AtenRa's Reviews > Pieces of Us

Pieces of Us by Margie Gelbwasser
Rate this book
Clear rating

's review
Jul 14, 2011

it was amazing
bookshelves: favourites, adult-fiction, contemporary

Wow. Pieces Of Us was an emotional hurricane of a book that despite all the anger and frustration I felt, I just couldn't put down.

I have to hand it to Gelbwasser, she had me from the first chapter. Even when I knew it was not gonna end well, I had to know, find out for myself. Like a car crush, I just couldn't look away. As I was reading I found myself feeling agitated, frustrated, angry and unbelievably sad that I couldn't do anything about Alex, I couldn't save Katie. I put the book down, tried to do other stuff to get my mind off it, but nothing would work. It was always about Alex,Katie,Julie and Kyle.

Each one of these kids was abused mentally or physically or both. Katie by her classmates, Julie by her insufferable, to put it lightly, mother, along with her own suffocating jealousy, Alex by his mom's boyfriends and dad's suicide and Kyle by his brother's dramatic character change. In my opinion, Kyle was the most likeable one, the originally "good" one. I liked how his chapters were in second person, like some faraway observant was documenting his life. like he couldn't trust himself to utter "I" for fear of realizing that all this was actually happening to him.
The character I felt the most animosity towards was first Alex and then Julie. However, as my anger towards their actions grew bigger and bigger, I realised that their behavior mostly stems from traumas of an awful childhood. Was that it though, I still wonder. When does psychological baggage stop and free will begin? How much of their bad behavior is justified? Can we all pin treating other people badly to childhood traumas and by doing that, can we automatically wash our hands of everything we do and never suffer any consequences? That's why in the end, I don't know if I felt sorry about those two. I feel like an awful person saying it but especially in Julie's case, she kinda chose to go down that path, regardless of whatever problems she had with her sister and her mom in the past. She craved for it, it seemed to me. She wanted it from the very beginning. She chose to bury her head in the sand as far as the Katie situation was concerned, telling herself that she is much stronger than her sister and that she can handle it. I really wanted to see how she and Alex ended up (no wonder they were the only ones who stayed to watch the chicken killings every year - chlling scenes, by the way!), but the ending was a bit abrupt and I guess we'll never know. I didn't like the ending at first, but in retrospect I am grateful to Gelbwasser for not prolonging their suffering and misery, or mine.

And how can I not be grateful to her for stirring up such strong feelings in me, even if they are a lot darker that what I'm used to? It was thrilling to get out of my comfort zone and read something this raw and real. So, thank you so much Margie Gelbwasser for writing Pieces Of Us :)

*****I had actually written half of this review when a GR friend informed me that people want Pieces Of Us banned because it has a blue cover and not a red one.
Wait. That's not it.
Oh, yes. Because it has a lot of sexual content for a YA novel. I knew it was something ridiculous like that.
Just when I thought I have finally understood people, they always surprise me and never in a good way. I will not try to educate people or make them less ignorant. They should know however, that Pieces of Us, apart from a YA book, it is also Realistic Fiction. Realistic Fiction=really happening. If you think these things are completely out of this world and don't happen, you're delusional, to say the least. What I am trying to say is that this is 2012 and whether you like it or not things change and the world goes forward, not backwards. Shocking, I know. It's called progress, deal with it.
I don't wish to be offensive, but when people who claim to be readers and book lovers want to to BAN a book, it simply drives me up the wall. Why don't we go back to the Middle Ages and just burn it instead? Tsk tsk tsk…
PS. If Forbidden by Tabitha Suzuma is considered YA, then damn if Pieces Of Us isn't as well!!

2 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Pieces of Us.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

July 14, 2011 – Shelved
February 21, 2012 – Started Reading
February 21, 2012 –
February 22, 2012 – Shelved as: favourites
February 22, 2012 – Shelved as: adult-fiction
February 22, 2012 – Shelved as: contemporary
February 22, 2012 – Finished Reading

Comments (showing 1-10 of 10) (10 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Kat Kennedy I'm so glad you liked it. I really liked it too. But calls for it to be banned? Really?

AtenRa NO WAY!!!!!You serious???
Just when you think people can't be any more hypocritical...
Like this stuff never happens, nooooo waaaaaay *shakes head*

Kat Kennedy Seriously, go check out non friend reviews. This book has so many 2 star reviews because people felt it was too graphic for a YA novel. Craziness.

AtenRa Is this about labels? Oh my god, seriously?
I respect people's opinions but this is apparently not about the book and whether it's good or not. It's all about the sexual content. Bottom line though is, is the book good or bad? It's good, end of.
It's so simple for me, I don't get how it's not so simple for others.

Aly (Fantasy4eva) it sounds amazing! did you read it on netgalley. can't find it :/

AtenRa Yep NG :)

Aly (Fantasy4eva) do you know if it's still on there? can't seem to find it.

AtenRa hm maybe they took it down because it's close to the pub date. Lemme look.


Yeah they took it down :(

Aly (Fantasy4eva) nooooooooooo. talk about bad luck! urgh. thanks anyway :)

AtenRa No worries. It comes out in like 9 days or so!

back to top