Terry 's Reviews > Scaramouche

Scaramouche by Rafael Sabatini
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Aug 30, 2011

it was amazing
bookshelves: swashbuckler, historical-fiction, audio-books, favorites
Recommended for: lovers of swashbucklers, historical fiction and witty repartee

I wavered between four and five stars on this one, but I totally have to go with the five. It’s just that awesome. I was actually a little surprised at how much I loved this book. I mean, I love swashbucklers and historical fiction…Dumas père is my man, but the only other Sabatini novel I’ve read, Venetian Masque, I found to be a little underwhelming so I did not expect this from Sabatini. Speaking of Dumas, I almost think that _Scaramouche_ can be placed in the same company as that master’s great work _The Count of Monte Cristo_, no small praise from me. It doesn’t quite have the same level of intricate plotting as the latter, and I will never give pride of place to any but Monsieur le Comte, but it is still an awesome read filled with exciting ups and downs as we follow the trials and triumphs of the title character aka Andre-Louis Moreau. I actually noticed that Moreau shared some similarities with Dantès as a character, at least in the fact that both of them seemed to have a Batman-like ability to adopt nearly any skill they required to further their own ends. For Moreau this leads him to start out as a lawyer with exceptional reasoning and speaking skills, become a brilliant actor, stage writer and theatre impresario, then move on to master the art of the sword and become a maître d'armes, and finally to enter the realm of politics all within a span of two years. That’s ok, I don’t mind it if my heroes are super and Moreau pairs his ability with an acerbic wit and keen insight I found both refreshing and awesome.

I have to add here that I ‘read’ this as an audiobook downloaded from Librivox. Now the narrators from Librivox, given that it is a free site, can be…how to put this delicately? Crappy. Not so this one. The narrator Gordon Mackenzie was fantastic. He had just the right pacing, didn’t stumble on his words (you’d think that would be a prerequisite for narrating an audio book, wouldn’t you?), and was able to voice each character differently without sounding completely ludicrous. He even managed the French phrases and Latin epigrams with no apparent effort. Excellent job Mr. Mackenzie! I really think his work on this added to my already superlative enjoyment of the text itself.

Given that this is a classic I imagine that many already know the plot, at least in broad strokes: Andre-Louis Moreau is a bastard of no name, taken in as the “godson” of the local seigneur of the village of Gavrillac (amidst the knowing glances and whispers of the locals). He is a young man of intelligence and wit, known primarily for his acerbic tongue and incisive reasoning, who acts as the legal representative of his godfather, M. de Kercadiou. His best friend, Philippe de Vilmorin, is a young seminarian who also happens to have revolutionary political leanings. When a local peasant is summarily killed by a local noble, the Marquis de la Tour d'Azyr, Philippe tries to convince the nobleman to recompense the dead man’s family for the deed. Incensed, and sensing in the eloquent young man one who could stir the mounting discontent of the people that is beginning to raise its head in France, d’Azyr decides he must get rid of this possible thorn in the side of his class. An expert fencer, perhaps the best in France, d’Azyr forces the fledgling Philippe into challenging him to a duel and handily dispatches the young man, whose own abilities with the sword are non-existent. It is this act of bald-faced murder (and the subsequent inability of the young lawyer to gain any justice from the established powers) that sends young Bruce Wayne, er Andre-Louis, on his road of vengeance against the man, and the class, that killed his friend in cold blood.

As we follow Andre-Louis in his quest we see him taking up the mantle left by his dead friend and using his own eloquence to stir up the crowds against their unjust masters. Forced into hiding when his name and actions become know, Moreau manages to join a travelling band of actors who mount plays based on the fading style of the Commedia dell'Arte and, after establishing himself as not only an excellent actor and writer, but even a company manager of some skill Moreau takes on the role of Scaramouche (one that is uniquely suited to his outlook and abilities) and proceeds to lead the troupe to the verge of fame and fortune. Along the way he falls in love and ultimately finds himself once again crossing paths with his avowed enemy, seemingly driven by the hand of fate. Moreau encounters numerous dangers and escapes in his years of hiding which I won’t recount here…read the book and enjoy them to the full yourself! Suffice it to say that the nascent revolution turns the tables and thrusts Andre-Louis into a position of power. It is a position that is not so easily taken advantage of, despite Andre-Louis’ apparent single-mindedness in regards to his quest, and the conclusion of the tale is satisfying and much more complex than one might be given to expect from a work in this genre.

