Nicole's Reviews > Atlantia

Atlantia by Ally Condie
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
1150241
's review

liked it

I didn't love Matched by Ally Condie so I'm not sure why I decided to pick up Atlantia. Maybe because I thought there were a few redeeming qualities in Matched, at least enough for me to give Condie a second chance. The plot also intrigued me, and I was looking for something easy to read and entertaining to read over the holidays.

Well, Atlantia certainly fit the bill for easy to read and it was entertaining enough that I finished it. However, it had many of the same disappointments that I found in Matched. It's difficult not to compare the two books because they are both dystopian fiction for teens, written by the same author.

In both books I was quickly drawn in to the premise, the excitement of exploring a new world, and the anticipation of how the story and characters could develop within the rules of the new world. I think the author did a better job of creating a believable world for Atlantia than she did with Matched. I didn't find myself questioning so much whether the human responses were plausible given the circumstances. I was actually quite impressed by the beginning of the book. I loved how Condie "showed" me the rules of the world she had created rather than "told." The pacing was quick and engaging, and the world itself was interesting and had some unique aspects. Through the first quarter of the book I had high hopes that it was going to succeed where Matched had failed me.

At the halfway mark, unfortunately, my hopes crumbled. The book centers around conflict between the world Below (the city Atlantia which was built in a "bubble" on the ocean floor) and the world Above (the world we inhabit). The main characters and the storytelling begins Below, but it's clear early on that the story will, at some point, have to continue Above. I was disappointed and bored to get halfway through and still be building to the point where the action would switch to Above. I knew at that point that there was going to be rushed action to the climax and rushed resolution in order to wrap up the story in the number of pages left.

I was right. I didn't get nearly the feel or Above that I needed to balance the care that had been taken to show me Below. The characters Above were weak without the needed development and I didn't care for them like I needed to in order to really care about the plot. In the world Below the author used mystery and the characters' gradual discovery of important information to build tension. A little over halfway through that method completely broke down and information just starts getting handed out left and right. It felt like the author knew how she wanted to wrap it all up, but she didn't have a great grasp on the steps needed to get there. She spent an overly long time building up which could have been ok if the same care had been taken in the action and resolution. But instead it just fell flat and became forgettable.

I debated on whether to give 2 or 3 stars. I settled on 3 because I respect the potential of the author's ideas. I even liked the poetic style she tried to give her prose. I felt like it fit the idea of an underwater civilization that worships "the Gods." Had she just been able to balance the story elements better it would have been a satisfying entertainment escape.

See more of my reviews at thereaderssalon.com
flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Atlantia.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 20, 2017 – Started Reading
December 22, 2017 – Shelved
December 23, 2017 – Finished Reading

No comments have been added yet.