Charles's Reviews > The Other Side of You

The Other Side of You by Salley Vickers
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
191480
's review
Jun 15, 2009

liked it
Read in June, 2009

I read this book with pleasure. It's neatly plotted and written with skill and a certain buttoned-up elegance. But I was left with doubts about its final success. First, did anyone else find the narrator unconvincing? I would have found the book more believable if the narrative voice had been female, because David never fully persuaded me that he was male. I didn't expect Rambo, but there was something oddly neutered about the character that goes beyond the psychological damage he'd no doubt suffered. I also had problems with the speed with which Elizabeth decided to tell her tale. I know narrative time scales are necessarily more economical than those in real life, but there are ways and ways of disguising this, and I don't feel that it was particularly well done in this novel. There's also something rather precious and old-maidenly about the way the nature of love is represented that, despite the recruitment of Caravaggio and the slightly improbably figure of Thomas, finally started to irritate me. So it's a slightly reluctant three stars. But definitely better than the rather dreadful Mr Golightly's Holiday by the same author.
1 like · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Other Side of You.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

06/15/2009 page 50
19.08%

Comments (showing 1-2 of 2) (2 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Jamie I'm only 3 chapters in and have just paused to add this book to my goodreads shelf. I too am finding the narrator to be distractingly non-male ('neutered' fits perfectly).


Ruby Yeah, I wondered about the 'maleness' of the character too, but figured as a woman myself I may not be the best judge. Her male characters remind me of romantic leads in bad soap operas, or the male figures in Bronte novels - ie - Thomas=Heathcliff, David=Edgar. I also found David's interest in Elizabeth a bit difficult to swallow. Her writing is very well constructed and a pleasure to read, but only if the reader manages to leave any expectations of credibility at the door.


back to top