Latanya (CraftyScribbles)'s Reviews > The Girl Who Fell from the Sky

The Girl Who Fell from the Sky by Heidi W. Durrow
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
24192262
(Check out the full review at http://www.craftyscribbles.com)

Rachel, sole survivor of a family tragedy navigates boxes others deem fitting for her. Will she choose, or will she set out to determine who she is on her own terms?

The Girl Who Fell From the Sky, a debut book, by Heidi W. Durrow, paints a picture of a young girl, born to an African-American father and a Danish mother, and her journey to reclaim what she believes herself to be in a world obsessed with categories, while realizing how hard choosing not to categorize one's self may be.
Rachel moves to Portland to live with her paternal grandmother in a mostly black community in the 1980s. She finds her light skin, blue eyes, and curly hair grants her beauty accolades at the cost of other girls and women. She's special while learning to swallow the grievous moments interlocking with peaceful days.

Throughout the book, readers glance at those categorizing her as the lone survivor of a sadness indescribable. Her mother, Nella, along with a witness, Brick/Jamie, and a mother's friend, Lavonne serve as the other eyes of Rachel's life.

While race centers the story, sexuality and coming of age follow as subsequent themes to create a gumbo worthy of reading.

At first glance, I shivered from an angry undercurrent permeating and worried whether I could finish this story. Earlier on, she gives indictments about the black community she lives in and judges them based on the little knowledge she has on black people. For example, she mocks their vernacular and appearances, unless she likes them (e.g. Aunt Loretta). My eyes rolled in sweat. She "othered" herself before others boxed her with an air of supremacy I've witnessed from the "Tragic Mulatto" cliche. I closed the book, at first, because I decided not to continue.

However, after a breathe or two, I continued, hoping Durrow had something to say, other than propagating the "Tragic Mulatto" trope. As the chapters progressed and Rachel grew familiar with her new family and community, peeling back Rachel's layers, you see why she behaved in the manner she presented.

Her mother.

Constant confusion and chaos by a woman unsure of herself and unsure of how to raise her children, raised in fear, anxiety, and an unacknowledged discussion of their place in the world. She simply did not know who she was.

Once pieces created the puzzle, our eyes (Rachel and mine) opened, a silent dialogue began.

Pros:

1. A good story

2. Complex characterization

3. Believable dialogue

4. Constant opportunity for discussion beyond the page

5. Brick. Even though he's fictional, I wish the best for him - a young boy trying to find his way after witnessing that day.

6. Multiple points of view, garnering everyone's role in Rachel's literal and metaphorical fall from the sky

Cons:

1. Use of a her father's point of view once or twice (Not enough of a p.o.v. to give chapters)

2. I got confused when some information that came as the chapters passed (Who is Charlie?)

3. I still feel Rachel served as an avatar for Durrow's feelings about black people. She receives a side-eye with her pseudo-therapeutic approach.

4. Jesse. He showed his true colors. Yet, Durrow ends his arc without consequence - almost letting him get away with his actions when she wouldn't do the same for the black kids.

5. Her mother's reason for her action. Protection from society? What?

6. An open-ended ending that's a tad abrupt. I guess I would have liked more of a clear destination for Rachel. But, it's not my tale to tell.

Overall, I rated this book a 3.5 out of 5. The Girl Who Fell From The Sky attempts for an unflinching look at flight, but may leave you buying a train ticket to another story.

*This book happily sits on my bookshelf from my own funds*
19 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Girl Who Fell from the Sky.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

May 9, 2017 – Shelved
May 9, 2017 – Shelved as: to-read
May 12, 2017 – Started Reading
May 12, 2017 – Shelved as: african-american
May 12, 2017 – Shelved as: contemporary
May 12, 2017 – Shelved as: historical-fiction
May 12, 2017 – Shelved as: food-for-the-melaninated-soul
May 12, 2017 – Shelved as: realistic-fiction
May 12, 2017 –
10.0%
May 12, 2017 –
20.0%
May 14, 2017 –
26.0% "Durrow's angry at the black community. I feel her writing this story as some sort of exorcism. I can't help but side-eye various moments."
May 14, 2017 –
30.0% "I like the use of multiple p.o.v. Rachel, Brick, and Roger share perspectives. I wonder if they know they'll collide."
May 15, 2017 –
36.0% "There's a sadness permeating the pages. Witnessing people come and go without an emergency exit saddens me."
May 16, 2017 –
40.0%
May 16, 2017 –
45.0%
May 16, 2017 –
50.0% "Oh Brick. Go home."
May 18, 2017 –
55.0% ""The ghetto looks different in different places, but if you live there, it makes you feel the same."

Why didn't I write that line? It's true. It packs emotion that only those surviving accept. No matter the region, this line writes a truth many learn."
May 18, 2017 –
66.0%
May 18, 2017 –
73.0%
May 19, 2017 –
76.0% ""You're from Chicago. But, what are you? Like black, or - like me?"

"Oh, I'm black. Regular." He said "regular" like he was describing coffee without milk.

Rich language. Simple yet complex, conveying bonds within the initiated."
May 19, 2017 – Finished Reading
May 20, 2017 – Shelved as: ownvoices

No comments have been added yet.