Melanie's Reviews > Legendary

Legendary by Stephanie Garber
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3030788
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: magic, mystery, young-adult, romance, fantasy, arc, read-in-2018, buddy-reads


ARC provided by Flatiron in exchange for an honest review.

1.) Caraval ★★★★

“But the best villains are the ones you secretly like, and my nana always said Legend was the villain in Caraval.”

I know that Caraval was a super polarizing read last year when it released, but I fell on the side of totally loving. From the game, to the mystery, to the lyrical writing, to the compelling characters, I couldn’t get enough. I devoured it in two sittings and never wanted to stop the reading experience. And guess what? Legendary was no different.

In Caraval we follow Scarlett and watch her run away from her home, and her abusive father, so that she can try to rescue her sister, Donatella, by winning the magical game of Caraval. Well, immediately after the outcome from Caraval, Legendary picks right up. Except this time, we follow Donatella, and she has stumbled on her own very own mystery and her very own game. And forget everything you think you learned in Caraval, because this trilogy takes a completely new approach, with completely new twists and turns, in Legendary.

“Legend has chosen you to play a game that may change your destiny.
In honor of Empress Elantine’s 75th birthday,
Caraval will visit the streets of Valenda for six magical nights.”

The invitations are distributed and a brand-new game of Caraval is going to begin, in a brand-new empire that is ruled by a very powerful empress. And this time Tella has decided to play so that she too has a chance to locate someone who has disappeared from her and Scarlett’s lives, their mother. Paloma was truly a woman of mystery, but we are able to see a few flashbacks that Tella has of her mother, along with a few of the keepsakes that Tella has kept all these years.

“For it was also said the Prince of Hearts was not capable of love, because his heart had stopped beating long ago. Only one person could make it beat again: his one true love. They said his kiss had been fatal to all but her—his only weakness—and as he’d sought her, he’d left a trail of corpses.”

We also get to see that a magical card prophesied that Tella would be a victim of unrequited love for her entire life. So, a ring that appears to be more than just a ring, and a card (think Tarot cards) that Tella took against her mother’s will, is all she has as clues. That is, until she meets someone who knows much more about that particular card, and the entire Deck of Destiny. And Tella ends up trying to win Caraval for this new stranger, for her mother, for her heart, for her life, and for Legend himself. Because the only way Tella will ever see her mother again is to win this game.

This book also had a bit more romance than Caraval, but I was completely living for it. And I’m still living for it, honestly. And like, we are maybe about to get a love triangle and I’m still totally here for it. And some of these scenes were legit 11/10, and I completely recommend. Also, I’m still swooning over Dante. But I also can’t stop thinking about Jacks and love that good angst. Be still, my heart.

“I’ve never wanted to be someone else until that moment I saw him kiss you on the dance floor.”

Okay, now I don’t want to gush too hard on you all, but you want to know what this book reminded me of? The Cruel Prince and The Wicked King by Holly Black. And chapter thirteen was such a work of art. Probably the best chapter I’ve read in any book in all of 2018.

So, why did I end up giving this four stars and not five with glowing sentences like the paragraph above this one? With so many twists and turns throughout this book, all of which blindsided me and made me fall more and more in love, the ending ended up being so predictable. Like, to the point that I thought it couldn’t be real, and that the epilogue was going to pull the wool from my eyes. But no, the disappointment just stayed. Which is so sad, because this book was so good, and such a treat to read in every single way, but the ending just made this amazing book really end on a bad note.

“Tella would destroy the world before she allowed anything to happen to her sister.”

Also, there wasn’t as much of a positive sibling emphasis in this book. Like, Tella was 100% committed to Scarlett, and we know from Caraval that Scarlett was 100% committed to Tella, but Legendary didn’t do anything to help enforce that percentage. Scarlett was honestly kind of a hot mess in this book, from start to (especially) end. I pray that Finale is either entirely in Tella’s point of view or it switches between Scarlett and Tella’s point of view. I don’t think I can deal with another solo Scarlett book after her actions in Legendary.

But overall, I really did love reading this. Again, I know not everyone does, but I just love Stephanie Garber’s writing and purple prose so much. I completely connect with it, and it completely immerses. I always feel like I’m there for all six nights of Caraval, in the castles, carriages, balls, and cathedrals. Also, these books and their settings are such aesthetic goals, I swear! Plus, this entire series is such a love letter to morally grey characters! I can’t wait to see how this all wraps up in the last book, Finale.

