Paul's Reviews > Prolegomena to the Study of Greek Religion

Prolegomena to the Study of Greek Religion by Jane Ellen Harrison
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
5070927
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: ancient-history, religion, ancient-greece

This book, originally published in 1903, is the best thing I've found on Greek mythology or Greek attitudes to things of the spirit generally.

I forget exactly what prompted me to get it, probably favorable mention of it in some other book, but in July 2010 I got myself a used copy of the stout Meridian Books paperback published in 1955. An imposing tome of 682 pages, it sat on my shelves until just 5 months ago. At that time I had hit, as I occasionally do, a gap in my reading, and I came down to the "library" (a carpeted storeroom housing our freezer and 3 Ikea Billy bookcases) to prowl for something of interest. I finally decided to give the Prolegomena a chance.

I was immediately impressed with the author's perceptiveness, authority, and approach. The book's 12 chapters take one on a journey from "chthonic rituals" of "ghosts and sprites" to an extended discussion of Orphism, which occupies the last 4 chapters. And what a journey it is: I felt that all kinds of puzzles and mysteries and seeming inconsistencies of Greek mythology resolved and fell into place. The fascinating thing about this book is that it has very little to do with what I had always thought of as Greek religion, which was a religion centered on the familiar gods of Olympus. Jane Harrison occasionally mentions these gods in passing, but her interest is in all the religious phenomena that lay in the penumbra of the spotlight pointed on Olympus by Homer and other classical authors. Her interest is in tracing the development of Greek religion from its most primitive manifestations up to its most sophisticated ones. The Olympian gods formed part of that story, but only a part, and seemingly, as this author tells it, by no means the largest part.

I was already aware that ancient Greek religion had been formed by a collision between the prehistoric matriarchal system of the ancient inhabitants of the Balkan Peninsula and Crete and the patriarchal invaders who swept down from the north and east. But Harrison shows how the deepest layers of Greek religion need to be sought in the beliefs and behaviors of primitive people who fear, above all, ghosts. Much of what develops into what we call religion begins with the riddance and placation of the souls of the dead, who, when angry, vengeful, or envious, can bring terrible misfortune to those still living. Long before there is anything so definite and well characterized as a personal god, there are countless invisible sprites--the Keres of ancient Greece--who affect the human world for good and ill, and many of Greece's famous festivals and rituals had their origins in repelling, expelling, and appeasing these ghostly figures.

Harrison shows how goddesses and gods eventually emerged from these primitive spirits, and how these gods eventually became clearly distinguished and named--even if with a number of different names. And she shows how these two eventually gave way to a higher, more mystical kind of religious experience and practice that gained the name Orphism. Some investigators have believed that Orpheus was a god, but Harrison dismisses this view. To her it's clear that Orpheus was a man, a revealer and reformer who created a mystical new religion inspired by the worship of Dionysos and injecting new esoteric meaning into primitive rites.

Much of the author's argument is based on the interpretation of ancient Greek art: vases, bowls, funerary monuments. The book is richly illustrated with black-and-white reproductions of these, and Harrison's depth of knowledge of these artifacts is most impressive. She knows what she's talking about.

The prose itself is very readable. Harrison writes with passion and admiration, even as she does not hesitate to criticize and pass judgment on ancient practices and authors when they reveal signs of savagery or confusion. She is quick and punctilious to acknowledge the work of other scholars, but unafraid of noting when she disagrees with them or rejects their ideas. She is also well versed in the ancient authors and treats them in much the same way; she relies on them, but is aware of their personal shortcomings. There are a couple of interesting footnotes too in which she admits that some theory of her own, already appearing earlier in the book, is in error! Read carefully.

In all, a thoroughly excellent book. If you're new to ancient Greek mythology and religion, then you probably should not start here. Acquaint yourself with the Greek myths and festivals, and then reach for this book. You start to see how all those various strange myths start to make sense; they are expressions of a few guiding principles that underlie their formation.

