Melanie's Reviews > Foolish Hearts

Foolish Hearts by Emma   Mills
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: contemporary, romance, young-adult, signed, read-in-2019, subscription-box-owlcrate, buddy-reads

“He is my small son”

I’m going to write this review a little differently; instead of telling you the synopsis of this book right away, I’m going to show you the two parts of my heart.

Best Friends & Boy Bands - If you follow me on any social media, you will know that BTS has completely and wholeheartedly taken over my life. The amount of unconditional happiness that I have found within myself because of BTS could be a thesis statement all alone. But the pure joy I feel when I know that I will get to follow and enjoy BTS and everything they give ARMY, along side my best friends? That’s something I don’t have words for, and I don’t think I ever will, but it truly owns half of my heart.

Little Brothers & Video Games - I am very open in many reviews about my little brother being my best friend in this entire world. He always has been, and he always will be. Ever since I graduated college and moved across the country, we have kept our closeness because of video games. Don’t get me wrong, we play them nonstop when we are together, in the same room, too, but it is truly something that I’ve been able to do with him to never make me feel like I’m away from him, and because of this, this combination makes up half of my heart.

Foolish Hearts is a book that made me feel so seen and so very whole, because it combines those two halves of my heart seamlessly. Our main character, Claudia, spends her afternoons playing video games with her siblings and her best friend, not really looking to add any addition people into her life. That is, until the end of this summer, right before school is about to start up, where she has to go to a party where she accidentally overhears two girls break up.

Iris and Paige were the *it* couple at Claudia’s school, but now that they are broken up, Paige gets to still be the beloved, popular one, where Iris looks like the mean and heartless one. And when Iris and Claudia are forced to work together, not once, but twice, Claudia also uncovers Iris’s unconditional love for a boy band. And the start of a beautiful friendship blooms.

Not to get too personal in this review, but I am also pretty open about Jane being the reason that I got into BTS, and even though we were friends before, BTS really made Jane my best friend, and it really changed my life in the best way possible. The Iris and Claudia comparisons were just a little too real, but they were also a little too perfect.

So much more happens in this book, maybe with boys and them entering Claudia’s MMO and making me swoon because I’m nerdy and basic. Maybe with secrets that others were keeping from Claudia. And maybe this entire story is set with the backdrop of a school play. There is a lot to love about Foolish Hearts, but how real it felt to me and my personal experiences was really the brightest and shiniest star.

You can really tell that Emma Mills gets fandom culture. How it is so easy for people to be negative about things that (unharmfully) make people happy. But also how sharing your happiness and love for something with someone else is truly a magical feeling sent from the higher powers. How fetishizing is totally a thing that is very serious and very real, but most of the time fandoms just want to love, support, and bring happiness to the people that bring them happiness. (Protect Park Jimin at all costs!)

Overall, this was just a really personal read to me on a few levels, but I loved it completely with the sum of my being. Also, there is epilepsy rep in this story, too, and I really loved how it was written! This book is really just a love letter to friendships, and I really do feel so soft currently. But if you are into BTS, or any musical group, I really highly recommend this one. I had the goofiest smile on my face while reading this entire book, I swear. It is for sure one of the best things I’ve read all year. And even though this review already feels like a love letter to BTS, I just hope anyone who reads this review finds happiness in things they can love wholeheartedly.

Blog | Instagram | Twitter | Tumblr | Youtube | Twitch

Content and Trigger Warnings: high risk childbirth, panic attacks, seizure mentions, and talk of past underage drinking.

Buddy read with Jane & Chelsea! ❤

❤ I read this for The Reading Rush, 2019!
289 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Foolish Hearts.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 29, 2017 – Shelved
December 29, 2017 – Shelved as: contemporary
December 29, 2017 – Shelved as: romance
December 29, 2017 – Shelved as: young-adult
January 8, 2018 – Shelved as: to-read
July 11, 2018 – Shelved as: signed
December 11, 2018 – Shelved as: read-in-2019
June 13, 2019 – Shelved as: subscription-box-owlcrate
July 26, 2019 – Started Reading
July 26, 2019 –
page 100
31.25% ""He is my small son"
July 27, 2019 – Shelved as: buddy-reads
July 27, 2019 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-23 of 23 (23 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Cheryl (new) - added it

Cheryl I don't know how to start reading

Taasia ✨ Yes! I had a feeling you'd love it :)

Tracy Dishman One of the very few books that has made me laugh out loud.

ⒶH-ℳℰⒾ ♔♚♛Queen Of The Fat Cats♛♚♔ AMYzing review, Melanie chan!!!

ⒶH-ℳℰⒾ ♔♚♛Queen Of The Fat Cats♛♚♔ yahoo the paperback and ebooks are reasonably priced!!!

Hollis I was living for your updates on this book!

message 7: by Jaguar (new)

Jaguar IT'S ANOTHER ARMYYYYY!!!!!!!!!!!!! (Sorry! I get excited when I see people who love BTS!) I 💜 you!

message 8: by Penny (new) - added it

Penny I read this book because you spoke so highly of it! and OMGOSH it's AMAZING! I loved it so much! basically this is me in a book and I'm SO happy you brought it to my attention! <333 Luv you, girlie! :D

message 9: by Rae (new) - rated it 5 stars

Rae SAME!!! Wait you guys wanna be in my ARMY family?

Melanie Cheryl wrote: "I don't know how to start reading"


Melanie Taasia ✨ wrote: "Yes! I had a feeling you'd love it :)"

you know me, bb! 💖xx

Melanie Tracy wrote: "One of the very few books that has made me laugh out loud."


Melanie Ⓐℳⓨ ( pronounced Ⓐh-ℳeⓨ) ♔AntiExpensive books ProHiddengems Queen♔ wrote: "AMYzing review, Melanie chan!!!

thank you, love! 💖xx

Melanie Hollis wrote: "I was living for your updates on this book!"

my heart! i love you, sweet friend. 💖xx

Melanie BulletProofBoyScout- wrote: "IT'S ANOTHER ARMYYYYY!!!!!!!!!!!!! (Sorry! I get excited when I see people who love BTS!) I 💜 you!"

MY HEART! Trust me, nothing makes me more excited in my life currently! Bless you, bb! and i love youuu! 💖xx

Melanie Rae wrote: "SAME!!! Wait you guys wanna be in my ARMY family?"

YES! 💖xx

Melanie Penny wrote: "I read this book because you spoke so highly of it! and OMGOSH it's AMAZING! I loved it so much! basically this is me in a book and I'm SO happy you brought it to my attention! <333 Luv you, girlie..."

gosh, i love you SO much, penny! ahhhh! thank you for this comment and your friendship! 💖xx

message 18: by Celianor (new)

Celianor I've been an Army for almost 5 years and i'd absolutely read this book thank you so much for recommending it , it amazes me sometimes how big this fandom is

message 19: by Tucker (new)

Tucker  (TuckerTheReader) Thanks for the seizure trigger warning. I have seizures and get super anxious whenever they're discussed. I'll be sure to look out for that when I read this! 💕

message 20: by Daniela Esmoris (new)

Daniela Esmoris Esta bueno

message 21: by g (new)

g awsome book ay

message 22: by g (new)

g I thought it was just great

Hayley Bahnemann Hello fellow Army! I also felt a personal connection to this book in many ways, some similar to yours and some different. But Emma Mills books are now auto buy for me and I'm not sorry about it :)

back to top