Emily's Reviews > The Ask and the Answer

The Ask and the Answer by Patrick Ness
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Nov 16, 2011

really liked it
bookshelves: dystopian, futuristic, girls-who-kick-ass, war, orphans-and-foster-kids

** spoiler alert ** Oh dear. I have about six more books I’ve told myself I have to get through before I can read the third book in this trilogy, but it is going to be tough. At first, I was just relieved to finally be reading this one, and then about halfway through, I realized it would probably end with another cliffhanger and I’d be in the same position I was before. This is the sort of problem you love to have, you know? At least I do.

This book starts out just about where the last book left off, with Todd and Viola being captured by Mayor Prentiss. They are immediately separated and the Mayor does his best to use them against each other as he takes over control of Haven. Todd is forced to work for the Mayor, and Viola is put under the care of a healer named Mistress Coyle, who is developing plans to combat the new regime.

For the first time, we get chapters from Viola’s point of view as well as Todd’s, which is necessary for the narrative and also gives us a better sense of her character. There is constant tension in this story, as Todd and Viola struggle to figure out what’s right and who they can trust, and as they desperately try to find each other again. The strength of their need for each other is so clear and heart-wrenching, and it feels entirely natural. The Ask and the Answer is just as brilliant and powerful as the first book. It is surprising, heartbreaking, and beautiful and the third volume is sure to be even more so.


Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Ask and the Answer.
Sign In »

No comments have been added yet.