Angie's Reviews > Going Too Far

Going Too Far by Jennifer Echols
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review

liked it
bookshelves: good-uns, ya

I picked up Jennifer Echols' GOING TOO FAR on the recommendation of the Ana-half of The Book Smugglers. Ana is good peeps and pretty much never steers me wrong. She said she stayed up into the wee hours of the night reading this one and what do ya know? I did, too! It's just that it was my birthday eve and I was feeling like being incredibly cozy and wanted something sweet and absorbing. This book is both. I read it in one sitting and pretty much had to know what happened before I could sleep. The funny thing was my dreams had an interesting musical score behind them that night. Full of songs about love and loss. Particularly "Re: Stacks" by Bon Iver. Over and over again in my head, this one seemed to fit Meg and John so well.

Stuck in Nowhere, Alabama, Meg MacPherson is counting down the hours until she can move away to college. And it doesn't even matter that she's only going just a few miles down the road to Birmingham. She'll still be away from her hometown, away from her parents, and away from her thankless (and payless) job at their 24-hour breakfast greasy spoon--Eggstra! Eggstra! *snort* For the last few years Meg has comfortably occupied the position of town Bad Girl, complete with rapidly changing hair color (currently blue) and revolving door of lousy boyfriends (seriously, her latest makes Charlie Sheen look like a real catch). One night up on the railroad bridge, Meg and three compatriots have the misfortune to be caught, drunk and disorderly, by the local cops. For their punishment, they each have to spend a week riding with one of the emergency personnel that had to come out after them that night. Meg pulls the cop who chewed her out that night--Officer After--a 19-year-old hometown boy whose only ambition in life appears to be busting the butts of errant high schoolers and who never dreams of leaving. Over the course of the next five days, Meg and Officer After learn a few things about each other that complicate both of their long-term plans.

At first these two seem like fairly straightforward stereotypes. Bad Girl meets Straight Shooter. Sparring and romance ensue. In that order. But then, just as you're prepared to get bored, things get interesting. Meg shows herself to be quite a bit more layered than initially expected. She's clearly got several hideous incidents in her past which make it, among other things, difficult to be in confined spaces. Handcuffs or prison bars, for example, assume nightmarish proportions for Meg. And she has a charming habit of voicing her thoughts and emotions. Every time she blurted out, "I am full of fear," I laughed and loved her more. Except when she really was. And had good reason to be. Then I was full of fear for her and I couldn't stop turning the pages. John is as layered as Meg, only it comes out more slowly as Meg herself discovers it. And it doesn't all come out in the right order, which is frustrating for all concerned. But they're both so likable, you'll go along for the ride. My favorite bit about this story is that in the end, when the inevitable unforgivable act occurs, Meg squares her shoulders and fixes things. She doesn't dissolve in her despair but rather has a good cry and then goes about making reparation and salvaging what she can. I always liked her, but that's when I admired her. Recommended for fans of Simone Elkeles' Perfect Chemistry, Laura Wiess' Such a Pretty Girl, and for when you're looking for a light, swallow-in-a-single-gulp read.
6 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Going Too Far.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Started Reading
August 1, 2009 – Finished Reading
August 17, 2009 – Shelved
August 17, 2009 – Shelved as: good-uns
April 3, 2012 – Shelved as: ya

Comments Showing 1-9 of 9 (9 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Samantha So glad you liked it too! Now you can see why I finished it so quickly, it really is a "single-gulp" read, lol! :D

Also....Happy Belated Birthday!!!

Angie Aw, thanks Samantha! It was a good birthday and fun to ring in by reading this book. :)

message 3: by Jolie (new)

Jolie While on my recent trip with my daughter, I found myself with lovely reading time after she was asleep (and on the plane, too!). Decided to give this a try and enjoyed enough to download her book, Major Crush, as well for the next night. It was a weekend of YA reading, and lots of fun. (Also made it through Lisa McMann's Wake and Fade, and Sarah Dessen's The Truth About Forever. Now settled into Brigg's Hunting Ground...)

Angie Jolie, that sounds like a lovely trip. :) I'm glad you liked this one. Should I look up Major Crush, then? I love Wake and Fade. I'm not as big a Dessen fan for some reason. I keep wanting to try another one to see and am not sure which one I should try. Should I give The Truth About Forever a go?

I just finished Hunting Ground last night! Liked it quite a bit.

message 5: by Jolie (new)

Jolie Major Crush was definitely a teen romance, and a bit lighter all the way through than Going Too Far. I was never a part of a marching band, but my mom was a majorette in high school, and so I enjoyed a tiny window into that experience.

I've never read any other Dessen, so I can't speak to any of her other titles. A few young women I know encouraged me to try this one. The Truth About Forever felt a little like Echols' books, actually-- a girl who is dealing with a personal tragedy, but instead of acting out like Meg, she tries to live an ordered, "perfect," life. And there's a lovely boy with a tragic past to help her through... The musings on the meanings of "forever" began to feel a little forced by the end of the book, but I certainly enjoyed it.

Angie Lol. My mother was in marching band all through high school and college. I refused when it came my turn but I imagine I'd get a kick out of it all the same.

Lovely boy w/ tragic past...sounds like I should give it a go. ;)

Have you read Perfect Chemistry? If not, next time you're in the mood for some teen romance I highly recommend it.

Holly Angie, I second The Truth About Forever. It's been awhile, but I really liked it when I read it. It was my first and so far only Dessen read. I haven't wanted to read anything else because I'm afraid (as many tell me) that it's their favorite and her best book.

message 8: by Jen (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jen I just bought this book and can't wait to read it! But the main reason I'm writing this is because I love love LOVE Bon Iver. Re: Stacks is one of my favorite songs :)

Angie Jen, awesome! That song is incredible, isn't it?

back to top