TheBookSmugglers's Reviews > Earthseed

Earthseed by Pamela Sargent
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Feb 20, 2012

really liked it
bookshelves: apocalypse-dystopia-keepers, science-fiction-awesomeness

Originally Reviewed on The Book Smugglers

Earthseed begins with a familiar premise: after mankind has wiped out the majority of Earth's natural resources and damaged its ecosystem over the centuries, humans turn to the stars for a new home. These human survivors have thrown their hopes on a distant system in deep space, creating an artificial intelligence powered space ship, loaded with the history of human culture, knowledge, and the genetic material to create new humans, crops, and animals. As Ship nears its destination, just years away from reaching the new planet, it executes its mission to create and nurture human children from its genetic stores.

Zoheret and all of her fellow shipmates have grown up under the careful watch of Ship, learning about Earth's past and preparing for a future on a new planet. But Zoheret and her friends come of age at fifteen and come ever closer to reaching their new home, things begin to change. To best prepare its children for the reality of pioneering a new world, Ship creates a competition and gradually begins to withdraw the careful protections and conveniences with which it has provided its passengers over the duration of their young lives. As the teens cope with the reality of creating a new society, divisions form, violent tendencies are exposed, and the truth of Earth's past history, Ship's mission, and the future of humanity comes to a dramatic, terrifying head.

Inevitably, when reviewing older SF titles like Earthseed, there's the question of datedness. Having read and reviewed Monica Hughes' The Game earlier this year, there certainly is something to be said for the context and point of time in which a novel was written - in the case of The Game, while the overall conceptualization was fantastic, the execution and depth of character was somewhat wanting. Earthseed begins with honest-to-god ROLLERBLADING around a spaceship.

I repeat: Rollerblading. On a spaceship.

How freakin' 1980s-early-'90s baller is that?!

All joking aside, I am happy to report that Earthseed stands the test of time. In the lingo of an '80s child, Earthseed is a totally rad book.

The premise of the novel is a familiar one, and fairly standard in future-dystopia SF fare, from the aforementioned The Game to Wall-e, but I think handled with a (surprising!) deftness and freshness in Earthseed. There are a number of unpredictable twists, plot-wise, as Ship hurtles its way to a new planet, and besides the rollerblading, the novel didn't feel dated at all.[1. On a side note, this is the mark of an excellent work of SF - take Ridley Scott's Alien, for example. I can still watch that 1979 film today and be thoroughly convinced by the acting, the set, the quality of the aliens...that's pretty awesome, and no small feat. But I digress.] Yes, this is soft science fiction (e.g. faster-than-light space travel, an enormous ship that houses an entire ecosystem that takes days to traverse in its hull), but I loved the jungle-within-the-ship setting and the juxtaposition of high-technology against a new low-tech environment, and watching how characters would respond. I also loved the diversity of the cast, encompassing many different races and cultural namesakes, which is, again, not something I expected in a book from 1983. Also unexpected was the level of brutality in this book, since it is billed as a YA novel. Earthseed doesn't shy away from anything - I'm talking teen sex, jealousy, infidelity, drinking, deception, murder, you name it. One of my complaints with much of the contemporary YA dystopian market is its lack of teeth - there's never any fear that our heroes are in the wrong, that they won't prevail or survive. In Earthseed, this is decidedly not the case. Characters do what they have to do in order to survive - and many of them die. Our heroine, Zoheret, makes many questionable decisions, and though her heart is in the right place, she's not idealized or infallibly right, which is wonderfully compelling. At one point in the novel, Ship tells Zoheret that she's not the smartest, or the kindest, or the most deserving - but like Ship, there's something about Zoheret's dogged stubbornness that is appealing.

Beyond Zoheret, many of the overall characterizations were perhaps a tad superficial, but only because the cast is so large - I do think the actions and justifications for all made sense and rang as genuine. I liked Ho's conniving and Manuel's selfishness - though these are archetypes that one often sees in society-falls-apart type of stories, they are archetypes for a reason. Ultimately, though, I think what I loved most of all about Earthseed is that the character of Ship (because yes, Ship is a central character) is not an evil robot/AI monster with a twisted agenda. I feel that in many contemporary SF novels, technology is demonized, and in this book, Ship is the voice of reason and civility; it is the peacemaker to our warlike tendencies, the Vulcan to our messy human emotions.

Ship is, above all, a nurturing force that is seeding the future with hope that mankind can change. And that kind of optimism, especially in a novel as bleak and gritty as this one is, is brilliant.

I'll be back for Farseed very, very soon.
3 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Earthseed.
Sign In »

Comments (showing 1-2 of 2) (2 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Phoebe (new)

Phoebe I also loved the diversity of the cast, encompassing many different races and cultural namesakes, which is, again, not something I expected in a book from 1983.

I actually expect this more from both adult and kid's sci-fi from the 70s, 80s, and 90s, when multiculturalism was in full swing. Animorphs is a good example of a rainbow cast.

(Also, I love Ship. Best character in this series!)

message 2: by Estara (new)

Estara You have a point about multi-cultural expectations in the 80s - the grown-up version would by Vonda McIntyre's Starfarer Quartet?

back to top