Wealhtheow's Reviews > A Door Into Ocean

A Door Into Ocean by Joan Slonczewski
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
May 28, 2012

liked it
bookshelves: sci-fi, queer-characters
Recommended for: fans of Native Tongue
Read on July 02, 2012

Shora is a world without land. The humans who colonized it chose to reshape themselves, instead of terraforming the planet. Sharers, as the descendents of the colonists call themselves, strive to live in balance with each other and their world. Although they have incredibly advanced biological science, they try to change as little as possible about the natural ecology of Shora, even though it means losing friends and loved ones to vast monsters that roam the ocean. Their highest goal is to strengthen the ecological and social web that ties each creature to another. But they share their solar system with Valedon, a feudal, warlike world. And Valedon wants to expand its hold. Can the pacifists of Shora find a way to understand, and be understood by, their invaders?

I've seen other reviews that decry this book as gender-essentialist lesbian separatism, and I have to disagree. The Sharers are all female, and they are, as a group, very wise. But the book doesn't seem to present being wise as the natural extention of being an all-female society. The original colonists created a society that prizes consensus and pacifism, and those are the priorities they passed on to their descendents. There are many Sharers who are not wise in the least, who are hot-headed, blood-thirsty, or narrow-minded. The Valedon soldiers are male and female, and their chief torturer is a woman. And it's not like men are left out of the book--a male Valedon first learns from a wise (male) seer, then becomes a Sharer. We spend a large portion of the book inside his head, and much of the latter half inside another man's.

I really enjoyed reading the Sharers' struggles. They're incredibly inspirational, and I loved their society (even though I'd hate to live on their world). They refuse to do anything that might harm the Valedons (prefering civil disobedience), but the Valedons only value strength. It's fascinating conflict, but the resolution felt like a cop-out: (view spoiler) That aside, the societies Slonczewski create are engrossingly unique, and the conflict between them made me very tense and anxious.
11 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read A Door Into Ocean.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

06/09/2016 marked as: read

Comments (showing 1-6 of 6) (6 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Matt I am curious about your spoiler, that idea was mentioned, but it didn't seem to be taken seriously. I wondered about that as I read the ending, and even turned back to see if what stopped the other course of action. Sorry if this is cryptic, there isn't a spoiler tag for the comments.

Wealhtheow I might have misunderstood why the Valedons decided to give in to the Sharers--what interpretation did you have? (I think you can use spoiler tags in comments: (view spoiler))

Matt That is actually something I didn't get. (view spoiler)

Wealhtheow I read a sequel set hundreds (thousands?) of years in the future, and the planet and its moon are both still there, as are both peoples. So at least the pacifistic Sharers are safe for a time!

Matt Wow, didn't realize it was a series, might have to check it out. I like some of what she does quite a lot, but it seems to be a bit long in the middle.

Wealhtheow It did! But really, the societies she creates are so interesting to me that it hardly bothers me. The next one is just as long and meandering (in that it switches between various viewpoints, and the plot is mostly in the background until the last quarter), but involves even more new cultures interacting. I quite liked it!

back to top