Markus's Reviews > Neither Here nor There: Travels in Europe

Neither Here nor There by Bill Bryson
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
39193
's review

did not like it
bookshelves: non-fiction

Bryson at his worst. He is the whining American tourist he claims to detest. Meandering through a dozen or so european countries, he manages to complain about virtually every hotel accomodation. And for christ sake Bill, put a freakin map in your book. I'm not totally ignorant when it comes to european geography but if youre gonna write about travelling hundreds of miles every other day, i'd like to glance at the route with out having to bust out my world atlas.
After Shorthistoryof nearly everything i was so high on him, now this...
128 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Neither Here nor There.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Started Reading
September 1, 2007 – Finished Reading
September 14, 2007 – Shelved
September 14, 2007 – Shelved as: non-fiction

Comments Showing 1-25 of 25 (25 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Greg (new)

Greg Staddon And how wonderful this book would be if he had only stayed in 5-star extravagance and praised every second of it.
How much more useful to us if he had only included a map of mainland Europe!
One-star? Pathetic.


Markus a picture is worth 1000 words. even 1000 shitty ones.


Lisa Now who's whining?


Markus Me


Markus any more compelling questions?


Leelo Absolutely agree about the whining, it did get annoying.


Ellen The whining was part of the fun for me. Anyone ever heard of tongue-in-cheek?


Deirdre I totally agree with Markus. I found it snarky, not funny. I have lived in Europe as an American and yet Bryson's take on it was totally alien to me. It was my first Bryson book so I will have to pay more attention to the reviews before I pick another.


message 9: by Liz (new)

Liz D., I haven't read this one but I like Bryson a lot. A Short History of Nearly Everything and Mother Tongue are both really good. I know he's lived in England for something like 30 years so maybe like Ellen said, he was going for tongue in cheek but it didn't come across?


Ilona Vellekoop Totally disagree. i think it is one of the funniest books I have ever read and a feast of recognition. "Whining"??? I guess you missed the point and probably have another sense of humor. As a European I love it.


Ilona Vellekoop And it definitely was all tongue in cheek with a lot of self mockery.


Mr. Fluffynson I disagree completely. The whining was the best ingredient of the book. I do not understand how the book would be any good if he just described everything as amazing and pretty and blahblah. He also visited my country and I found that chapter hilarious! But honestly... a map of Europe?


Markus i love maps


Peggy Graves Google maps.


message 15: by Phil (new) - rated it 2 stars

Phil Couldn't agree more!


Anja247 Especially the first half was a litany of complaints. The book got better towards the end.


message 17: by Shelley (new)

Shelley Odell i was disagreeing with you up until the Germany part, for heaven's sake Bill, its 1991(2017 now) jeez the war is over the Germans lost, now they're successful again, get over it!


Ilona Vellekoop Mr. Fluffynson wrote: "I disagree completely. The whining was the best ingredient of the book. I do not understand how the book would be any good if he just described everything as amazing and pretty and blahblah. He als..."

Yeah, he visited my country also and it was hilarious. Also the descriptions of all other countries he visited totally match my experiences and make me love my own memories more. He is not whining he is the funniest travel writer, not a travel guide.


message 19: by Doug (new) - rated it 4 stars

Doug Anybody who whinges and whines about this doesn't understand Bryson


message 20: by Mark (new) - rated it 5 stars

Mark I took it more as sarcasm, and it made me laugh.


Joost Sarcasm is a language spoken and understood by not too many Americans.


Michael Crosbie I actually found it boring when he was going on and on about how much he loved Italy. He balanced out his grievances and his loves of places extremely well , I think his time in Denmark highlights this.


Barbara Nutting I got out my paper world map to follow his trek!


Humble Diane This was not one of Bryson's better books. The writing was lazy; his self-deprecation amusing at first, but tiring with it's repetitiveness. His attempts to make comical observations were sometimes accurate, other times insulting with a hyberbole of inaccuracy.
Bryson was four years ahead of me at the same high school; I understand his humour and references from his youth. I also empathize with his love for Europe, having lived in Ireland for the past 30 years and visited many of the cities on Bryson's checklist. This book was first published in 1992; Europe has changed much in almost 30 years. But, in the many times I've visited various parts of Sweden, never have I seen litter or people publicly urinating and vomiting on the streets. Nearly everywhere is expensive in Europe to travel. His complaints and praises are repetitive, just different settings throughout the book.
Bryson, however, leads the weary reader through his trail of dribble with breadcrumbs of interesting historical anecdotes or economical facts about a particular place. When he shares his vast pool of knowledge from years of research and reading with his educated wit is when Bryson shines.


Naren I would have to agree. I love Bryson usually but this was disappointing.


back to top