Fionnuala's Reviews > Confessions of an English Opium Eater
Confessions of an English Opium Eater
by
by
Fionnuala's review
bookshelves: one-book-leads-to-another, proust-and-related, review-may-contain-comic-content, metamorphosis, non-fiction
May 02, 2013
bookshelves: one-book-leads-to-another, proust-and-related, review-may-contain-comic-content, metamorphosis, non-fiction
The Opium Eaters, a comedy, based on the sleeping habits of Thomas de Quincey and Marcel Proust.
Characters:
Marcel Proust
Thomas de Quincey
The curtain goes up on a bedroom scene. Two of the walls are cork-lined, the third is a bare stone wall roughly coated with Roman cement. In the angle of the two cork-lined walls is a narrow wrought-iron bedstead covered with an eiderdown quilt and beside it, a night-table on which lie books, papers, and a little brass bell.
Against the stone wall there is a brass bedstead piled high with blankets, and beside it a night-table on which lie books, papers, and a little gold bottle.
There is someone lying on each of the beds.
Marcel Proust:
Longtemps, je me suis couché de bonne heure...
(Propping himself on his elbow, he becomes aware of the audience and immediately reaches for the bell which he rings impatiently while calling out for his servant to come and close the curtains):
Françoise, Françoise, il faut fermer les rideaux - il y a une foule immense devant la fenêtre!
Thomas de Quincey, (sitting up in his bed angrily):
My dear sir, desist immediately from your tintinnabulous propensities. These velvet drapes will be closed at the end of the scene and not before, so you are wasting your breath, which I see you have little enough of, in calling for it to be done ahead of time. And indeed your feeble efforts are doubly futile since the character you call for is not even in the play, and the people you speak of are only the audience, such a harmless group that is in no way to be feared, unlike the horrible hoards who people my own dreams; and can I caution you, dear sir, for I perceive you to be something of a valetudinarian, against becoming a confirmed heautontimourousmenos...
Marcel Proust, (rubbing his eyes):
Bougre! Qui est-ce qui me lance des propos incompréhensibles plein de mots intérminables et de phrases impénétrables?
T de Q, (swinging his legs over the side of the bed):
Ah, you wonder who addresses you in such elaborately constructed language? Allow me to introduce myself.
(He walks to the centre of the stage)
I am Thomas de Quincey and you and I are characters in a play, and please note, my dear sir, that this play is in English, and therefore oblige us by refraining from any outbursts à la française henceforth. I might remind you also that this play is being staged in the year of our Lord, 2013 to mark the bicentenary of the events contained in one of the chapters of the most famous of my works, the essay with the much disputed title among my peers of 'Confessions', yes, my dear sir, not a sensational 'Diary of an Addict', but the humble Confessions of an English Opium Eater, and a work furthermore in which my contemporaries believed I was being too confidential and too communicative..
MP, (rising from his bed to look at a calendar hanging on the wall):
But if this is indeed the year 2013, then this play is surely meant to mark the centenary of the publication of my most famous work, my 'Recherche', that single work on which I devoted the labour of my whole life, and had dedicated my intellect, blossoms and fruits, to the slow and elaborate toil of constructing it...
T de Q, (holding up a document):
I think that you are on the wrong page of the script, my dear sir, those are in fact my lines, taken directly from page 175 of the 'Confessions', referring to my own life’s work, begun upon too great a scale for the resources of the architect alas, and which because of the very subject of this play, was likely to stand as a memorial of hopes defeated, of baffled efforts, of materials uselessly accumulated; of foundations laid that were never to support a super-structure, of the grief and the ruin of the architect.
MP, (moving towards the front of the stage and speaking directly to the audience):
Strange how these words of his recall my own fears and doubts concerning the completion and future acclaim of the 'Recherche', although I always subscribed to the belief that true works of art are slow to receive their full recognition, and must wait for a period when the author himself will have crumpled to dust. This centenary celebration, and your devoted presence proves me right.
(He nibbles on the corner of his moustache and mumbles to himself): Where are the Bergottes and the Blochs? All gone and forgotten while I alone have survived to become the keystone of modern literature...
T de Q, (lying down again upon his bed):
But alas, opium had a palsying effect on my intellectual faculties...
