Terry's Reviews > Anna Karenina
Anna Karenina
by
by
In the beginning, reading Anna Karenin can feel a little like visiting Paris for the first time. You’ve heard a lot about the place before you go. Much of what you see from the bus you recognize from pictures and movies and books. You can’t help but think of the great writers and artists who have been here before you. You expect to like it. You want to like it. But you don’t want to feel like you have to like it. You worry a little that you won’t. But after a few days, you settle in, and you feel the immensity of the place opening up all around you. You keep having this experience of turning a corner and finding something beautiful that you hadn’t been told to expect or catching sight of something familiar from a surprising angle. You start to trust the abundance of the place, and your anxieties that someone else will have eaten everything up before your arrival relax. (Maybe that simile reveals more about me than I’d like.)
My favorite discovery was the three or four chapters (out of the book’s 239) devoted to, of all things, scythe mowing—chapters that become a celebratory meditation on physical labor. When I read those chapters, I felt temporarily cured of the need to have something “happen” and became as absorbed in the reading as the mowers are absorbed in their work. Of course, the book is about Anna and Vronsky and Levin and Kitty and Dolly and poor, stupid Stepan Arkadyich. It’s about their love and courtship and friendship and pride and shame and jealousy and betrayal and forgiveness and about the instable variety of happiness and unhappiness. But it’s also about mowing the grass and arguing politics and hunting and working as a bureaucrat and raising children and dealing politely with tedious company. To put it more accurately, it’s about the way that the human mind—or, as Tolstoy sometimes says, the human soul—engages each of these experiences and tries to understand itself, the world around it, and the other souls that inhabit that world. This book is not afraid to take up any part of human life because it believes that human beings are infinitely interesting and infinitely worthy of compassion. And, what I found stirring, the book’s fearlessness extends to matters of religion. Tolstoy takes his characters seriously enough to acknowledge that they have spiritual lives that are as nuanced and mysterious as their intellectual lives and their romantic lives. I knew to expect this dimension of the book, but I could not have known how encouraging it would be to dwell in it for so long.
In the end, this is a book about life, written by a man who is profoundly in love with life. Reading it makes me want to live.
My favorite discovery was the three or four chapters (out of the book’s 239) devoted to, of all things, scythe mowing—chapters that become a celebratory meditation on physical labor. When I read those chapters, I felt temporarily cured of the need to have something “happen” and became as absorbed in the reading as the mowers are absorbed in their work. Of course, the book is about Anna and Vronsky and Levin and Kitty and Dolly and poor, stupid Stepan Arkadyich. It’s about their love and courtship and friendship and pride and shame and jealousy and betrayal and forgiveness and about the instable variety of happiness and unhappiness. But it’s also about mowing the grass and arguing politics and hunting and working as a bureaucrat and raising children and dealing politely with tedious company. To put it more accurately, it’s about the way that the human mind—or, as Tolstoy sometimes says, the human soul—engages each of these experiences and tries to understand itself, the world around it, and the other souls that inhabit that world. This book is not afraid to take up any part of human life because it believes that human beings are infinitely interesting and infinitely worthy of compassion. And, what I found stirring, the book’s fearlessness extends to matters of religion. Tolstoy takes his characters seriously enough to acknowledge that they have spiritual lives that are as nuanced and mysterious as their intellectual lives and their romantic lives. I knew to expect this dimension of the book, but I could not have known how encouraging it would be to dwell in it for so long.
In the end, this is a book about life, written by a man who is profoundly in love with life. Reading it makes me want to live.
1345 likes · Like
∙
flag
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Anna Karenina.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
April 27, 2008
– Shelved
Started Reading
June 19, 2008
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-50 of 87 (87 new)
message 1:
by
Frank
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Jun 20, 2008 08:41PM
Beautiful review, Terry. Makes me want to read the book.
reply
|
flag
*
That's the best review! I felt exactly like you describe feeling in your first paragraph there. This book is JUST LIKE visiting Paris. Actually, I haven't been to Paris so for me, it was like visiting Rome - but yep - same feelings.
This is the best review of any book I've ever read. I love my memories of reading Anna Karenina and going to Paris all the more for it.
I think you have written an excellent summary of the experience of reading this novel. I find it amazing and am looking forward to a third reading soon.I have nothing to add to your remarks save that each character has the weight of Anna, she is the central figure that they all have some relation, distant or otherwise to.
You have captured the true essence of this work far more eloquently than I ever could and in particular I find your reference to the mowing a perfect reference for how often I felt like I was there,and I have never been to Russia! I would be interested in running into more of your reviews, Terry.
I love this description because at the beginning I didn't think I would ever finish now I love it. Wish I had more time to read:)
Loved this, thanks! This could be a dumb question, but it stood out to me and I don't understand it - do you have any insights into why all along he mentions Anna wearing rings, and at the end he mentions Kitty wearing rings? I had assumed it signified Anna being shackled to elements of worldliness, so then was confused as to why Kitty is wearing them in the end.
