Tyson Adams's Reviews > Blackwater: The Rise of the World's Most Powerful Mercenary Army

Blackwater by Jeremy Scahill
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
4968342
's review

it was amazing

Let's privatise the military. How could that possibly go wrong?

Blackwater: The Rise of the World's Most Powerful Mercenary Army outlines the political landscape of Blackwater's founding, the personal history of several key players - particularly Erik Prince - and the actions and intentions that made the company so infamous. It attempts to explain and document how mercenaries went through a rebranding to become the operators of choice in conflict zones around the world.

Okay, so I thought I had read enough news articles and the like to have some idea of what Blackwater was about. Mercenaries and the name Blackwater became something of a shorthand for "loose cannons", becoming the villains in movies and TV shows. But as Scahill outlines, the reality and totality are so much worse than I'd thought. Blackwater and several other companies are discussed, along with the players who made this all possible. You'll recognise many of the politician's names, but maybe less so the "contractors". This was disturbing reading.

There were a few very important points that were made. The first was how senior political figures decided they wanted to privatise the military and associated intelligence work. This is such a terrible idea that you have to be pretty ideologically bent-out-of-shape to think it is good. The most troubling reason for this being terrible is the lack of accountability this gives these newly privatised people with guns, bombs, and shady contacts. As numerous leaks have shown over the years, the military is already far too unaccountable.*

Which brings me to the second point, that once they are privatised, the companies lobby hard to remain unaccountable, saying they don't fall under military rules because they are private citizens, and that they don't fall under civilian rules because they are acting as part of a military force. In essence, they can literally commit murder and they have been positioned by their lobbyists and key politicians to never be even investigated for the crime.

Those points should disturb everyone. You may not see a problem with war profiteering, or religious fundamentalists pushing for war and creating conflict (or at least involving themselves in them), or free marketeers wanting to privatise everything, or private companies hiring "shoot-first-never-answer/ask-questions" mercenaries to guard their kitchen supplies. But I think we can all agree that you have to be accountable for your actions, and Blackwater (et al.) has not been.

After reading this book you'd think Erik Prince would suffer some consequences.... Nope. He's still going.

The only complaint I have about Scahill's book is that it was somewhat repetitive. Several points were raised repeatedly, not to highlight them, but because the surrounding issues or players were being discussed again.

After reading this I can only hope that the various players involved aren't allowed to have positions of power and influence ever again.**

* Because schools, hospitals, cafes, etc are totally legit military targets and not war crimes.
** My hopes will remain unfulfilled, I'm afraid.
flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Blackwater.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

February 26, 2020 – Started Reading
February 26, 2020 – Shelved
March 10, 2020 – Finished Reading

No comments have been added yet.