James's Reviews > The Return of the Native

The Return of the Native by Thomas Hardy
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Jan 14, 2009

it was amazing
bookshelves: favorites, study-group, lincoln-park, british-literature, read-and-reread
Read in October, 2006 , read count: 4

I have enjoyed reading and rereading this novel since I was in my teens. In thinking about this I can only suggest that from the first reading I was impressed with Hardy's ability to create a complete believable setting where the characters interacted not just with one another but with the world in which they lived. That world was a rural Victorian one, but it resonated with my own somewhat rural experience even though it occurred more than one hundred years earlier.
What Thomas Hardy created was a tale of passion and tragedy on Egdon Heath located in his fictional Wessex. Egdon Heath itself is the first "character" introduced into the book. The heath proves physically and psychologically important throughout the novel: characters are defined by their relation to the heath. Among them is Eustacia Vye whose desire to lead a life elsewhere is dashed when she marries Clym Yeobright (the Native) upon his return from Paris. The pair represents the archetype of two people caught up in their passion for each other and conflicting ambitions. For Clym, the heath is beautiful; for Eustacia, it is hateful. The plot of the novel emphasizes just this kind of difference in perception. What impresses me upon rereading this is the intricate plotting of Eustacia who throughout the novel is weaving a web of deceit with the aim of enhancing her own life. Her hubris knows few bounds and is exacerbated by her lack of understanding of those in whose lives she has intervened. She raves, "How have I tried and tried to be a splendid woman, and how destiny has been against me! I do not deserve my lot! O, the cruelty of putting me into this ill-conceived world! I was capable of much; but I have been injured and blighted and crushed by things beyond my control! O, how hard it is of Heaven to devise such tortures for me, who have done no harm to Heaven at all!"(Book 5, Chapter 7) This lack of understanding is an example of the importance of misconception in the novel which is not limited to the character of Eustacia. Ambiguity builds as the novel progresses and the main characters remain obscure for the reader. When The Return of the Native was first published, contemporary critics criticized the novel for its lack of sympathetic characters. All of the novel's characters prove themselves deeply flawed, or--at the very least--of ambiguous motivation. What I found redeeming about the novel was the way Hardy brings the lives of this couple and their friends and families alive through detail that reinforces his penetrating portrayal of the community on the heath.
The final section provides some hope for the future, tempering the otherwise bleak landscape of the novel. This was Thomas Hardy's first great novel and he would follow it with bleaker tales this is the one that I return to when reminiscing of the joy of reading Thomas Hardy's novels.
9 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Return of the Native.
Sign In »

Comments (showing 1-4 of 4) (4 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Bruce (new)

Bruce Hardy's novels are magnificent; I've reread them all several times through the years. His poems, I think, are even better. Claire Tomalin's biography of Hardy is terrific and sheds light on his literary works.

James Thanks for your comment - his poems are great. I'll have to check out Tomalin's biography, she also has written a good Austen biography.

Gary  the Bookworm I just finished reading this and I found your review to be both relevant and illuminating. I have immersed myself in Hardy this summer and the rewards have been immense. Thanks for a thoughtful analysis of a spectacular novel.

James Gary wrote: "I just finished reading this and I found your review to be both relevant and illuminating. I have immersed myself in Hardy this summer and the rewards have been immense. Thanks for a thoughtful ana..."

Thanks for your kind words. Hardy is fascinating in his ability to create flawed but believable characters.

back to top