I was enthralled throughout the novel but was particularly taken with the chapter on mowing, as well. As a
Absolutely touching and feeling review. It is worth reading your review again and again, over and over. With deep respect for these beautifull words right from your soul. Did you already write a book yourself? If i may adise you start writing your own book, perhaps about places you loved to experience in your life? Or about your visits to other cities? Or about visiting restaurants and your experience with the food and environment? If you ever have your book written, please inform me and make it available for me at a buying price. thanks for your review and wonderful words.
I agree - the mowing/scything scene evoked the same feeling in me when I read it. I pictured Frost's poem "Mowing" and that delicious pleasure in that simple action. You're absolutely right: this is a book about life! :)
I felt the same!!!! Excelent review! Another part that I simply loved is on Book 5, Chapter 14. When Levin compares married life with admiring the course of a little boat ;) Absolutly great!
Milou Pujol wrote: "I felt the same!!!! Excelent review! Another part that I simply loved is on Book 5, Chapter 14. When Levin compares married life with admiring the course of a little boat ;) Absolutly great!"
Yes. That's a beautiful (and wise) moment. I may need to reread this book soon... I'm starting to forget parts of it...
Terry wrote: "Milou Pujol wrote: "I felt the same!!!! Excelent review! Another part that I simply loved is on Book 5, Chapter 14. When Levin compares married life with admiring the course of a little boat ;) Ab..."
Yes!!! This was my second time reading it and I discovered a lot more :-) some books have a different impact dependig your age or livings
What a wonderful review! I tried to read Anna Karenina twice when I was a teenager, but (I don't remember exactly why, I guess I found it boring) I gave up after a few pages. You made me want to give it another chance now that I'm older and wiser, lol :)(Please ignore any language mistakes since I'm not a native English speaker)
I totally felt and understood your words every single word. I love this novel truly. Simply its all the world. What i love the most is The way Leo Tolstoy describes the tinny changes in Anna's emotions,feelings which is so great amazing. How great and poor Anna is!
I'm half Russian, and I felt mandatory to read the great Russian authors in my teenager years. But this is a book you have to read later on in life, when you are a bit more mature...Absolutely accurate review Terry, you were able to put in words what I feel reading it for the second time, more settled and grown up. Beautiful book, I just wish you could have read it in Russian...it so truly represents Russians, our culture, our way to see life and our struggles.
Thank you for the beautiful review!
I have not heart much about this book which may be strangely enough. I am glad I came across your review. I want to fall into story immediately!
Your review is so truthful. I completely agree, I feel related to that feeling about liking or disliking books that are considered masterpieces and the fear of not being able to appreciate them.
What a great review. Your first paragraph can be applied to so many novels, and I thoroughly enjoyed the review of the book as well. I think your well thought out and worded review will speak to people who may be on the fence about reading Anna Karenina and trying out Leo Tolstoy. Really, I'm also sure your review articulates many readers experiences with the novel in a way we simply couldn't. Love that this Anna Karenina review is reserved as a digital record for others to find and be encouraged to read or re-read this book.
Great review. I had the fun of reading this book aloud to my future husband in the evenings over a period of several weeks as we traveled together, about 22 years ago. We had the luxury of abundant time and enjoying our book group of two. I remember the same feeling of getting a sense of the totality and wonder of life. I remember the beautiful description of the harvesting! And the happiness of Levin and Kitty's strong marriage as a counterpoint to Anna and Vronsky. It was a joy to read.
I've just finished this wonderful novel. Terry's review was just what I needed to gather my thoughts and feelings together about it. I've needed two weeks of relatively undistracted reading(give or take a family wedding in Jakarta and climbing Mt Batu in Bali). It's like entering another world, and feeling you are part of that world. This is what all great novelists such as Jane Austen achieve for their readers. But Anna Karenin (the A is left out in my Penguin Classics translation) is far more universal in its embrace than the Austen novels, taking in all of life - birth, marriage, death, work, politics, war....I agree about the scything and how the rhythm of the description takes you over. Above all it is Tolstoy's ability to get into the thoughts and feelings of the men and women in the book, delicately and subtly describing the small changes, responses, reactions in them, that is remarkable.What must it be like to read it in Russian?
So glad I stumbled upon the book without any prior knowledge of who Leo Tolstoy was so there was no pressure,it was more about curiousity and boy was it aroused coz I've never put the book down since day 1.
Beautiful review. I read this book so many years ago and since I have seen the newest movie and am currently watching the hulu series based on the story, set in modern times, A Beautiful Lie. It all makes me want to go back and re-read the book as daunting as the length is. I was 20 something when I read it. At 47, surely it'd be a different book.
I would say this is a beautiful review, but everyone siad it already! Oh well, what a beautiful review. I could sure use a life affirming book to read. I'm in the beginning about page 100 and am enjoying it a lot so far.
I am in the middle of the book and I totally agree with you. so many parts of the history that weren't familiar to me! And it's such an easy comforting reading. beautifully reviewed!























