Claire Caterer's Reviews > Mary Poppins

Mary Poppins by P.L. Travers
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
716733
's review
Mar 02, 2012

it was amazing
bookshelves: classic-kids-reads, fantastic-fantasy, britain, favorites, home-library
Read in January, 1971

Why am I so wild about Mary that I award her the coveted five out of five stars? It may be childhood sentimentality, I admit. My mother used to read Mary Poppins as well as Mary Poppins Comes Back aloud to us in the car on long vacations. Nothing could hold me as mesmerized. I so wanted a nanny who could serve tea on the ceiling or rescue me from the nasty characters inside a Royal Doulton bowl. I was devastated every time Mary left, even knowing she would come back. I loved her because she wasn't sugary sweet (the lovely Julie Andrews notwithstanding); magic was part of who she was and she saw no nonsense in it. So what if extraordinary things happened whenever Mary was around? Children still had to go to bed on time and drink their cod liver oil (though when Mary administered it, it was somehow delicious).

I envisioned that one day I would live on Cherry Tree Lane, where the cherry trees danced down the center of the street with houses running down one side and the park on the other. This book was probably the beginning of my deep and abiding love of all things English.
3 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Mary Poppins.
Sign In »

Comments (showing 1-2 of 2) (2 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Cathy (new)

Cathy I read these as a child in the 50's-60's and LOVED them, too. They were so imaginative and even though Mary was somewhat mean you knew she cared about the children. I wanted to have her as a nanny, too. The movie was so disappointing in that it was nothing like the book, with no depth of Mary's personality, and the lack of mystery.


Claire Caterer Cathy wrote: "The movie was so disappointing in that it was nothing like the book, with no depth of Mary's personality, and the lack of mystery. "

I agree, Cathy, that the movie just didn't do the books justice. I was and am a big fan of Julie Andrews, so I try to appreciate the movie on its own, apart from the books. I did love the songs. But P.L. Travers' words are the real gold.


back to top