Emma Deplores Goodreads Censorship's Reviews > Villette

Villette by Charlotte Brontë
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Jan 06, 2012

really liked it
bookshelves: classics, belgium, best-10-books-read-in-2012, 4-stars-and-a-half
Read from January 05 to 13, 2012

It’s hard to review a classic, so I’ll keep it brief. As others have related, this book is about a young Englishwoman who, following an undisclosed family tragedy, picks up and crosses the Channel to make her living as a teacher in the fictional city of Villette. As one would expect from a classic, it’s very well-written, and I’m sure there’s plenty to analyze that I didn’t even catch. So I’ll move on to what I liked best about it.

Above all, Villette is a brilliant character study. Lucy Snowe and the people around her (and their relationships with each other) seem real in a way that’s rarely seen in fiction. There’s a lot of variation in how readers react to these characters, but to me Lucy made a lot of sense, and was in many ways very relatable even though the book was written over 150 years ago. It’s very much a character-driven book; there’s not a lot of plot, but the book kept my attention regardless (in fact, monopolized my attention over several modern books in my to-read stack). It’s also a very melancholy book. Lucy isn’t happy, she’s disappointed by the people around her, and she definitely doesn’t get a fairytale ending. (view spoiler) This aspect of the book is probably what impressed me the most: most authors with lonely protagonists give them wonderful, caring, supportive, long-suffering best friends by the end of the book, but life isn’t always like that. And Lucy’s love interest is a very flawed person as well--as is everyone in this book, really, which is what makes it good.

But while I certainly recommend the book, I can’t say I recommend the Signet Classics edition. First, there are an awful lot of typos. Second, the French dialogue is translated only in endnotes in the back of the book. I can only assume that the person who made this publishing decision has never enjoyed getting lost in a book in his/her life, or else assumes everyone who reads classics knows French (but don’t think because of that the book has only academic value and can’t be enjoyed!). Third, and I never thought I’d say this, but a few explanatory footnotes other than the translations would have been helpful. For instance, I had to Google “Labassecour” to figure out that it’s the name of Bronte’s fictionalized version of Belgium (and enough readers mistakenly think the book takes place in France that I’m clearly not the only one to get confused). So, I definitely recommend the book, but try for an edition that’s actually had some work and thought put into it, if you can.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Villette.
Sign In »

Comments (showing 1-4 of 4) (4 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Jan-Maat (new) - added it

Jan-Maat did you enjoy it? It's on my mental list of books to read.

Emma Deplores Goodreads Censorship Yes, I did. It's not a book everyone will like since the protagonist is very solitary, reserved, and unhappy. But it's quite good and it worked for me.

Orinoco Womble (tidy bag and all) They call it open ended because Bronte had to change the sad ending she wanted to make it seem less inevitable that he didn't come back. She wanted a tragic ending...possibly to give herself some closure re: her feelings for M. Heger. Or to kill him off in her mind, perhaps.

Emma Deplores Goodreads Censorship I've heard that she changed the ending, but I don't consider it open-ended. What happened may not be spelled out in so many words, but it's very easy to figure out. To me it just read as if it was too painful for Lucy to actually spell it out.

back to top