Poonam's Reviews > Hidden Figures: The American Dream and the Untold Story of the Black Women Mathematicians Who Helped Win the Space Race

Hidden Figures by Margot Lee Shetterly
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
17656456
's review
Mar 31, 2017

liked it
bookshelves: historical, non-fiction, feminist, group-reads
Read from March 08 to 29, 2017 , read count: 1

This is my Book Of the Month- February-March 2017, with GR group- The Reading For Pleasure Book Club, Category: Non-Fiction Group Read.

This is one of the most celebrated books of this time and I had very high expectations from this book. I wanted to read this before watching the movie.

Now, the thing is the movie trailer somehow makes it come off as a motivational story with humorous undertones but in fact the book has absolutely NO humor in it!! And I say this because I found the writing very very dry. The content and the subject matter is fabulous because of which I cannot give it anything under 3 stars.

The problem which most of the non-fiction books generally have occurred here too. There is too much information dump, too many people mentioned that have no major role or any great significance in the story.

There are three main characters, Dorothy, Katheryn and Mary. Every-time we got a bit of interest in their stories the plot suddenly veered off mentioning other random people.*Sigh*.

Coming to the good parts- the content. This book was definitely an eye-opener for me. Things I did not realise--

People were heavily oppressed based on their skin color in America till 1960's.
"There were black jobs and there were good black jobs. Sorting in the laundry, making beds in white folk's houses, stemming in the tobacco plant- those were black jobs. Owning a barbershop or a funeral home, working in the post office, or riding the rails as a Pullman porter- those were good black jobs. Teacher, preacher, doctor, lawyer- now those were very good black jobs, bringing stability and the esteem that accompanied formal training."

Those times were definitely confusing as there we soo many apparent reasons a person could be mistreated.
"Bemused, Katherine considered the engineer's sudden departure. The moment that passed between them could have been because she was black and he was white. But then again, it could have been because she was a woman and he was a man. Or maybe the moment was an interaction between a professional and a subprofessional, an engineer and a girl."

And then there is the whole space program and the landing on the moon.
"Because of the overwhelming white public face of the space program, the black engineers, scientists, and mathematicians who were deeply involved with the space race nevertheless lived in its shadows, even within the black community."

It is appalling to read about the segregation which went on till about 1960's. Shocking that such things happened 50 or so yrs ago!!

It could have easily been a 4 or even a 5 star read but it was such a slow read for me. I could not even read it continuously and needed to put it down to digest all that information dump (that I ended up reading 4 other books while reading this one!)

I would recommend this to anyone who has lot's of patience and likes the subject matter mentioned in the above review.

P.S- I am planning to watch the movie soon. Have you seen it and what did you think about it?
36 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Hidden Figures.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

01/26 marked as: to-read
03/08 marked as: currently-reading
03/08
7.0% "Well, I am happy for Dorothy."
03/17
34.0% "Sooo many names, so much information dump :("
03/18
37.0% "Discrimination they had come to expect, if not accept. But the prospect of integration planned a new fear in the souls of Christine and fellow members of the Brown V. Board of Ed generation: that as blacks, they would not be good enough- smart enough- to sit next to whites in a classroom and succeed.
My God, it is appaling to think that this was the situation in 1954!"
03/20
43.0% "There were laws restricting her ability to apply for a credit card in her own name, because she was a woman. --I wasn't aware there was such a law EVER!"
03/29
100.0% "Review to come"
03/31 marked as: read

Comments (showing 1-6 of 6) (6 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by StMargarets (new)

StMargarets I adored the movie. It starts a bit slow and then you find yourself caught up with the characters. The acting is superb - and conveys the ambivalence of this passage without a word of dialogue.


"Bemused, Katherine considered the engineer's sudden departure. The moment that passed between them could have been because she was black and he was white. But then again, it could have been because she was a woman and he was a man. Or maybe the moment was an interaction between a professional and a subprofessional, an engineer and a girl."

I haven't read the book, but it sounds like this is one of those rare movies that is even better than the book.


Poonam StMargarets wrote: "I adored the movie. It starts a bit slow and then you find yourself caught up with the characters. The acting is superb - and conveys the ambivalence of this passage without a word of dialogue.


..."


I have to catch the movie soon. The trailer did look good which raised my expectations for the book!!


Blossomknitwear The movie is great. The book..... meh. Too dry for me.


message 4: by Poonam (last edited May 11, 2017 10:55AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Poonam Blossomknitwear wrote: "The movie is great. The book..... meh. Too dry for me."

The book.is definitely dry. Still got to catch-up on that movie.


Chetak Poonam, I couldn't agree more to you. I started book with high expectation, but took me almost more than month to finish reading it, as I need to digest what i have just read. I have also watched Movie, the facts that book missed, I think they took hold in it, there are no unnecessary characters unlike in book, you will get greatly connected with story and acting of those three ladies is superb !! Movie is highly recommended if you have finished reading.


Poonam Chetak wrote: "Poonam, I couldn't agree more to you. I started book with high expectation, but took me almost more than month to finish reading it, as I need to digest what i have just read. I have also watched M..."

I haven't yet had a chance to catch this movie but will definitely try to watch it soon.


back to top