Petrik's Reviews > Gates of Stone

Gates of Stone by Angus Macallan
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
59458347
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: ebooks
Recommended for: Asian-inspired epic fantasy fans

ARC provided by the publisher—Berkley Publishing Group (Ace)—in exchange for an honest review.

An Indonesian-inspired epic fantasy accompanied by Chinese, Japanese, and Indian influences; I’ve never read an epic fantasy with world-building like the one in Gates of Stone.

Angus Macallan is a pseudonym for Angus Donald, a historical fiction writer most well-known for The Outlaw Chronicles series. Gates of Stone, the first book in Lord of the Islands series marked his first foray into the fantasy genre. When I first stumbled upon this book on Twitter, I was utterly filled with joy and disbelief that someone actually wrote an epic fantasy inspired by my home country. And it’s real and not a joke; Macallan cleverly utilized his skills as an author of historical-fiction into creating a powerful beginning of an Indonesian-inspired epic fantasy series.

The two main characters of the book are Katerina and Prince Arjun. Just before her sixteenth birthday, Katerina, the rightful heir to the Empire of the Ice-Bear was denied her ascension solely because of her gender. As such, Katerina was determined to scour the tropical islands of Laut Besar in search of vast power and wealth to regain her rightful inheritance. As for Jun, his peaceful life was shattered when a malicious sorcerer came to his island, slaughtered everyone and stole the ancient sword in his father’s possession. Jun then decided to track down the sorcerer and reclaim the ancient weapon, which apparently was one of the Seven Keys required to unlock a devastating power. Although the two main characters are teenagers, their stories contain trigger warnings for rape, gang rape, and some gore.

There is a marked contrast in the personalities and character development of the two main characters. Katerina exhibits brutality and tyranny; her determination to not let anything stand in her way resulted in gruesome cruelty. She started off as terrifying and intimidating but as the story progressed, we get to see the depth of her personality peeled off layer by layer. Jun, on the other hand, was almost the complete opposite of Katerina in his characterization. I enjoyed the two characters’ development and storylines immensely. Admittedly, there was another side POV that took quite a while to spark my interest, Farhan. While Katerina and Jun’s storylines started with characterization over action sequences, Farhan’s POV featured tons of battle scenes right from the beginning with very few breaks in between. This isn’t necessarily a problem; I would imagine that anyone who prefers faster-paced narratives with action sequences introduced early on may enjoy his story a lot. However, as I’ve mentioned this in almost every review of mine, I’m a reader that places the utmost priority on characterization. It’s not until around 70% of the book that I was finally invested in Farhan’s story. Luckily, even though Farhan’s POV didn’t really click with me, the other two main characters were more dominantly featured.

Macallan’s prose and action sequences were incredibly engaging and easy to follow. It doesn’t matter whether it was naval battles, close-quarter combats, magic, or sieges, Macallan delivered his vivid and visceral action scenes. I believe that his ability to write such great action scenes was one of the two skills stemming from Macallan’s experience as a historical fiction author; the other is world-building.

Generally, I’m not a fan of reading a high fantasy that takes place on the same world like ours but I found the originality and intricacy in the world-building to be my favorite part of this book. Obviously, I’m a bit biased because I’ve been living in Indonesia since I was born. However, even without being an Indonesian, the book’s setting was highly original for an epic fantasy and its Indonesian inspirations were absolutely spot-on. The islands, the jungle, the fauna, the weapons, the terms, the names, the clothing, and the lore; I can’t possibly talk about each of them in detail without adding on at least an extra thousand words into this review. I’ll just list some of these Indonesian influences:

-Pahlawan is an Indonesian word meaning ‘hero’.
-Garuda Bird is the symbol for Pancasila, the official foundational philosophy of Indonesia.
-Yawa is derived from Java, the islands of Indonesia.
-Dewa in this book equates to the lower caste of a slave but the word itself means ‘god’ in Indonesia.
-Muda is an Indonesian word for ‘young’.
-Mburu, a hunter in this book, is most likely a derivative of the word ‘pemburu’, the Indonesian word for ‘hunter’.
-Raja in Indonesia means ‘king’. Same meaning in this book.
-Istana in Indonesia means ‘castle’. Same meaning in this book.
-Laut Besar literally means ‘big sea’ in Indonesia.
-Obat is an addictive narcotic in this book; in Indonesia, obat is ‘medicine’ or ‘drug.’
-Hantu Harimau is the other nickname for Ghost Tiger in this book. ‘Hantu’ and ‘harimau’ literally means ‘Ghost’ and ‘Tiger’ in Indonesia.
-Kris (search for an image of this unique weapon.)

Additionally, below this is a comparison between the maps of the world inside the book versus Indonesia.

Picture: The World Map in Gates of Stone



Picture: Map of Indonesia



I purposely left some out, but if you really want to know the meaning behind the other terms while reading this book, do feel free to message me and I’ll answer your query the best that I can. Indonesian influences aside, other Asian influences from China, India, and Japan were also evident. Macallan imbued noteworthy Asian influences into his work with due justice. As an avid fantasy reader and a Chinese born, raised, and living in Indonesia, and one who also loves Japanese cultures, I truly applaud Angus Macallan for the courage to write something original and different from the other current mainstream fantasy.

Gates of Stone is a uniquely great and impactful start to an epic fantasy series. Thank you, Angus Macallan. I’ve read many fantasy books over the past two years, and I’m pretty sure I’ve never read any with a setting and lore like the one in this book. With Gates of Stone, Macallan has established that he’s here to stay in the fantasy genre.

Official release date: February 19th, 2019

You can buy the book with free shipping by clicking this link!

