Rain Misoa's Reviews > Sanctuary

Sanctuary by Melissa Marr
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
4481312
's review
Mar 28, 2012

liked it
bookshelves: manga
Recommended to Rain by: Library
Recommended for: Wicked Lovely fans and those who have a high tolerance for pathetic girls.

Yup! You guessed it! I am still going strong with my manga binge. I don't plan to stop anytime soon. I'm just having so much fun with these. I cannot wait to keep going~ So I decided that after the last bomb I reviewed (seriously, that manga was utter crap) I had to go for something that had a little more promise. A little more. I've read the first three books of the Wicked Lovely series and... I have mix feelings of it. I liked the first book enough to read the second. The second was okay but I hated the main character with all my heart and found myself only liking the yaoi parts (Niall and Irial are just smex!!!). And the third book... was the worst in the bunch. Nothing happened in it. It basically a waste of time. So... it's a hit and miss with me. BUT! I did like the series as a whole enough to look into the manga series. When I saw that my library has all three volumes, I checked those babies out like a BAMF. Well, I read the first one and it's... eh, okay. I liked it and there were some parts I even went fangirly over but there are somethings, like in the novels, where I was just not into it. There were some good points to the story, but a lot of it was like... "WHA-!?" And some parts that just made me roll my eyes. Point is... I think I'm just so-so with this book.

Let me start off by saying... I have a love/hate relationship with Melissa Marr. I love her writing. I think it's absolutely brilliant and when she gets something down, you bet your ass it's going to be awesome. However, there are some moments where I feel that she just... doesn't get it. She thinks that love has to be right there and then and there's no need to learn about the other person. Another thing that bothers me about the stories that she writes is the fact that she makes all girls appear pathetic when it comes to men. The degrade themselves just so that they can be with the guy for just one more moment. It's annoying and it really comes off as if this is behavior that's okay for teenage girls to go through. It's not. Girls should be strong and not go to the guy first. Especially if he shows little interest in being with you in the first place. Marr also has a habit of writing instalove. Really? You meet for the first time and right away you're in love? That's what happened with these characters in this manga (more on that later). One thing that really confused me with this manga is the fact that it just right into the plot. There wasn't a lot of backstory so anyone going into this would be confused to high heaven. If you didn't read at least the first two novels of the Wicked Lovely series, you would be REALLY confused by this manga. Hell, I was confused for a good half of it and I read the first three novels. Basically, it's a manga meant just for the fans of the series. Not saying that's a bad thing but anyone who is curious and goes into it without much research would be lost quite a bit. Still, I do like Melissa Marr and respect her as a person... I just have my issues with her at times.

I must say that I do love the artwork. Xian Nu Studio did an excellent job in drawing this manga. It's very nice and easy on the eyes. Even the comical scenes are great to look at. One thing I will say about the art that wasn't really to my liking were some of the character designs. Especially with the males. Sure, when their shirts are off they look like males but when you can only see their face, you could swear they are women. The men are REALLY feminine looking. I don't have a problem with that. I read a lot of manga so I am used to men looking some what like girls. But in this manga they REALLY look like girls. There's no distinction unless one of the characters say so or their shirt is off. I also had a bit of a problem with the way Jayce's hair is drawn. It looks bizarre. It appears, to me, as if he has branches or weeds in his hair. I don't think it's an appealing look for him as a character. Other than that, I think the manga is beautifully drawn. I like how the setting is drawn and I like the way the faeries are drawn. They have a lot of details put into their design and I love them all the more because of that. So the artwork is okay in my book!

