James's Reviews > A Dance with Dragons: Dreams and Dust

A Dance with Dragons by George R.R. Martin
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
6022914
's review
May 04, 2012

liked it
bookshelves: fantasy, song-of-ice-and-fire, sword-and-laser
Read from May 05 to 17, 2012

With only five months between my reading of A Feast for Crows and this, I dread to imagine how confused readers would be who'd been forced to wait the full five years between publications. I was confused as hell. I can see why George R.R. Martin thought he had to split books four and five this way - geographically - but I'm not convinced. This time the book focuses on the viewpoints that A Feast for Crows had ignored - concentrating on Jon, Tyrion, Daenerys, Bran and Reek (view spoiler) - and staying mostly around The Wall, the lands beyond The Wall and everything to the east of Westeros - is that Essos? But, for me it didn't work. I can see I'm going to have undertake a massive re-reading programme before Winds of Winter comes out, whenever that is. 2015 is my guess.

The characterisation and writing was up to Martin's usual standards, but by-and-large, the book felt like the collection of chapters that just weren't quite good enough to go into A Feast for Crows. I think a large part of this is because the story is covering the same ground as that book. A lot of what you're reading isn't exactly new or shocking. Instead it's stuff you were generally able to guess or surmise from the parallel chapters.

Combined with my previous complaint about Martin's book one of a pair, A Storm of Swords: Steel and Snow , the story is really only half the story. Instead of excitement and action, you've got a lot of Martin moving his pieces around the board of his world so that they're all in the right places for the finale. Except the finale never comes because that's supposed to be in the next half. There's no sense of arriving at the end of this book, presumably the publisher has just took a knife through the middle of the spine of the hardback edition and used that as their guide for the two paperbacks.

That said, there's a lot to like about this book. The characters you missed from the previous book are back. Tyrion is as delightful and witty as ever, Jon is further developing his third dimension and realising that being Lord of the Watch involves some hard decisions, while Theon may still be a complete shit, you do also start to feel a little sorry for him, and Daenerys continues to try and juggle the desire to be both a fierce warrior princess with her need to be a compassionate queen who looks after the people in her kingdom. In all, a good start, but not a complete novel.
15 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read A Dance with Dragons.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

05/08/2012 page 59
9.0%
show 10 hidden updates…

Comments (showing 1-5 of 5) (5 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by N (new) - rated it 4 stars

N exactly how I felt, I am lucky enough to have started the series 2 weeks ago and I'm confused! !


James How confused are we going to be by the time the next book comes out in 2015?


S.B. Wright Same feelings here, even skipped the Chapters about Dorne. Some isolated chapters that were really engaging. On the whole I agree with your assesment


message 4: by Inge (new) - added it

Inge I agree. I think this book should have been before feast of crows as it continue more where we left off on a storm of swords


Sheila Well I finished A Feast For Crows last week and have just started the next one A Dance with Dragons: Dreams and Dust but I am very confused with the Samwell, Gilly & Maester Aemon part. In the last one they are all on the ship going to the Citadel (Gilly with the wrong baby as Jon's order which wasn't mentioned at all in this book). Maester Aemon at 92 dies in this book. However the Jon chapter I have just read in this one is him sending Gilly away with the wrong baby and ordering Samwell to go too and saying that Maester Aemon will be accompanying them. Surely this should be in the last book? Maester Aemon is surely already dead? I even looked on Wikipedia and both books say that Jon sends Samwell, Gilly & Maester Aemon to the Citadel. Confused!


back to top