Scope 's Reviews > The Curious Garden

The Curious Garden by Peter  Brown
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Feb 19, 2009

really liked it
bookshelves: 2009

Hello! My name is Mr. Message. You probably know me from my countless appearances in books, especially the "for children" variety. It's my job to expose a universal truth or support a cause. Sometimes I even tell the reader how they should act. As you may know, I can be controversial.

Sometimes, people get upset when authors make it really clear that I'm coming to the party. They put me front and center, and the story takes a back seat. Hey, I can be preachy if that's what the author wants! I don't always raise a stink, though. Occasionally, authors cleverly sneak me into a story, making as little disruption as possible. The reader hardly knows I'm there.

Then you have an author like Peter Brown (Chowder, Flight of the Dodo) and his book The Curious Garden. In this book I tell kids that caring for the environment makes a better world. Peter somehow manages to to make me the center of attention, yet not so preachy that it feels like readers are learning a lesson. There's a kind of take-it-or-leave-it nonchalance that I quite like.

The story is about a red-haired boy named Liam. He lives in a dreary town without a plant to speak of. No trees, no flowers, nothing but cement and smog. One day Liam happens upon a staircase which leads to the abandoned railroad tracks. What our hero discovers there changes his life. He finds plants. It's not much - some sad looking grass and a few flowers on their deathbeds, but Liam decides to nurse them back to health. As they get better, the vegetation begins to spread, and soon other folks begin to follow Liam's lead. After a while the town, once dingy and gray, is transformed.

While Peter did a great job adding me to the story, his acrylic and gouache illustrations really steal the show. The man is a master of perspective, always choosing the right angle to add life to the story. The beating heart of this book is right in the middle. Two wordless two-page spreads show the amazing growth of Liam's garden. In fact, the illustrations are such that this book would function pretty well were it completely wordless.

While I, Mr. Message, would love to take sole credit for the success of The Curious Garden, more praise should go to Mr. Brown, who created beautiful images, tamed my preachy side, and crafted a lovely story.
21 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Curious Garden.
Sign In »

Comments (showing 1-5 of 5) (5 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by [deleted user] (new)

How does this compare to Mr. Message's appearance in, say, The Lorax?

Scope Hmm. Good question. The message is certainly more subtle than that of The Lorax. Curious Garden doesn't have that good vs. evil element that Seuss' classic uses to such great effect.

message 3: by [deleted user] (new)

I'll have to pick this one up then. Great review!

message 4: by Sue (new) - rated it 2 stars

Sue Johnson Wonderful review, "Mr. Message!"

message 5: by Anke (new)

Anke Love this review! I'm reading this story aloud to a class of 2nd graders tomorrow.

back to top