MP, (walking across to T’s bedside table, picking up the gold bottle and sniffing its contents):
I too have often reflected on the kinds of sleep induced by the multiple extracts of ether, of valerian, of opium...
T de Q, (closing his eyes):
I must now pass to what is the main subject of these confessions, to the history of what took place in my dreams. At night, when I lay in my bed, vast processions passed along in mournful pomp; friezes of never-ending stories, that to my feelings were as sad and as solemn as if they were stories drawn from times before Oedipus or Priam, before Tyre, before Memphis.
MP, (massaging his temples):
I feel something quiver in me, shift, try to rise, the glimmer of a visual memory, the elusive eddying of stirred-up colours...a magic lantern full of impalpable iridescences, multicoloured apparitions where legends are depicted as in a wavering, momentary stained-glass window...
T de Q, (in a dreamy voice):
A theatre seemed suddenly opened and lighted up within my brain, which presented nightly spectacles of more than earthly splendour. As the creative state of the eye increased, a sympathy seemed to arise between the waking and the dreaming states of the brain in one point, that whatsoever I happened to call up and to trace by a voluntary act upon the darkness was very apt to transfer itself to my dreams...
MP, (going back to sit on the side of his bed):
Yes, what one has meant to do during the day, one accomplishes only in one’s dreams, that is to say after it has been distorted by sleep into following another line than one would have chosen when awake. The same story branches off and has a different ending.
T de Q:
All this and other changes in my dreams were accompanied by deep-seated anxiety and gloomy melancholy, such as wholly incommunicable by words...
MP, (lying down):
But my sadness was only increased by those multi-coloured apparitions of the lantern..
T de Q:
The sense of space, and in the end the sense of time, were both powerfully affected. Buildings, landscapes, &c., were exhibited in proportions so vastly as the bodily eye is not fitted to receive....
MP, (closing his eyes):
In Combray, I moved through the church...a space with, so to speak, four dimensions - the fourth being Time - extending over the centuries...
T de Q:
The minutist incidents of childhood, or forgotten scenes of later years, were often revived...
MP:
I have many pictures preserved by my memory of what Combray was during my childhood..
T de Q:
The following dream...a Sunday morning in May...Easter Sunday..right before me lay the scene which could really be commanded from that situation, but exalted, as was usual, and solemnised by the power of dreams...the hedges were rich with white roses...
MP:
It was at Easter...in the month of May that I remember...in the church..little branches of buds of a dazzling whiteness...
T de Q:
I find it impossible to banish the thought of death when I am walking alone in the endless days of summer...
MP:
That summer day seemed as dead, as immemorially ancient as...a mummy
T de Q:
Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz...........
MP:
Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz..................
Audience:
Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz..................
Readers:
Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz........................
Characters:
Marcel Proust
Thomas de Quincey
The curtain goes up on a bedroom scene. Two of the walls are cork-lined, the third is a bare stone wall roughly coated with Roman cement. In the angle of the two cork-lined walls is a narrow wrought-iron bedstead covered with an eiderdown quilt and beside it, a night-table on which lie books, papers, and a little brass bell.
Against the stone wall there is a brass bedstead piled high with blankets, and beside it a night-table on which lie books, papers, and a little gold bottle.
There is someone lying on each of the beds.
Marcel Proust:
Longtemps, je me suis couché de bonne heure...
(Propping himself on his elbow, he becomes aware of the audience and immediately reaches for the bell which he rings impatiently while calling out for his servant to come and close the curtains):
Françoise, Françoise, il faut fermer les rideaux - il y a une foule immense devant la fenêtre!
Thomas de Quincey, (sitting up in his bed angrily):
My dear sir, desist immediately from your tintinnabulous propensities. These velvet drapes will be closed at the end of the scene and not before, so you are wasting your breath, which I see you have little enough of, in calling for it to be done ahead of time. And indeed your feeble efforts are doubly futile since the character you call for is not even in the play, and the people you speak of are only the audience, such a harmless group that is in no way to be feared, unlike the horrible hoards who people my own dreams; and can I caution you, dear sir, for I perceive you to be something of a valetudinarian, against becoming a confirmed heautontimourousmenos...