I thought Sabatini’s prose was great. His turns of phrase, especially in the mouth of Moreau, were sublime and the text is littered with an abundance of bon mots. His characters also shine and often manage to attain a level of complexity that goes beyond the one dimensional duality of good-guy/bad-guy one might expect. While I was always cheering for Moreau and loved his character, he is not always an eminently likeable guy and even the sneering and vain arch-rival the Marquis de la Tour d'Azyr manages to show himself to be something more complex than a mustachio-twirling villain. Bottom line: this book was great. I don’t know why I took so long to read it, but I’m very glad I finally did. I’ll be revisiting this one many times in the future.

Highly recommended.

Also posted at Shelf Inflicted
44 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Scaramouche.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

August 30, 2011 – Shelved
February 18, 2012 – Started Reading
February 18, 2012 – Shelved as: swashbuckler
February 18, 2012 – Shelved as: historical-fiction
February 18, 2012 – Shelved as: audio-books
February 21, 2012 –
page 32
February 22, 2012 –
page 79
February 23, 2012 –
page 144
February 24, 2012 –
page 166
46.24% "This book rocks my socks!"
February 27, 2012 –
page 191
February 29, 2012 –
page 227
March 1, 2012 –
page 274
March 2, 2012 –
page 303
March 7, 2012 – Shelved as: favorites
March 7, 2012 – Finished Reading

Comments (showing 1-21 of 21) (21 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Richard (new)

Richard Derus ...!!!... Coolness!

Terry Oh yes. I didn't feel like leaving Revolutionary France, so it's time to buckle some swashes!

message 3: by Jeffrey (new)

Jeffrey Keeten Excellent review, I've added it to my list.

Terry I think you'll really enjoy this book. A well-deserved classic.

Noran Miss Pumkin Thanks_I am enjoying the audio right now-great narrator!

Terry He is great, isn't he? Quite a surpise considering it's Librivox. Enjoy!

message 7: by Richard (new)

Terry Yes, I hope it lives up to this one! I may also have to revisit Venetian Masque...maybe my blasé first impression of it was due to bad book bio-rhythms and not the book itself.

message 9: by Richard (new)

Richard Derus "Bad book bio-rhythms"! Wonderful...stealing.

Terry I think I actually stole that from someone else, but I don't remember who, so I'll take credit. :)

message 11: by Richard (new)

Richard Derus Multiple thievery central, this is (insert alias here), may I rob you?

Mike (the Paladin) This is my favorite Sabatini book...it's among my all time favorite reads. His books can run a bit hot and cold but there are some great reads. Have you read Captain Blood? It's another excellent read for we vicarious swash bucklers.

message 13: by Steve (new)

Steve This sounds terrific! Your review was the perfect sales pitch, Terry. You have a surplus of credibility when it comes to books of this sort.

Brenda ╰☆╮   Loved Scaramouche. Read it as a teen.....my dad had a copy and enjoyed his books. I'll have to read it again, since it's no long fresh in my mind.
I also liked Costain.... The Black Rose, The Silver Chalice and Below the Salt were some I remember. I'm not sure they hold up the same for me. I tried a reread recently and didn't feel as interested.

message 15: by Kyle (new) - added it

Kyle A classic I've yet to get around to, but it definitely sounds like it could be my cup of tea. Wonderful review Terry!

Terry @Mike, I've definitely found Sabatini hot and cold...almost abnormally so. _Scaramouche is so awesome that I find it hard to believe he wrote some of the other books I've read by him. I have been currently reading The Marquis of Carabas for some time now and I don't know if I'll even finish it...it's not actively bad, but pretty blase.

@Steve, thanks for the kind words! You definitely must read this book (and The Count of Monte Cristo if you have not already done so).

@Brenda, I've never checked out Costain, but will give him a look-see.

@Kyle, thanks and definitely check it out.

Mike (the Paladin) I love Count also. I checked your swash buckling shelf for recommendations. We agree on the sub-genre I think, LOL.

Sarah this book is awesomeness awesomer than Prussia...! Almost. My favorite characters are Philippe, Bertrand de Amis, Leandre, Andre-Louis, obviously, and le Chapelier. Two of 'em died though... :( I LOVE THIS BOOK!

message 19: by Hari (new)

Hari Had read an abridged version of Scaramouche in my childhood͵ and later the full version was so captivating been reading it from time to time since then. My favourite parts of the novel 1) the duel between Andre and Azyr 2) The chapter dealing with how Andre became an expert at fencing 3) The fracas at the Feydau theatre 4) The climax when Andre discovers truths ! Truly this book made my life vastly more enjoyable !

Terry It is a great book, isn't it?

message 21: by Sarah (new) - added it

Sarah I've been looking for something to match The Count of Monte Cristo. Hopefully I've just found it....

back to top