You can find this and the rest of my reviews at Novel Notions
120 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Gates of Stone.
Sign In »

Comments Showing 1-30 of 30 (30 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Samir (last edited Nov 01, 2018 03:23AM) (new)

Samir Fun fact; in Croatian muda means balls :D


message 2: by Virginie (new) - added it

Virginie Dammit. You win, Demon! Added to the TBR!
(I will def PM you when I finally get my hands of this book to get more details about the Indonesian influences :D )


message 3: by Birte (new) - added it

Birte This sounds so great! I'm so happy that the author used Indonesia as an influence. I'll probably notice more of the Chinese and Japanese inspiration so I'll probably ask you if that's ok. :)


Petrik Samir wrote: "Fun fact; in Croatian muda means balls :D"

Holy shit that's indeed a FUN fact xD


Petrik Virginie wrote: "Dammit. You win, Demon! Added to the TBR!
(I will def PM you when I finally get my hands of this book to get more details about the Indonesian influences :D )"


The competition may be over but the TBR demon will always continue to haunt you! P.S: Absolutely, feel free to message me about it! :)


Petrik Birte wrote: "This sounds so great! I'm so happy that the author used Indonesia as an influence. I'll probably notice more of the Chinese and Japanese inspiration so I'll probably ask you if that's ok. :)"

It's great, Birte! I think you'll love this one too! And of course, feel free to ask me! :D


message 7: by Rinaldo (new)

Rinaldo I did the double take on Indonesian. You have my attention now.


message 8: by Petrik (last edited Nov 01, 2018 05:26AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Petrik Rinaldo wrote: "I did the double take on Indonesian. You have my attention now."

And you should read it, bro! Hantu Harimau menunggumu! :D


message 9: by Audrey (new) - added it

Audrey I am looking forward to read it , your review is well written as always petrik , I am glad you liked this book.


Petrik Audrey wrote: "I am looking forward to read it , your review is well written as always petrik , I am glad you liked this book."

Thank you so much, Audrey!! I hope you'll like it too! :)


message 11: by Maia (new) - added it

Maia Love your review! That seems really great!


Petrik Maia wrote: "Love your review! That seems really great!"

Thanks, Maia! It was! :D


Clemlucian (🏳️‍🌈the brooding witch) you had me with "indonesian inspired epic fantasy." It has to be the first time I see a book with that kind of mythology and culture! Thank you for the synopsis (the review is also great btw.)


message 14: by Colleen (new)

Colleen Great review! That's so cool that you found an Indonesian-inspired fantasy!


Petrik Clemlucian (🏳️‍🌈the brooding witch) wrote: "you had me with "indonesian inspired epic fantasy." It has to be the first time I see a book with that kind of mythology and culture! Thank you for the synopsis (the review is also great btw.)"

You're welcome, Clemlucian! I know right? I've never read anything like this one! Thank you, I hope you'll love it! :)


Petrik Colleen wrote: "Great review! That's so cool that you found an Indonesian-inspired fantasy!"

Thanks, Colleenn! What are the chances right? I never thought a non-Asian writer would ever write something with this setting and lore! :D


Eon ♒Windrunner♒  Sounds very cool Petrik. *fistbump


Petrik Eon ♒Windrunner♒ wrote: "Sounds very cool Petrik. *fistbump"

Thank you, Eon! :) *fistbump


LittleBookDruid This book sounds so interesting.


message 20: by Ayu (new) - added it

Ayu Wow okay as an Indonesian i'm curious with this book


Petrik LittleBookDruid wrote: "This book sounds so interesting."

It is! You should check it out when it's out, Druid! :)


Petrik Ayu wrote: "Wow okay as an Indonesian i'm curious with this book"

I know right, Ayu!? How awesome is that someone wrote an Indonesian inspired fantasy book! :D


message 23: by Ayu (new) - added it

Ayu Yup, hmm but i doubt the book will available in Bahasa next year


Petrik Ayu wrote: "Yup, hmm but i doubt the book will available in Bahasa next year"

Haha I doubt it too!


Nils | nilsreviewsit Hey Petrik, I see this book is classed as YA - does it feel YA? As in is there a lot of romance/angst/love triangles etc? Also you know I’m not a fan of rape scenes, so do you think it would be a problem for me in this?


Petrik Nils | nilsreviewsit wrote: "Hey Petrik, I see this book is classed as YA - does it feel YA? As in is there a lot of romance/angst/love triangles etc? Also you know I’m not a fan of rape scenes, so do you think it would be a p..."

Nope! I have no idea what this is classified as YA. Seriously, the content would shock anyone who expect this as YA book. No angst, no love triangles, no romance. As for rape scenes, there's a gangbang rape scene, not explicit but yeah, there's one and a few mention.


Nils | nilsreviewsit Thanks my friend! If the scene is not explicit then I don’t think I’ll have a problem. 😁 Also glad its not got a YA feel to it!


Petrik Nils | nilsreviewsit wrote: "Thanks my friend! If the scene is not explicit then I don’t think I’ll have a problem. 😁 Also glad its not got a YA feel to it!"

You're always welcome, Nils! I hope you'll enjoy this one too. It's really unique!


message 29: by Olga (new)

Olga It's such a joy to read your reviews my friend! You sold me on this one. Can't wait to read it. ☺️ And I'm so glad to know is respectful of your culture and other Asian cultures.


Petrik Olga wrote: "It's such a joy to read your reviews my friend! You sold me on this one. Can't wait to read it. ☺️ And I'm so glad to know is respectful of your culture and other Asian cultures."

Thank you, my friend! As far as Indonesian culture and naming goes, this was absolutely spot on. I hope the story and characters will be working out great for you too! :)


back to top