Andy's Reviews > Wildwood

Wildwood by Colin Meloy
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Nov 15, 2011

it was ok
Read from November 26 to December 11, 2011

Wildwood, all props to Meloy and his lovely wife Ellis, reads like one of the longest Decemberists songs of all time. This reads longer than The Mariner's Revenge Song (one of my favorites, seriously, I've used it while teaching Melville), but is not as interesting. This book reads like a long version of pretty much all of The Decemberists albums... which can be a good thing, but the problem is... it isn't. I want my small snippets of Meloy charm. I want my Eli the Barrow Boy, and Leslie Ann Levine. Unfortunately, Meloy sort of overdoes it with this novel. This could have been a really cool YA book, if it were 300 pages thinner. I think, and this is my humble opinion, that Meloy just became a little over zealous in his writing, and just couldn't stop. He was like Grady Tripp, but with YA. There as no ending... ahhhhh... that is a rough trade for a reader, but hey, I'll take that challenge. I want more Meloy, just in a much smaller dose.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Wildwood.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

11/30/2011 page 150
27.0% 1 comment

No comments have been added yet.