Some of the characters I had an issue with. The first being our female lead, Rika. I love that she can fight and all that. She doesn't really need anyone to defend her in that aspect. However, she's a little pathetic when it comes to men. She had a relationship with Keenan, the Summer King (of you read the book, you'll know who he is), and despite the fact that she said she doesn't have feelings for him, she still cries over him. Even though he did shitty things to her... she still CRIES over him! You can't be serious! You should never shed tears over a man who did you wrong. It's pathetic and weak. Speaking of being pathetic, Rika stalks her love interest, Jayce, for a long time before she had the guts to show herself to him and expect for him to like her right away... AND HE DOES!!! Instalove at its finest, people! DX She threw herself at him when she thought that he was going to distance himself from her. Rika, a little tip. If a guy questions having a relationship with you, DON'T FORCE HIM TO BE WITH YOU!!! DX One last thing that I didn't like about Rika was that she seems to be a girl that just wants a relationship and it doesn't matter with who. I say this because her friend, Sionnach (I call him Sion for short), was flirting with her and then she starts questioning some feelings towards that. (I know it sounds vague but I'm trying not to spoil it here.) Bah... I hate girls that just want to be with someone without trying to stand on their own. -_-" Moving on! Jayce... he was okay. Typical nice guy. He wasn't too amazing. He was just kinda... there. There to be pretty. Still, I didn't hate him so that's a plus! Then there's Maili, one of the antagonists in the manga. I have to say that I LOVE her character design. I don't know what about it makes me happy but it does! I think she is really beautiful. More beautiful than Rika. Her personality... well, she's evil. A bitch. I like that in my characters. XD Needless to say, I enjoyed her a lot. I didn't get to see much of her but that's okay. I'm sure she'll appear in the other volumes. Last character to talk about Sion! I love him to bits! I mean you get certain hints about him (which I will not say) but I think he's cute, fun, hilarious, sweet, a bit flirty, and everything else I like in a male. He has a female face, too, but that didn't really bother me since he just came off as a fun character. In fact, he's the only reason I am going to pick up volume two. Well, him and Maili.

To sum everything up, it's a good read. It's not the best but it certainly is far from being horrendous. I'm quite glad I gave this manga a try. It was entertaining even if it did have its faults. I cannot wait to read the second volume. Do I recommend this series? Yes but only to those who have read the novels. Non-fans would just not get it. Be warn. There are moments that might drive you up the wall if you have little patience for... well... stupid girls. But you might find yourself enjoying it. Give it a go. Wouldn't hurt you none if you've already read the books. ^_^
1 like · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Sanctuary.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