Marcel Proust, (rubbing his eyes):
Bougre! Qui est-ce qui me lance des propos incompréhensibles plein de mots intérminables et de phrases impénétrables?
T de Q, (swinging his legs over the side of the bed):
Ah, you wonder who addresses you in such elaborately constructed language? Allow me to introduce myself.
(He walks to the centre of the stage)
I am Thomas de Quincey and you and I are characters in a play, and please note, my dear sir, that this play is in English, and therefore oblige us by refraining from any outbursts à la française henceforth. I might remind you also that this play is being staged in the year of our Lord, 2013 to mark the bicentenary of the events contained in one of the chapters of the most famous of my works, the essay with the much disputed title among my peers of 'Confessions', yes, my dear sir, not a sensational 'Diary of an Addict', but the humble Confessions of an English Opium Eater, and a work furthermore in which my contemporaries believed I was being too confidential and too communicative..
MP, (rising from his bed to look at a calendar hanging on the wall):
But if this is indeed the year 2013, then this play is surely meant to mark the centenary of the publication of my most famous work, my 'Recherche', that single work on which I devoted the labour of my whole life, and had dedicated my intellect, blossoms and fruits, to the slow and elaborate toil of constructing it...
T de Q, (holding up a document):
I think that you are on the wrong page of the script, my dear sir, those are in fact my lines, taken directly from page 175 of the 'Confessions', referring to my own life’s work, begun upon too great a scale for the resources of the architect alas, and which because of the very subject of this play, was likely to stand as a memorial of hopes defeated, of baffled efforts, of materials uselessly accumulated; of foundations laid that were never to support a super-structure, of the grief and the ruin of the architect.
MP, (moving towards the front of the stage and speaking directly to the audience):
Strange how these words of his recall my own fears and doubts concerning the completion and future acclaim of the 'Recherche', although I always subscribed to the belief that true works of art are slow to receive their full recognition, and must wait for a period when the author himself will have crumpled to dust. This centenary celebration, and your devoted presence proves me right.
(He nibbles on the corner of his moustache and mumbles to himself): Where are the Bergottes and the Blochs? All gone and forgotten while I alone have survived to become the keystone of modern literature...
T de Q, (lying down again upon his bed):
But alas, opium had a palsying effect on my intellectual faculties...
MP, (walking across to T’s bedside table, picking up the gold bottle and sniffing its contents):
I too have often reflected on the kinds of sleep induced by the multiple extracts of ether, of valerian, of opium...
T de Q, (closing his eyes):
I must now pass to what is the main subject of these confessions, to the history of what took place in my dreams. At night, when I lay in my bed, vast processions passed along in mournful pomp; friezes of never-ending stories, that to my feelings were as sad and as solemn as if they were stories drawn from times before Oedipus or Priam, before Tyre, before Memphis.
MP, (massaging his temples):
I feel something quiver in me, shift, try to rise, the glimmer of a visual memory, the elusive eddying of stirred-up colours...a magic lantern full of impalpable iridescences, multicoloured apparitions where legends are depicted as in a wavering, momentary stained-glass window...
T de Q, (in a dreamy voice):
A theatre seemed suddenly opened and lighted up within my brain, which presented nightly spectacles of more than earthly splendour. As the creative state of the eye increased, a sympathy seemed to arise between the waking and the dreaming states of the brain in one point, that whatsoever I happened to call up and to trace by a voluntary act upon the darkness was very apt to transfer itself to my dreams...
MP, (going back to sit on the side of his bed):
Yes, what one has meant to do during the day, one accomplishes only in one’s dreams, that is to say after it has been distorted by sleep into following another line than one would have chosen when awake. The same story branches off and has a different ending.
T de Q:
All this and other changes in my dreams were accompanied by deep-seated anxiety and gloomy melancholy, such as wholly incommunicable by words...
MP, (lying down):
But my sadness was only increased by those multi-coloured apparitions of the lantern..
T de Q:
The sense of space, and in the end the sense of time, were both powerfully affected. Buildings, landscapes, &c., were exhibited in proportions so vastly as the bodily eye is not fitted to receive....
MP, (closing his eyes):
In Combray, I moved through the church...a space with, so to speak, four dimensions - the fourth being Time - extending over the centuries...
