EmmaMarie Hunneyball's Reviews > A Clash of Kings

A Clash of Kings by George R.R. Martin
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Aug 30, 2011

really liked it
Read from March 05 to April 17, 2012

Whilst reading this book I was forcibly reminded of the movie "The NeverEnding Story". In the film, Bastian has read many classic books such as 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea and Robinson Crusoe but Mr Koreander scorns his taste;

Mr. Koreander: Listen. Have you ever been Captain Nemo, trapped inside your submarine while the giant squid is attacking you?
Bastian: Yes.
Mr. Koreander: Weren't you afraid you couldn't escape?
Bastian: But it's only a story.
Mr. Koreander: That's what I'm talking about. The ones you read are safe.
Bastian: And that one isn't?

In most books you have a rough idea of the direction of the narrative, you broadly know that Professor Aronax will survive even if Captain Nemo can never rejoin society; that Lizzie Bennett will get married; that Dorian Gray will have to answer to a higher power for his crimes. The main draw is not what will happen in the end, but how the characters will get to their ending. They are safe.

"A Song of Ice and Fire" is not "safe". You can have no measure of certainty over where the story is going, or how it will affect the characters, or indeed whether the characters will live to see the end of it. Book 2 opens with the main players of Book 1 dead, background characters now come to the front, and plans which once seemed certain are thrown into disarray.

Book 1 belonged to Daenerys Targaryen. The slow burning narrative was driven forward by her difficult journey from child fugitive to Queen-in-waiting in little more than a year. In book 2 the drive is provided by the story of Theon Greyjoy, one of the background characters I kept forgetting about in book 1. His story is masterfully told: he's a man with two fathers who is struggling to live up to the ideals of either: too refined and civilised for Balon Greyjoy, not honourable or selfless enough for Ned Stark. His actions and dealings with his birth family and his adoptive family have far-reaching consequences and his story is masterfully told.

Theon's story is a flagship tale which is echoed through other storylines: children attempt to live up to, or defy their fathers: Joffrey Baratheon is another character with two fathers and he embodies the worst of both of them as he rebels against his family and creates a reign of terror. Ramsay Stone fights against the contempt he receives at being labelled a "bastard": he assumes Roose Bolton's family name and crest when riding to Winterfell to prove his worth. Tyrion Lannister effortlessly lives up to Lord Tywin's intelligence and strategic planning, while Robb Stark has to defy his mother in order to fully take on the mantel of his father.

A secondary theme in the book is that of hidden identities: Asha Greyjoy, Gendry, Arya Stark and Ramsay Stone all gain advantage by pretending to be someone else, while Theon Greyjoy causes himself problems by getting others to switch identities, to save face, as it were, when things look bad.

The backdrop to the story is the struggle between heirs assumptive to the throne, but in reality this is about power struggles and betrayal within families. There is no-one more dangerous to Tyrion Lannister than his own family; Stannis and Renly Baratheon are brothers at open war with each other; the Starks breed their own danger.

Of course this continues the running theme of legitimacy and illegitimacy; in a realm where none of the contenders has a solid claim to the throne each tries to cement his position, and it is the bastards and outsiders, Jon; Tyrion; Joffrey; Ramsay; Theon and Stannis who wield the most power.

As in book 1 the vast array of characters is bewildering: I again forgot who many of them were and started glossing over them. I think this is a major flaw in the work and it's becoming more pronounced: as some of these background characters take centre stage it's difficult to remember who they are or where they came from.

The fragmented narrative is rather distracting: each narrative is genuinely engaging and gripping, but it is always broken off to move to someone else's story. I had to spend a while at the start of a few chapters reminding myself where each character was up to, and getting back into the story, before the focus switched again.

These flaws aside, this is a rich, well-drawn world with colourful characters and no end of suspense and surprises.

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read A Clash of Kings.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

No comments have been added yet.