Join Goodreads

and meet your next favorite book!

Sign Up Now
Scarlet rated a book really liked it
about 1 year ago
Recommended to Scarlet by: Samadrita
Recommended for: Jill
Read in June 2013
I did not expect a book on extra-terrestrial life to leave me thinking about the evolution of mankind.

You won't find any alien action here, no war-of-the-worlds scenario. Instead, 2001 is a book that relies on the sheer strength of ideas - which is what I believe good science-fiction should be about. All those intriguing what-if and maybe questions that can challenge your beliefs and change your perspective.

Maybe light is not the fastest medium there is. How do we know what lies buried on the moon? What if there are aliens out there who are so very alien that it's beyond out human faculties to even think of them as life forms?

Okay, I'm freaking out a little.

My point is, as fascinating as the book is, it's also utterly terrifying because almost everything about it seems plausible. Especially the part about Hal's malfunctioning. My blood nearly froze when that happened. (view spoiler).

I did not fully understand the ending and I don't think I ever will. The implications of that are so immense that it's impossible to get your head around - pretty much like the universe itself.

Or maybe I should say that the ending was too alien for my poor brain to make sense of.

2001: A Space Odyssey is one of those books that have timeless appeal. No wonder this has been labelled as the best science-fiction book ever.
Jim Scarlet,

You might try Clarke's Childhood's End, which I thought was a mind-blower at age 15 (and I read 2001 when I was 12-13).

The 1953 "SF Community" awarded the Hugo to Childhood. In 1969, 2001 was not even nominated.

(this may speak more to the time(s) than to more modern more literary sensibilities).
  • 3 years ago
Sharon This is one of my all time favorite movies. I still haven't read the book, but I really must one day. For some reason I think the book came out after the movie. In any case, you can find websites that discuss the ending. I hope you get the chance to see the movie some day because it's fantastic!
  • 3 years ago
Samadrita Jill wrote: "And Samadrita, even though that's a shame about Sagan's limited fiction output, the reason it's probably good sci-fi is that he had such strong academic background in physics and astronomy. A potential silver lining, perhaps."

Exactly. The ideas propounded in Contact ring so true. Arthur C. Clarke was an inspiration to Sagan and in 2001, Clarke mentions Sagan in the acknowledgements at the end of the book. At least in my edition there was this special essay by Clarke in which he mentions Kubrick and Sagan and Heinlein. Stalwarts of sci fi. :)
  • 4 years ago
Scarlet Yes, The Fifth Wave has made us appreciate sci-fi, I agree :)
I'm sure Contact will be great!
  • 4 years ago
Jill Well, if there is anything positive that came from the 5th Wave catastrophe, it's that we all united in an effort to read good and proper sci-fi.

I will definitely review Contact when I'm done with it. And Samadrita, even though that's a shame about Sagan's limited fiction output, the reason it's probably good sci-fi is that he had such strong academic background in physics and astronomy. A potential silver lining, perhaps.
  • 4 years ago
Samadrita You know what I hate the most? That Carl Sagan did not write any other science fiction apart from Contact. All his other books are works of non-fiction.
  • 4 years ago
Scarlet Samadrita wrote: "Better start with Contact since you already have it and write a kickass review to convince Scarlet to read it as well. :P "

Scarlet does not need a lot of convincing to read Contact! :P

And Jill, The Fifth Wave now seems like an insult to sci-fi! I'm tempted to downgrade it to 1-star ;)

But do review Contact when you're done. Hope it turns out great!
  • 4 years ago
Samadrita Jill wrote: "This sounds SO good! I got the other sci-fi book Samadrita recommended--Contact by Sagan--at the library yesterday and now I'm wondering if I picked the wrong one to start with!"

Contact is BRILLIANT, Jill. See I typed that in caps to convince you.
Better start with Contact since you already have it and write a kickass review to convince Scarlet to read it as well. :P
  • 4 years ago
Jill This sounds SO good! I got the other sci-fi book Samadrita recommended--Contact by Sagan--at the library yesterday and now I'm wondering if I picked the wrong one to start with!
  • 4 years ago
Scarlet "Proper sci-fi" - that's exactly what this book is!! This is going to be good, I can tell :)
  • 4 years ago
Samadrita In proper sci fi books there are usually no insta-loves, trust me! In fact there's no love at all.
  • 4 years ago
Scarlet One chapter down and I'm intrigued. The writing doesn't hurt my brain and I sense no insta-love in the future so this should go well ;)
Still, fingers crossed.
  • 4 years ago
Jill ooh! Excited to see if you like this. Hopefully not another sci-fi disaster à la 5th wave!
  • 4 years ago