T de Q:
The minutist incidents of childhood, or forgotten scenes of later years, were often revived...
MP:
I have many pictures preserved by my memory of what Combray was during my childhood..
T de Q:
The following dream...a Sunday morning in May...Easter Sunday..right before me lay the scene which could really be commanded from that situation, but exalted, as was usual, and solemnised by the power of dreams...the hedges were rich with white roses...
MP:
It was at Easter...in the month of May that I remember...in the church..little branches of buds of a dazzling whiteness...
T de Q:
I find it impossible to banish the thought of death when I am walking alone in the endless days of summer...
MP:
That summer day seemed as dead, as immemorially ancient as...a mummy
T de Q:
Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz...........
MP:
Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz..................
Audience:
Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz..................
Readers:
Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz........................
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Confessions of an English Opium Eater.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
May 2, 2013
–
Started Reading
May 2, 2013
– Shelved
May 2, 2013
–
6.82%
"I picked up Lindop Greville's life of Thomas de Quincey a couple of months ago, led to it by a reference I'd stumbled upon elsewhere, as I tend to do more and more, one book quickly becoming an entire shelf, and I read about a quarter of it before realising that what I really should be reading was de Quincey himself so now I'm enjoying his wonderful style non-stop instead of only in excerpts chosen by someone else."
page
24
May 2, 2013
–
8.52%
""Hence it is that children of bishops carry about with them an austere and repulsive air, indicative of claims not generally acknowledged, a sort of noli me tangere manner, nervously apprehensive of too familiar approach, and shrinking with the sensitiveness of a gouty man from all contact with the οι πολλοι."\n Latin and Greek in one sentence! I wonder if this is oneofthefirstuses of 'hoi polloi' in an English text?"
page
30
May 2, 2013
–
11.36%
""He was one of those anomalous practitioners in lower departments of the law who..deny themselves the luxury of...a conscience...in many walks of life a conscience is a more expensive encumbrance than a wife or a carriage; and just as people talk of 'laying down' their carriages, so I suppose my friend Mr--- had 'laid down' his conscience for a time, meaning, doubtless, to resume it as soon as he could afford it.""
page
40
May 4, 2013
–
18.47%
""I know not what he was: he was an ill-looking fellow, but not therefore of necessity ill-meaning; or if he were, I suppose he thought that no person sleeping out-of-doors in winter could be worth robbing. In which conclusion, however, as it regarded myself, I beg to assure him, if he should be among my readers, that he was mistaken."\n Dickens must have read this, orphans, peripatetics, odd characters of every sort.."
page
65
May 9, 2013
–
32.67%
""I myself used to find that half a dozen glasses of wine advantageously affected the faculties...and certainly it is most absurdly said, in popular language, of any man that he is 'disguised' in liquor; for, on the contrary, most men are disguised in sobriety, and it is when they are drinking...that men display themselves in their true complexion of character, which surely is not disguising themselves.""
page
115
May 10, 2013
–
34.09%
""The years of academic life are now over..the student's cap no longer presses my temples..my gown is by this time, I dare say, in the same condition with many thousand excellent books in the Bodleian, viz., diligently perused by certain studious moths and worms; or departed...to that great reservoir of 'somewhere' to which all the tea-cups, tea-caddies, tea-pots, tea-kettles, &c., have departed..."
page
120
May 10, 2013
–
38.35%
"At any rate, he who summons me to send out a large freight of self-denial upon my voyage of moral improvement must make it clear that the concern is hopeful, it cannot be supposed that I have much energy to spare, in fact I find it all little enough for the intellectual labours I have on my hands, let no man expect to frighten me by a few hard words into embarking any part of it upon desperate adventures of morality"
page
135
May 11, 2013
–
53.98%
""I know not whether my reader is aware that many children have a power of painting, as it were upon the darkness, all sorts of phantoms. In some that power is simply a mechanical affection of the eye; others have a voluntary or semi-voluntary power to dismiss or to summon them; or, as a child once said to me, "I can tell them to go, and they go, but sometimes they come when I don't tell tell them to come.""
