John Pistelli's Reviews > Alack Sinner: The Age of Disenchantment

Alack Sinner by Carlos Sampayo
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review

really liked it
bookshelves: comics, twentieth-century, twenty-first-century

This second volume of Alack Sinner collects Muñoz and Sampayo's noirish series of graphic novels originally published from the 1980s through the early 2000s. In the narrative the authors, politically radical Argentines exiled to Europe by their country's 1970s right-wing dictatorship, keep time politically.

The first Sinner story in this volume of avowed disenchantment is set against the backdrop of U.S. involvement in Nicaragua as the titular detective tries to keep visiting Nicaraguan leftists safe in the atmosphere of the Reagan '80s, all the while falling in unrequited love with one of them, a woman named Delia. As the series progresses, Muñoz and Sampayo's storytelling style, never very linear to begin with, becomes even more dream-like and uncertain: the centerpiece of "Nicaragua" is a hallucinatory puppet show the white Sinner attends with his young black daughter, Cheryl, a horrifying pageant that displays the history of U.S. imperialism in Latin America. "My mom said that Nicaragua is people..." Cheryl hesitantly muses on the spectacle, a phrase that compresses a unified theory of white western dominance.

Sinner's relationship with Cheryl and the other women in his life, including Cheryl's mother Enfer, his on-again-off-again lover Sophie, and his sister Toni dominate the middle stories in the book, one of which is aptly titled "Private Stories." While Sinner's inner monologue refers to "my women," the series begins to dwell more consciously on gender, especially in the long story where Sinner struggles to save first his daughter and then his sister from various forms of imprisonment. Politics-with-a-capital-P is also touched on here, as the "private story" of Cheryl's false accusation of murder involves her extrication in Haiti's long oppression by the west.

The politics return in full in the final story, titled "The U.S.A. Case," as if to signal Muñoz and Sampayo's own object of criminal investigation: a country they do not live in but whose global dominance has shaped their lives nevertheless. "The U.S.A. Case" takes place a month before September 11, 2001, a month in which Cheryl, now pregnant, is threatened again, this time by a shady arms deal whose implication is U.S. intelligence services' foreknowledge of the coming terrorist attacks. As one ghoulish old agency man puts it on the book's final page, "Security? [...] That's the investment of the future, as long as the Bin Ladens and company are around." Too paranoid? Alack Sinner is about nothing other than the corruptions of power, global, economic, racial, and otherwise; in this world, as in its noir forerunners, you can't be too paranoid.

The passage of time makes these stories more affecting than those in the first volume, as we watch Sinner and his friends and lovers go from middle age to the brink of old age, and as we watch his daughter grow from child to mother. Muñoz's inkily fluid, shadow-laden pages remain the best thing about the work, even if his style ages, along with its hero, into sometimes illegible forms of looseness and abstraction. I don't know if Alack Sinner is one of the best comics I've ever read, but it's certainly among the best I've ever seen.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Alack Sinner.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
October 11, 2018 – Shelved as: comics
October 11, 2018 – Shelved
October 11, 2018 – Shelved as: twentieth-century
October 11, 2018 – Shelved as: twenty-first-century

No comments have been added yet.