Jack's Reviews > Anathem

Anathem by Neal Stephenson
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Oct 22, 2008

it was amazing
bookshelves: scifi
Recommended for: everyone

There are very few books to which I'd give a five star rating. My criteria for this are pretty simple, but not many writers produce anything that meets them. _Anathem_ nails them all.

1. Scope. The book must be ambitious. It must approach a multitude of themes and problems, tackle all of them well, and give the sense in the end of having synthesized them all. I can think of only a handful of books (_Gravity's Rainbow_ & _Midnight's Children_ are two) that pull this off. _Anathem_ not only pulls this off in the final analysis -- it gives you the sense _throughout_ that it is a novel of massive yet cogent scope.

2. Story. This is obvious, but the problem for many books is that pulling off point 1, above, makes the story incredible, wooden, impersonal, or contrived. Again, _Anathem_ passes this test with flying colors.

3. Ideas. Stephenson's powerful intellect is on full display here. Not only does he assimilate some really interesting takes on science and philosophy into the narrative, he's spinning social and political theory out there as well.

4. Invention. Some negative reviews of the book have made a lot of the notion that Stephenson's worldbuilding in _Anathem_ is more recombinant than inventive. Bollocks, I say, for two reasons: 1) recombining in an innovative way is an entirely valid mode of invention, especially when the result is as immersive and complete as what Stephenson puts out in this book, and 2) the central conceit of the novel (and I'll steer clear of spoilers here), which some critics maybe missed or glossed over when critiquing Stephenson on his level of invention, succeeds in explaining why the world of _Anathem_ is -- must be -- so similar to our own.

I have a few quibbles with the book (again, steering clear of spoilers here), foremost among them being that one of the spacecraft in the book couldn't theoretically achieve the velocities he proposes -- at least not as the technology is understood by some of our best physicists, who spent considerable time on the problem. A spacecraft could probably come close to the speeds he suggests using a similar tech with a different fuel source, but it's a minor hard sci-fi fail, forgivable against the overall awesomeness of the book.

So yeah, I liked it. Read it now!

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Anathem.
Sign In »

No comments have been added yet.