page
190
May 11, 2013
–
64.2%
"Another symptom..internal rheumatism..seemed again less probably attributable to the opium..than to the dampness of the house. In saying this I mean no disrespect to the house as the reader will understand when I tell him that with the exception of one or two princely mansions and some few inferior ones coated with Roman cement I am not acquainted with any house in this mountainous district which is wholly waterproof"
page
226
May 11, 2013
–
64.49%
""The architecture of books, I flatter myself, is inducted on just principles in this country; but for any other architecture, it is a barbarous state, and what is worse, in a retrograde state.""
page
227
May 12, 2013
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-50 of 105 (105 new)
message 1:
by
Kris
(new)
May 20, 2013 09:50PM
This is brilliant! I beamed while reading it. So creative and perfect, Fionnuala. :)
reply
|
flag
*
HA! Sorry, that is a totally inadequate expression of my delight and wonder at this piece of yours. The next episode - oh no! that makes it sound like yet another Star Trek film - but it is the next instalment in your idea of dialogues, the dialogues set up by great writers, and coming through to you (another great writer).
Fionnuala, nicely put. I'm envious...and I've purchased this as I hate to admit that I've never read it and need to rectify that fact.
Proustitute wrote: "This has to be one of the best, most inventive GR reviews I've ever, ever read, hands down. Brava, Fionnaula, brava!"Thank you for this Oscar, P!
Can I pay tribute also to the entire Proust Institute here on gr, and also to Mr Proust and Mr de Quincey, without whom this review would not have been possible, and to my mother, my grandmother, my great-aunt, and all those who in any way whatsoever may have contributed...
Kris wrote: "This is brilliant! I beamed while reading it. So creative and perfect, Fionnuala. :)"Exactly the response I wanted, Kris!
@Garima, glad you enjoyed it.
@Lynne, good that you are inspired to read de Quincey!
·Karen· wrote: "HA! Sorry, that is a totally inadequate expression of my delight and wonder at this piece of yours. The next episode - oh no! that makes it sound like yet another Star Trek film - but it is the next instalment in your idea of dialogues..."Delight and wonder - that is all I need to hear - makes struggling through all the quotes to find just the right ones to sustain the dialogue worth while!
What a brilliant and lovely and visionary review Fionnuala… What a gem..!I just cannot agree with the very last line… In no way can we readers fall asleep with such an extraordinary piece of writing. What a perk…!!
Will you now proceed with André Breton, Robert Desnos, Benjamin Peret, and give us a sequel to these oneiric writings?
Ten Dreamy Likes…
Tony wrote: "Brilliant, beautiful, and uncluttered. Your mind, I mean."If you only knew, Tony, I need to declutter so badly. I feel like as if Proust and de Quincey are living inside my head...and it's sometimes beautiful, but boy, is it hallucinatory!
Kalliope wrote: "What a brilliant and lovely and visionary review Fionnuala… What a gem..!I just cannot agree with the very last line… In no way can we readers fall asleep with such an extraordinary piece of writ..."
Love your response, Kall! But the sleep bit, well, I had great ambitions for this review when I started it, thinking of loads of other themes I could work in, like writing and music, but I just got so tired myself that I think the zzzzzs were automatic writing, dada style...
@Bettie, glad to provide some fun - my main purpose!
You are an artist Fionnuala! Genuine and creative and challenging and witty. This is a fascinating piece of writing.Do not cease to delight us with your art, please! :)
Fionnuala wrote: "Kalliope wrote: "What a brilliant and lovely and visionary review Fionnuala… What a gem..!I just cannot agree with the very last line… In no way can we readers fall asleep with such an extraordin..."
You had mentioned some sleep issues lately.. well, we now know what was happening.. this review was cooking inside your mind.. And.. so.. how could you sleep?
Kalliope wrote: "You had mentioned some sleep issues lately.. well, we now know what was happening.. this review was cooking inside your mind.. And.. so.. how could you sleep? "That's exactly my problem, Kall, too many crazy thoughts bubbling up like warm milk inside my head....I need a holiday!!!!!
Dolors wrote: "You are an artist Fionnuala! Genuine and creative and challenging and witty. This is a fascinating piece of writing.Do not cease to delight us with your art, please! :)"
Thank you, Dolors, yours, and all the other generous feedback makes it all worthwhile.