Blog | Instagram | Twitter | Tumblr | Youtube | Twitch

The quotes above were taken from an ARC and are subject to change upon publication.

Buddy read with Amy at A Court of Crowns and Quills! ❤
235 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Legendary.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

September 29, 2017 – Shelved
September 29, 2017 – Shelved as: to-read
September 29, 2017 – Shelved as: magic
September 29, 2017 – Shelved as: mystery
September 29, 2017 – Shelved as: young-adult
September 29, 2017 – Shelved as: romance
September 29, 2017 – Shelved as: fantasy
May 17, 2018 – Shelved as: arc
May 17, 2018 – Shelved as: read-in-2018
May 23, 2018 – Started Reading
May 23, 2018 –
page 106
25.48% "I know Caraval wasn’t a lot of my friends’ favorite, but holy moly Legendary is so good. Chapter 13 is highkey one of the best things I’ve read all year. All The Wicked King vibes. I never want this story to be over. 💛✨"
May 25, 2018 – Finished Reading
May 29, 2018 – Shelved as: buddy-reads

Comments Showing 1-12 of 12 (12 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Katie.dorny Omg that cover looks beautiful. I’m so ready for this book to be out!!


Melanie Katie.dorny wrote: "Omg that cover looks beautiful. I’m so ready for this book to be out!!"

It was such a fun read, Katie! I really enjoyed this one! And Chapter 13 was... everything, I swear! Hehe! Happy reading this Tuesday and always! 💗xx


message 3: by Amy (new) - rated it 4 stars

Amy Risner Amazing review as always, Melanie! Completely agree with everything you said. And omg, I really hope Finale won’t solely follow Scarlett because she really was a hot mess in this one. Thank you for buddy reading and swooning over everything with me! ❤️


Melanie Amy wrote: "Amazing review as always, Melanie! Completely agree with everything you said. And omg, I really hope Finale won’t solely follow Scarlett because she really was a hot mess in this one. Thank you for..."

Awh, thank you, Amy love, for this buddy read and your friendship! Such a dang blessing! Happy reading, love! 💗xx


(Bern) Mom to 2 Posh Lil Divas Fantastic review Melanie. I too loved Caraval & have been looking forward to reading this one.


Yusra  ✨ amazing review!! is there any more Julian in this one? he was kinda the highlight of Caraval for me 🤤


message 7: by Jaime (new) - added it

Jaime Stilwell Great review! I had the same issues with Caraval's ending. It was just so anticlimactic and a let down. Still excited for this, but it's sad that we have to have another meh ending. Hopefully the third book will be better about that.


Melanie (Bern) Mom to 2 Posh Lil Divas wrote: "Fantastic review Melanie. I too loved Caraval & have been looking forward to reading this one."

Awh, thank you so much, love! You are too kind! And I hope you absolutely love this one! Happy reading! 💗xx


Melanie Yusra wrote: "amazing review!! is there any more Julian in this one? he was kinda the highlight of Caraval for me 🤤"

Thank you, Yusra love! And, sadly, there isn't much Julian! Also... You know what? Just DM me when you finish. I'm very curious how you'll feel about the end of this one! Hahah! I love you and hope you're having the happiest of reading! 💗xx


Melanie Jaime wrote: "Great review! I had the same issues with Caraval's ending. It was just so anticlimactic and a let down. Still excited for this, but it's sad that we have to have another meh ending. Hopefully the t..."

Thank you so much, Jaime love! And hopefully it was just me that didn't love the ending! I have a few friends who did! I hope you have the happiest of reading, love! And you'll have to let me know how you end up feeling! 💗xx


Hanna Just saw this, I couldn't really connect with Scarlett on the first book, so what happened here concerning her didn't faze me, but I really liked Tella best! I hope that Finale will have more Tella than Scarlett, if it's split between 2 POVs, because I just can't with Scarlett.
Great review as always! <3


Jasmine I totally agree with Scarlett. I love her, but I’m the last few chapters in the book, her actions just seem dumb. Especially about Julian and the Count.


back to top