Andi's Reviews > The Right to Write: An Invitation and Initiation Into the Writing Life

The Right to Write by Julia Cameron
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
52752
's review

liked it

The book is subtitled "An Invitation and Initiation into the Writing Life," and thus is about the ways that people can start a writing practice that focuses on writing for the sake of the process rather than the sake of the product. Julia Cameron puts it this way:
If we are invested in a writing life -- as opposed to a writing career -- then we are in it for the process and not the product. We are in it for the body of work and not for the quick hit of one well-realized piece." (p. 66)

Each chapter of the book is on a different abstract concept related to writing such as "Mood" or "Voice" or "Making It", and each chapters ends with an "Initiation Tool," a writing exercise. The book reminds me of a combination of Lamott's Bird by Bird and Goldberg's Old Friend from Far Away because it combines thoughtful pondering on the practice as well as practical tools for the craft. Many of Cameron's writing assignments are about how you feel, however, encouraging you to draw a bath or take a walk, whereas Goldberg's exercises always take you to the page. I must confess that I prefer Goldberg's method more, since Cameron wanders a bit too far into the psychology of writing for my taste. I feel like Cameron is a cheerleader for people who want to write anything, including journals (which is great, just not where I am) whereas Goldberg is a cheerleader for people who need to write for other people to read. Does that distinction make sense?

In terms of what I took away from this book, I appreciated it, but I did not find it as useful as Lamott or Goldberg. That fact may be a result of where I was in my writing when I read it - at a place where I wasn't following a daily practice - but I think the book also waxes esoteric a bit too much, making me lose my grounding in my own writing. Additionally, Cameron largely discounts the intellect in writing practice, and while I certainly know writing comes from a deeper place than from the mind, it's hard for me to see our knowledge and our understanding of the world intellectually as completely devoid of value in writing.

All in all, this is a great book for people who need to get a daily writing practice started or for people who truly have great anxiety or fear about their writing (I have been both of those people and still am on some days). It may simply not be for those who are already writing and simply need someone to walk beside them.

http://www.andilit.com/?p=219
13 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Right to Write.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
July 21, 2008 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-1 of 1 (1 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Jennifer Tatroe I'm about 3/4 through this book and your review is very close to where I find myself standing on it. Especially this: "I feel like Cameron is a cheerleader for people who want to write anything, including journals (which is great, just not where I am) whereas Goldberg is a cheerleader for people who need to write for other people to read." The distinction absolutely makes sense and I feel the same way.


back to top