Luke's Reviews > Frankenstein

Frankenstein by Junji Ito
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review

it was amazing

Frankenstein is a story that most people are familiar with. Whether you’ve read Shelley’s original or no, you’re probably aware of the general thrust of the story thanks to films modern and classic. You know: creation, exclusion, and that it’s his Dad’s name, not the monster’s. So what can be brought to another adaption of the work?

Junji Ito is mostly known for weird and fairly gory manga, so it’s interesting to note that this version of the tale – an adaptation, so not strictly canonical – is more subtle than I’d expected from his earlier works.

The story departs from Shelley’s version in a couple of places, but not in ways that cause undue concern. The way the monster is portrayed is suitably horrifying, though it’s still easy to feel sympathy for the stitched-together thing, because the story is not played for gore’s sake. It’s shocking in places, yes, but that’s because the source is, not because Ito’s take is particularly wild. It’s respectful, and the translation reflects Shelley’s vocabulary and pacing – but there are some departures.

What’s interesting about Ito’s adaptation of Frankenstein is that it was commissioned by its publishers as a tie-in for Kenneth Branagh’s 1994 version of the story. This commissioning was the first time Ito had read the story, so it’s perhaps unsurprising that the filmed adaptations probably influenced his take more than anything else.

Frankenstein isn’t the only piece in the collection, though. Aside from a brief digression into the world of family dogs – yes, really – there’s a handful of stories gathered here that circle around the increasingly odd life of a school student named Oshikiri.

Let’s just say that he’s not exactly a normal boy. He’s a bit of a shrimp. And a bit confused, identity-wise.

And you know, also could be from another parallel world.

It’s a difficult thing, on top of having to do well in school, that’s for sure.

The stories involving Oshikiri are stranger than Ito’s Frankenstein, as is expected. There’s very much a feeling of folk horror, of legend and reality gone awry. In keeping with the author’s usual style, there’s also a lot of places where the mental health of the narrator – and their reliability – is questioned. Are we seeing the real world, or the static-filled invocation of disorder?

It’s never particularly easy to tell. Laying the whole connected-universes idea on top of that, the stories are disorienting reads: is this the real world? Is it seepage from another world? Is it hallucination?

The artwork pushes this point. It’s clean, and seemingly everyday, but then there’s… frames… that just don’t look right. It’s uncanny stuff, and eminently readable. I kept pushing on to see if there was any resolution to Oshikiri’s travails, or whether the tales are a collection of moments in time, frozen.

The answer is satisfyingly imprecise.

This collection of works is great. It’s a reminder that Ito has a wonderfully singular voice. His other titles have become iconic in their own rights – Tomie and Uzumaki (soon to be adapted into animated format) certainly are very well regarded – but his version of Frankenstein shows that the horror titan is just as good when he hasn’t written the underpinning text himself.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Frankenstein.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

August 31, 2019 – Started Reading
August 31, 2019 – Shelved
September 3, 2019 – Finished Reading

No comments have been added yet.