Christina (A Reader of Fictions)'s Reviews > Starling

Starling by Lesley Livingston
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review

did not like it
bookshelves: finishedreviewcopy, audiobook, series-graveyard
Recommended for: people who still aren't sick of the standard paranormal romance formula

I'm going to put this out there and make no bones about it: I didn't care for Starling. There were a few different reasons for that, some of which are just bad timing and others which involve Starling running along classic YA tropes I personally dislike. Now, some books I don't like leave a bad taste in my mouth, make me angry, but this one didn't. I know many readers will enjoy this, and I do not begrudge them that. It just was not for me.

Starling sounded so up my aisle like you wouldn't believe. I mean, slap the mythology label on something, and I'm pretty much guaranteed to be chomping at the bit to read it. Unfortunately, while the mythology in Starling is original, it didn't resonate with me. I don't know if it's because I don't know much about Norse mythology (or some other kinds of mythology, since Livingston draws from a bunch of different ones), but I was a bit confused. I could have used more descriptions of the various attacking creatures, since very few of them were familiar to me.

Of course, I might have been more charmed by the mythology herein had I not, through unfortunate happenstance read Valkyrie Rising, another Harper YA title with an eerily similar cover, while in the process of listening to this audiobook. Both involve Norse mythology generally, and Valkyries specifically. With that little coincidence, I can't help comparing the two, and I much preferred the more straightforward tale in Valkyrie Rising, as well as the fact that the setting fit the mythology so much better than an expensive prep school. I had some suspension of disbelief issues with the plot evolving around this prep school run by families who believe in Norse mythology still.

If you like a lot of action, Starling will provide that for you in spades. It's pretty much storm-battle-family drama-flirting-battle-battle-date-battle and on like that. Not only that, but you get to watch Mason and Fennrys battle myriad creatures. I will say this for Starling. Mason does have skills, and I liked that she was a talented fencer. I liked less her tendency to choke at big moments, usually because a boy told her she wasn't good enough to win. For all her magical mojo, she's the kind of heroine who runs when told to by a protective male, even though she has fighting talent. This may be the wiser choice, but it's not generally how I like my heroines.

Up to this point in my little discussion here, I know I've sounded hypercritical, but, honestly, the book would probably still have elicited a 2.5 from me, just sort of meh. What dropped it into the 'nope, not for me' range was the romance. If you don't like the main couple and you're supposed to, it's painful, am I right?

When the story opens, Mason has a crush on Callum, her fencing partner, and has had for ages. We soon learn that he likes her too, but, due to a beauty-maiming injury at the start of the novel, he's too afraid to make a move, and never stands a chance, serving as the pathetic, bum leg of the love triangle. Well, too bad, so sad, because Mason's over it as soon as she sees another (now prettier) face. Fennrys, who falls butt-naked out of the sky like man(na) from the heavens, catches her eye immediately, both for his sexy body and his manly fighting prowess.

He comes and finds her later so that he can clothing borrowed from the fencing team. They flirt and she commits to helping him find out who he is, since, conveniently he has amnesia. You may be wondering what's so convenient about amnesia. Well, it's pretty damn convenient when the only things that have been forgotten are plot points! *headdesk*

Anyway, Mason and Fennrys did not work for me at all. For one thing, they are just shy of instalove. They moon over one another from moment zero, but they at least don't declare their love during that opening battle scene. What REALLY made me rage, though, was that I'm supposed to ship them, even though Mason is like totally terrified of him at times. You know what's not a good sign? BEING AFRAID OF THE GUY YOU LIKE. And I'm not talking afraid he's going to fart on you or eat the last oreo, okay? She sometimes suspects he's dangerous and might hurt her. I'm not saying that means she can't date him ever, but you should probably hold off on going places alone all the time and pretending he's your soulmate.

Starling failed to be what I wanted it to be, but you might still like it. So far as I could tell from the audiobook version, I had no issues with the writing. I really don't have a specific recommendation. Give it a go if you're interested.

I think it's just so cool when authors narrate their own work. There's something so personal about that. Of course, not everyone has the voice for it, nor do they necessarily have the time, as audiobook narration is quite the length process.

Livingston has an incredibly pleasant voice. Her narration wouldn't have worked if the book were in first person, but suited a third person omniscient narrator just fine. Don't judge me when I say that my favorite part of the book was listening to Livingston's pronunciation of words in her Canadian accent. I am pretty fanatical about accents, so you can imagine me giggling with glee every time she said the word 'sorry.' Unfortunately, either because I was disengaged from the story or because of my personal reaction to Livingston's voice, I had a lot of trouble focusing on what was happening. I listened to at least two chapters twice, because I could not for the life of me remember what had happened, even though I'd only been listening.
3 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Starling.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

May 10, 2012 – Shelved
September 18, 2012 – Started Reading
October 4, 2012 – Finished Reading
October 9, 2012 – Shelved as: finishedreviewcopy
November 12, 2013 – Shelved as: audiobook
August 10, 2018 – Shelved as: series-graveyard

Comments Showing 1-7 of 7 (7 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Khanh, first of her name, mother of bunnies Doh. How disappointing, the summary sounded so promising, and the Norse mythology aspect is so rare in YA.

Christina (A Reader of Fictions) You should try Valkyrie Rising by Ingrid Paulson. I really liked that one.

Cogito_ergo_sum I am from Canada and after all these years, I still can't figure out what you guys hear when we say, 'sorry'. My sister recently visited Florida for a month for work and she said she also couldn't figure out how she says 'sorry' differently that it sounds amusing or something. I've seen many American movies and tv shows. Unless the actor has a New York Bronx accent, or southern accent, I honestly don't hear the difference. If it's possible, can you describe it? By the way, a francophone accent doesn't count. It has to be a native English speaking Canadian. Thanks :)

Christina (A Reader of Fictions) The Canadian sorry comes out rhyming with story or lorry. Americans say it so that rhymes with starry.

Cogito_ergo_sum Thanks for answering. It kind of clears it up. I hear 'sorry' like right in the middle between story and starry. There's no way I'll be able to change my hearing, but at least now I mentally know what other people hear.

message 6: by Amy (new)

Amy M I'm Canadian and think Americans "sarry" is hilarious :P

back to top