March 28, 2012 – Started Reading
March 28, 2012 – Shelved
March 28, 2012 –
page 1
0.57% "I read the first three books of Melissa Marr's Wicked Lovely series. And it's a hit and miss with me. I love some parts of the books... others I just simply want to burn. However, I do remember enjoying it enough to keep reading. One day I hope to finish the entire series. Until then, I shall check out the manga series! Hopefully, it will be a good read. ^_^"
March 28, 2012 –
page 28
15.91% "The art is very pretty with this manga series. I love it. However, the story is confusing me a bit. It just went right into things and now I'm just like, "What!?" Maybe things will get explained further on. Also, what girl Keenan DIDN'T fuck? I mean, come on! This is like the millionth one. (I'm not even exaggerating.) Another thing, the guys look like girls. That is all."
March 28, 2012 –
page 34
19.32% "Dude... you toyed with her feelings and dumped her like you did with all the other girls. I don't blame her for hating you. In fact, I hate you. You're an arrogant prick who needs to be shot. Multiple times in the head. -_-""
March 28, 2012 –
page 40
22.73% "I love the look of the faeries that don't really look human. I always thought they sounded/looked a lot more beautiful than the human looking ones. *Nods* This page is proof of that! <3"
March 28, 2012 –
page 47
26.7% "Rika's facial expression on this page just makes me giggle. XD Which reminds me... this manga, so far, has more art panels than it does dialogue. Not a bad choice. I like it when the art tells the sort a lot more."
March 28, 2012 –
page 60
34.09% "I don't know the name of that girl faery... but damn. She looks hot. Even if she IS a bitch. XD Why is it that I love the bitchy characters? The ones who are mean? With attitude? Ah, there's just something about them that makes me go all squee inside. Plus, she just looks so hot! XD"
March 28, 2012 –
page 62
35.23% "Seriously, Jayce, you look like a girl. I read manga and watch anime all the time and I can usually tell if it's a male character or a female character. But in this manga... the guys look REALLY feminine. :/"
March 28, 2012 –
page 64
36.36% "...and then I see your body, Jayce, and all doubts have been disperse. X3 No, I'm not shallow. *Crickets* Okay. Let me clear things up. When it comes to his face, he looks like a girl. His hairstyle doesn't help much. But when it comes to his body... okay... he's a man. XD I love his color skin, too! <3"
March 28, 2012 –
page 66
37.5% "Yay for instalove! It's in the manga, too! Whoo... *Sarcasm*"
March 28, 2012 –
page 69
39.2% "Ha! 69! *Coughs* Anyway, I am SOOOO happy we are getting some back story. The manga really started off confusing so let's clear up some of that confusion. Also, NO RIKA! Don't listen to him! He's a terrible faery! He says that to ALL the girls! DX"
March 28, 2012 –
page 77
43.75% "See? I told you he was a douche. >_<"
March 28, 2012 –
page 82
46.59% "Sionnach (strange name) has the face of a girl, too. XP BUT! I do like him. So far, anyway. He seems sweet and fun. XD The only thing I don't like is that he's obviously going to be the "other guy" that Rika is going to fall for. *Sighs* WHY!? WHY CAN'T THERE EVER BE JUST ONE!? *Head/desk*"
March 28, 2012 –
page 84
47.73% "Two things: Why is Rika crying over a prick like that after she said she didn't care about him? And I love the fact that that Sion (I'm going to call him that from now on. It's easier to remember.) doesn't give a crap really about that human she is crushing on. He's like, "Yeah I'll tell you where he is... but don't expect me to help you out. He's human. I'm not. That's that." XD Love him~"
March 28, 2012 –
page 92
52.27% "Girls... always falling for the pretty boy... who happens to be nice... somewhat charming... okay. I get why she likes him now! X3"
March 28, 2012 –
page 93
52.84% "And now she's crossing into territory that's similar to... "Pathetic much?" Talk to him, yes. But protect yourself at the same time, stupid. -_-""
March 28, 2012 –
page 96
54.55% "This is all well and good... but you guys are moving along WAY too quickly for my liking. Ah, instalove... it never fails to annoy me."
March 28, 2012 –
page 98
55.68% "...what just happened? O_o"
March 28, 2012 –
page 100
56.82% "Still don't know what that was about but Sion's face here is just too cute!!! *Flails*"
March 28, 2012 –
page 101
57.39% "Ah-ha! She IS a stalker! I knew it~ And what is Sion up to... I wonder..."
March 28, 2012 –
page 104
59.09% "Holy crap! It's Rude! Hey, Shades! How's it going!? XD"
March 28, 2012 –
page 114
64.77% "Oooo! Right in the nose! Sweet, Rika! Even though you have your faults, you're not a weakling. I can respect you a little for that. >:3"
March 28, 2012 –
page 125
71.02% "Ah! The pretty lady is back and she's trying to kick some ass! XD One thing I will have to say about this manga is that it moves a little too quickly. Sometimes it's hard to follow. I understand it all now but I wish the scenes didn't go by so quickly. One other thing, Sion saying that gives off bad vibes... I wonder what he wants with Rika. Oh well... I still like him. XD I wonder if that makes me... weird. XP"
March 28, 2012 –
page 141
80.11% "Maili is the pretty lady's name? Sweet~ And... Sion is sniffing Jayce... like a dog... and then smiles really wide... as if he approves... OMG I WANT TO HUG HIM RIGHT NOW AND JUST SQUEEZE HIM TO DEATH!!! WAH~! *Fangirling*"
March 28, 2012 –
page 148
84.09% "*Snickers* Oh, please do something like that to me, Sion~ <3333 *Gets shot* Okay... getting WAY too into this thing. I've got to stop. O_o"
March 28, 2012 –
page 154
87.5% "Wait... did you wanted to be kissed by Sion? You sure sounded like you do. *Narrows eyes* And what's with Jayce moving in like that? Dude, you barely know her. This is not something you do when you have not known a person for very long. -_-""
March 28, 2012 –
page 158
89.77% "There you go. Marr has done it again. She made the girl take the first step. Degrading herself in order for her to get the guy she wants. Marr... I do respect you and love you as a person and I'm not going to lie... I find your work to be very entertaining. But when you pull shit like this? I just want to smack you upside the head. -_-""
March 28, 2012 –
page 161
91.48% "That's the end of the manga. The rest of it is an excerpt of Fragile Eternity. (The worst book of the series if you ask me.) I... don't know how to take this manga. I like it... and I hate it. It's fun and entertaining... but there are little things that got on my nerves. Meh... I don't know how to rate this one... *Thinks about it for a bit*"
March 28, 2012 –
page 192
100% "I forgot to mention... Sion makes me giddy. I think he's the only real reason I enjoyed this so much. Him and the pretty lady... Maili, even though she only appeared for a few pages. In any case, I think I am now ready to review this sucker! >:3"
March 28, 2012 – Shelved as: manga
March 28, 2012 – Finished Reading

No comments have been added yet.