Fionnuala wrote: "Kalliope wrote: "You had mentioned some sleep issues lately.. well, we now know what was happening.. this review was cooking inside your mind.. And.. so.. how could you sleep? "That's exactly my ..."
Yes, you may need a holiday.. what about a few days in Paris, and then a detour to Chartres and Illiers and then proceed to the coast.. to Normandy, for example... Have you considered Cabourg?
Kalliope wrote: "Yes, you may need a holiday.. what about a few days in Paris, and then a detour to Chartres and Illiers and then proceed to the coast.. to Normandy, for example... Have you considered Cabourg? "Wow, that sounds like just the prescription for my insomnia, Doctor!
Such a powerful potion: multiple extracts of Paris ether, of Illiers valerian, of Chartres opium taken at the seaside in Cabourg? Genius!
@Reem, @Ce Ce, thank you both for taking the time to read this and I'm glad it you enjoyed the humour.
I enjoyed your play/review immensely, Fionnuala. I've read excerpts of this and now I want to read the whole. Can you tell me what 'heautontimourousmenos' means? Google was no help.
Thanks Teresa, great that you are going to revisit de Quincey. That exceedingly long word means a man who tortures himself, and also means a hypochondriac, perhaps they are the same thing. The Greeks certainly knew their valitudinarians from their hypochondriacs!
Fionnuala wrote: "Thanks Teresa, great that you are going to revisit de Quincey. That exceedingly long word means a man who tortures himself, and also means a hypochondriac, perhaps they are the same thing. The Gre..."
Thanks! I figured from the context that it meant something like that, but I like to be sure. ;)
Jocelyne wrote: "So much fun!"I couldn't resist making these two have a dialogue, J. They have a lot in common.
Wonderful! --and I do so humbly beg your pardon, but I was most emphatically not among the slumbering at the conclusion!
Anastasia wrote: "Wonderful! --and I do so humbly beg your pardon, but I was most emphatically not among the slumbering at the conclusion!"Thank you, Anastasia. I'm cooking up an extended version of this review so watch this space!
I swear this should be staged. It is such a brilliant mixture of wit, of irony, of gentle criticism and sharp perception, and such a piece of poetry too, the way you've woven the threads of the same colour together! What a tapestry of style, what a haunting that makes us long to go back to read between the lines of the combination you've created. Thank you thank you Fionnuala. You've made a third out of two marvels
Thank you, Babou. And you are right, I need to go back and write more of the between the lines bits, pull it out more, if I can....
Babou wrote: "I swear this should be staged. It is such a brilliant mixture of wit, of irony, of gentle criticism and sharp perception, and such a piece of poetry too, the way you've woven the threads of the sam..."I entirely agree. I, too, think it should be built on and staged.
Ce Ce wrote: "I entirely agree. I, too, think it should be built on and staged."I'll definitely build on it, Ce Ce, and thanks for the encouragement.
Ian wrote: "Wow, excellent Celebrity Death Match Review."That's it exactly, Ian! They weren't actually talking to each other but outdoing one another. Perfect.
Fionnuala,I've just re-read your excellent review and as I already have this book, it's reminded me to put it on my reading list for next year.
Warwick wrote: "Ooof! What a tour de force of a review! Brilliant work, I was laughing out loud."A little opium goes a long way...
Samadrita wrote: "What a marvellous review, Fio! You are gifted."It was fun to write - and I wasn't even half way through Proust at the time but I don't think he was completely miscast!
Kalliope wrote: "I have read this again.. It is wonderful...."De Quincey is really very similar to Proust in the way he describes his own work, using the word 'construction' and other architectural terms frequently.
Riku wrote: "What an amazing review! Now I am glad I recently picked up a copy."In spite of his easy use of opium, long words and even longer sentences, De Quincey is a very lucid writer - I like that - shows respect for the reader.
Awesome review, you are so clever and so inspiring with your writing. I've got this on my short list, but I think I'll put a little distance between my review and the brilliance of this one. 11 out of 10 Fionnuala!
Absolutely wonderful review, Fionnuala. Publish! You are so talented, clever. I must read both books. Time is the only issue. Perhaps Proust would understand.














