Dwan Tape's Reviews > City of Women

City of Women by David R. Gillham
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
5091222
's review
May 15, 2012

liked it
Read from May 15 to 20, 2012

Well-written prose, hence the 4th star. I struggled a bit with the story itself (I would not have made the same interpersonal relationship choices), but that's my personal preference and not a fault of the plot.

Edited to add - dropped the star rating down - feel like I've been over-rating. It's a good, promising first read, but I struggled with the characters.
flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read City of Women.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

05/16/2012 page 35
9.0%
05/17/2012 page 107
27.0% "Quite compelling."
show 2 hidden updates…

Comments (showing 1-9 of 9) (9 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Elise That looks like my kind of book!


Dwan Tape It's good - he's a promising new writer, I think.


Elise What do you mean? I loved the characters. I questioned some of Sigrid's choices less because she literally lived with bombs dropping from the sky daily, and each and every day could have very well been her last. I sympathized with her.


Dwan Tape I'm always super careful reviewing an ARC - as I'm reading an unfinished galley, ahead of a book's release, I like to review lightly.

When I was reading it, I wondered at the main character's choices - unhappy or not, I would not have made them myself. I could intellectually get my head around her choices, but at the same time, her highly charged sexuality seemed a bit prurient, like the author was exploring his own sexual fantasy

While the book is a fascinating look at an under-explored perspective on WWII, I found her dalliances distracting, even though they were relevant to moving the plot forward. On a related note, there are few folks that come in the store that I've been able to recommend this book to - either the topic is not interesting to someone, or it's interesting and they aren't looking for something steamy. Hasn't sold well here at all.


Elise I guess I'm a freak, but I like sex in my novels. And think about it, if you thought every day would be your last (and you were married to a passionless and absent husband), you wouldn't just stop having sex, right? Okay, maybe that was TMI, but I found that scene very moving where Sigrid surrenders to Egon knowing full well that he is a Jew and that she is breaking a law that could get her killed when she gives herself to him--the stuff of a great book, IMO.


message 6: by Dwan (last edited Jan 01, 2013 08:30AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Dwan Tape Nah, I'm all for sex in a book, too. I think it can be a great, healthy part of a narrative. ^_^ But, yeah, while I consider my libido nice and healthy, I wouldn't dally, regardless. It's just the way I roll, I guess.

Also - what I mean by prurience: the sex (to me) reads more like the interests of the author versus what (to me) it seemed like Sigrid would dig. I found the tone of it distracting. That's all. I'm no prude. XD


Dwan Tape Running late for work, but let me add an example - Jonathon Tropper's main character in This Is Where I Leave You - that felt like more genuine sexuality. Of course, that was a male, so who knows.....


message 8: by Elise (last edited Jan 01, 2013 10:30AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Elise Well, I really don't know if I would "dally" or not, because I have never actually been in a situation as dire as Sigrid's, and I have a husband who is enthusiastic in the sack. ;) Maybe I like the book so much because I am way too much of a goody two-shoes to do what she did. Reading books where I can live vicariously though characters who do these things keeps me honest. :) My point was that I could certainly sympathize with her actions given her situation, and I didn't find anything about the sex scenes in the book twisted, self-indulgent, or gratuitous. That's all I'm saying.


Dwan Tape XD I feel like we're off on a tangent here. Love ya, grrlie.


back to top