Marvin's Reviews > Ender's Game

Ender's Game by Orson Scott Card
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Nov 26, 2011

it was ok
bookshelves: science-fiction
Read from November 26 to 27, 2011

I believe it was A. E. Van Vogt who said, "The Golden Age of Science Fiction is 14." And in fact, much of the classic science fiction of Heinlein and others feed into the mind of the adolescent boy. The protagonist Ender is an adolescent's dream. He is alone, alienated and feels he is not appreciated for how special he is. In other words, he is the average teen male or at least how the average teen male sees himself. Add on the naive and egotistical worldview envisioned by Heinlein and it is no wonder why adolescents flocked to the science fiction pulps of the 50s. In fact it can be argued that the teen sci-fi fan of the 50s was not all that different from the Emos of our generation.

Ender's Game was written in 1986. Yet it reads very much like a Heinlein novel and the plot and themes are not all that different from Starship Troopers. Card was smart enough to add in video games and the internet as waves of the future but the old Cold War mentality and the "might is right" philosophy hangs on. This is why this somewhat sadistic journey of a six year old child to his role as sci-fi messiah is so disturbing. Ender is brilliant but it is his habit of extreme violence that attracts him to his superiors. This appears to be a virtue in the author's eyes. In fact, one of Ender's teachers spell it out in no uncertain terms.
"The power to cause pain is the only power that matters, the power to kill and destroy, because if you can't kill then you are subject to those who can, and nothing and no one will ever save you."

Keep in mind this is being said to a six year old boy.

This is the basic theme of the novel. Violence is never extreme enough if it is for a good cause. This idea is never really questioned by Ender or anyone. At the end there is a twist that appears to lay doubt. However is not the basic moral issue in question but the assumption that sets the means to the end in play

This is why I cannot give this novel anything more than two stars. Card isn't a bad writer although some of his action scenes are muddled and he had an annoying habit of changing to third to first person and back for no reason. This was his first novel but I've never read anything else by him so I don't know if he developed any better habits. But this kind of philosophy in any story, especially one that appeals to teens, is disturbing to me. I'm OK with the idea of a young boy with talent being challenged and persecuted. It is a stalwart of YA literature. Harry Potter is an excellent example. But Card seems to preach "If you can't beat them, join them but just be a better fascist than they are."

While we are on the subject, Orson Scott Card is also known for his rather conservative social and religious viewpoints. One of those is his opposition to gay marriage and his basic revulsion to homosexuals in general. So why does his book have so many scenes of young boys running around and wrestling in the nude? Not to mention that the aliens are nicknamed "Buggers". I see some major issues here. Mr. Card, please seek help.

39 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Ender's Game.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

07/02 marked as: read

Comments (showing 1-10 of 10) (10 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Nuclearlee I think this review sums the book up perfectly (and you made me crack up with your last I enjoyed the book quite a bit, but I'm pretty sure I am mentally still a teenager.

Marvin Thanks, Nuclearlee. I'm glad you enjoyed my review.

Jason For somebody reviewing a work of fiction, you seem to be rather intent on psychoanalyzing an author, instead of taking his work at face value. Whether he injected any political statements into his work or not (debatable, at best), they shouldn't detract from the telling of the story itself.

Marvin If I felt he told his story well, I might agree with you. However, told well or not, an author's views and intent in his story is certainly fair game for the reviewer.

Larry Day If you had bothered to read more than just his freshman novel I'd bother to address your freshman psych analysis of OSC's psyche.

message 6: by Marvin (last edited Jun 14, 2013 09:55AM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Marvin Well, you did bother to address me, didn't you? I do take your opinion of my analysis being freshman quality as a compliment since I am criticizing a work with a philosophy that never goes farther than middle school.

message 7: by Marvin (last edited Jun 14, 2013 09:54AM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Marvin The following article was sent to me just this morning.

Orson Scott Card’s long history of homophobia

This is getting press again since the Ender's Game movie will be released in November.

message 8: by Jan-Maat (new)

Jan-Maat It is not a novel that I've read, (not sure how I missed it, I was reading Sci-fi when it came out) but from the positive reviews I 've read about I get the strong impression that it is Fascism in space with Holocaust apologetics. I find it's popularity really remarkable. Maybe it's all the naked wrestling!

Marvin You pretty much have it right. But, to be fair, the naked wrestling isn't all that prevalent. It just strange it's there to begin with.

BTW, I saw the trailer for the movie last week. At the very least, it going to be a visually stunning movie which is saying something for a tale which has the main character playing a video game for most of the plot.

William Graphic depiction of child abuse and hatred. Sick America.

back to top