorey police procedurals into excuses for increasingly shameless porn.

But. I just couldn't stay away. Hamilton was the first paranormal romance I ever read, and to my mind, the main progenitor of the genre. I wanted to know if she'd managed to pull herself from the brink of complete un-readability. And you know what? She actually did. Sure, Anita is still insanely overpowered. (She is the strongest necromancer ever, has vampiric strength, is psychic, has the strongest shields anyone has ever seen, can control at least five different breeds of were, has the most vampire kills in the world, plus has some sort of godlike "ardeur" power that makes her feed off of people's anger or arousal. And I'm probably forgetting a power or two.) And yes, Anita has so many beautiful supernatural boyfriends that I'm pretty sure she herself can't tell them apart. And ok, most of this book is just everyone talking to her about how she's so strong and badass and bold and sexy. And, it must be said, Hamilton has gotten increasingly awful with consent--Anita has sex with a mind-controlled sixteen year old, and in the climax of the book is basically blackmailed into sex. It's sketchy at best.

But there's a plot! And Edward's back! None of her boyfriends spend more than a few pages on-screen! Anita spends a lot of time talking about weapons and fictional laws about vampire crimes! The series has not returned to its glory days, but it's definitely gotten better since I last read it. And, though I take issue with Hamilton's views on what counts as sex, plot, and relatable characters, this was an enthralling book. Once I started it, I didn't put it down till I was done.
14 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Skin Trade.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

11/04 marked as: read

Comments (showing 1-8 of 8) (8 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Eh?Eh! (new)

Eh?Eh! Is this book 15? I gave up around book 5 but nice to know she circles back. I like your recap!

Wealhtheow Insanely enough, this is number SEVENTEEN in the Anita Blake series, and it looks like she has two more being published this year. Prolific! I'm impressed that you gave up around 5--I kept going back to her and ended up reading far too many books worth of badly edited porn and self-insert fanfic.

message 3: by Eh?Eh! (new)

Eh?Eh! Sheesh! I guess she's supplying for the demand.

I confess, this series was the first paranormal romance I ever read, also, so I ended up skimming bits of a few more in the library/bookstore to confirm she had turned a corner (maybe it would be more appropriate to say she had swung that crop?) after book 3.

Hah, nice description: badly edited porn and self-insert fanfic.

Wealhtheow Mary-Suerotica?

message 5: by Eh?Eh! (new)

Eh?Eh! Hah! It fits.

"Mary-Sue" seems to be the term used for a female character that is written so badly it's flat, paper, 2-D. I saw it being used frequently in Twilight reviews in reference to Bella.

Wealhtheow Oh yes, I know--I was just trying to create a portmanteau. And failing, le sob.

message 7: by Eh?Eh! (new)

Eh?Eh! Oops! No no!! Success! (and I learned a new word - portmanteau, nice)

Sylence Also this book ended kind of lametasticly. I mean.. seriously? That was it?

back to top