For us in the West, Greek mythology is the mythology; when we talk about "myths," often we mean Greek myths. Our culture is shot through with them; our modern stories are based on them and are filled with allusions to their events. For example, I'm currently reading The Golden Compass by Philip Pullman, published in 1995, and I suddenly realized that some of the action was based on the Oedipus myth. But those myths are the tip of an iceberg, and to appreciate them fully one should have a sense of the shape and depth of the berg that lies below the waterline. Jane Harrison's book examines the underwater part of that iceberg, and it's illuminating indeed.
flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Prolegomena to the Study of Greek Religion.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 6, 2018 – Started Reading
December 6, 2018 – Shelved
December 6, 2018 – Shelved as: ancient-history
December 6, 2018 – Shelved as: religion
December 6, 2018 – Shelved as: ancient-greece
December 6, 2018 –
page 15
2.2%
December 7, 2018 –
page 22
3.23%
December 7, 2018 –
page 22
3.23%
December 8, 2018 –
page 28
4.11%
December 9, 2018 –
page 36
5.28%
December 10, 2018 –
page 40
5.87%
December 11, 2018 –
page 45
6.6%
December 13, 2018 –
page 51
7.48%
December 14, 2018 –
page 56
8.21%
December 15, 2018 –
page 61
8.94%
December 16, 2018 –
page 66
9.68%
December 18, 2018 –
page 72
10.56%
December 19, 2018 –
page 80
11.73%
December 20, 2018 –
page 93
13.64%
December 22, 2018 –
page 100
14.66%
December 23, 2018 –
page 111
16.28%
December 24, 2018 –
page 116
17.01%
December 25, 2018 –
page 119
17.45%
December 27, 2018 –
page 126
18.48%
December 28, 2018 –
page 134
19.65%
December 29, 2018 –
page 139
20.38%
December 31, 2018 –
page 150
21.99%
January 3, 2019 –
page 167
24.49%
January 4, 2019 –
page 172
25.22%
January 5, 2019 –
page 187
27.42%
January 6, 2019 –
page 197
28.89%
January 7, 2019 –
page 203
29.77%
January 9, 2019 –
page 214
31.38%
January 11, 2019 –
page 220
32.26%
January 12, 2019 –
page 232
34.02%
January 15, 2019 –
page 241
35.34%
January 16, 2019 –
page 245
35.92%
January 17, 2019 –
page 251
36.8%
January 18, 2019 –
page 255
37.39%
January 19, 2019 –
page 262
38.42%
January 20, 2019 –
page 271
39.74%
January 21, 2019 –
page 276
40.47%
January 23, 2019 –
page 285
41.79%
January 26, 2019 –
page 301
44.13%
January 27, 2019 –
page 313
45.89%
January 28, 2019 –
page 325
47.65%
January 29, 2019 –
page 333
48.83%
January 30, 2019 –
page 344
50.44%
January 31, 2019 –
page 350
51.32%
February 2, 2019 –
page 367
53.81%
February 3, 2019 –
page 384
56.3%
February 4, 2019 –
page 395
57.92%
February 5, 2019 –
page 403
59.09%
February 7, 2019 –
page 413
60.56%
February 8, 2019 –
page 425
62.32%
February 9, 2019 –
page 433
63.49%
February 10, 2019 –
page 443
64.96%
February 11, 2019 –
page 453
66.42%
February 13, 2019 –
page 464
68.04%
February 15, 2019 –
page 481
70.53%
February 16, 2019 –
page 489
71.7%
February 23, 2019 –
page 496
72.73%
February 23, 2019 –
page 496
72.73%
February 25, 2019 –
page 506
74.19%
February 26, 2019 –
page 517
75.81%
March 1, 2019 –
page 526
77.13%
March 2, 2019 –
page 537
78.74%
March 3, 2019 –
page 545
79.91%
March 4, 2019 –
page 557
81.67%
March 5, 2019 –
page 571
83.72%
March 6, 2019 –
page 581
85.19%
March 7, 2019 –
page 593
86.95%
March 8, 2019 –
page 604
88.56%
March 9, 2019 –
page 613
89.88%
March 10, 2019 –
page 623
91.35%
March 11, 2019 –
page 635
93.11%
March 12, 2019 –
page 647
94.87%
March 12, 2019 – Finished Reading
March 13, 2019 –
page 682
100.0%

No comments have been added yet.