Jessica Jeffers's Reviews > Born a Crime: Stories From a South African Childhood
Born a Crime: Stories From a South African Childhood
by
by
Within the first twenty pages of this book, I regretted just two days earlier writing the sentence “Trevor Noah, while smart and funny, doesn't feel like a must-watch” while lamenting how much I miss Jon Stewart.
This is perhaps the most remarkable celebrity memoir I’ve ever read. I am a hyperbolic person by nature, but I’m really hard pressed to remember one that’s made this big an impression on me. Not just because of the content--which is at times heartbreaking and mindblowing--but also because of the humor and warmth with which Trevor Noah’s managed to convey some very difficult life experiences.
Born in South Africa in the mid '80s, Trevor Noah’s very existence as a biracial child was illegal. Even though apartheid fell while he was still a child, he faced unique challenges due to his ill-defined racial identity. He stood out as light-skinned in the poverty stricken black neighborhoods, but that didn’t mean that he was spared the poverty or the prejudice faced by anyone who wasn’t white.
Noah introduces each of his stories with a little bit of background information on the political climate and culture of South Africa. Then he describes different phases of his life through that lens, looking at how his childhood friendships, early attempts at romance, and a sometimes turbulent family life: His mother remained single by choice until Noah was around 10, then she married a man with a violent temper and he lost touch with his birth father.
It’s not all bleak, though. Some of the stories are just about the hi-jinks that a teenaged Noah got into with his friends. It should not surprise you to know that he was a bit of a troublemaker and a hustler in his youth.
But even when he’s describing some unimaginable difficulties, Noah managed to make me laugh SO MUCH. His solution to his fear of using an outhouse shared by several other families in his grandmother’s neighborhood? Ridiculous. The time that he didn’t realize that his date to the school dance didn’t speak the same language as him? Hilarious. His response to his mother throwing him out of a moving vehicle because she was afraid that the driver of the minibus was going to kill them? Shouldn’t be funny, but it was.
But, the story that killed me was the one where he realized just how problematic his friend Hitler’s name is.
This is the kind of book that knocked my worldview around a little bit. I always knew that, yes, life under apartheid was hard, but Noah showed me just how hard, in a very visceral and personal way. He also showed how the shadow of apartheid lingered long after Nelson Mandela walked free, something that’s easy to forget. But what he really does so well here is demonstrate the power of human resilience. He gives so much credit to his mother, which seems to phenomenally deserved. But as amazing a portrait as he paints of her, I’m left with a newfound respect for Trevor’s own ability to overcome and succeed against the odds. And to do so with a straight head and an amazingly funny sense of humor? Blows my mind. I gotta start watching The Daily Show every night again.
This is perhaps the most remarkable celebrity memoir I’ve ever read. I am a hyperbolic person by nature, but I’m really hard pressed to remember one that’s made this big an impression on me. Not just because of the content--which is at times heartbreaking and mindblowing--but also because of the humor and warmth with which Trevor Noah’s managed to convey some very difficult life experiences.
Born in South Africa in the mid '80s, Trevor Noah’s very existence as a biracial child was illegal. Even though apartheid fell while he was still a child, he faced unique challenges due to his ill-defined racial identity. He stood out as light-skinned in the poverty stricken black neighborhoods, but that didn’t mean that he was spared the poverty or the prejudice faced by anyone who wasn’t white.
Noah introduces each of his stories with a little bit of background information on the political climate and culture of South Africa. Then he describes different phases of his life through that lens, looking at how his childhood friendships, early attempts at romance, and a sometimes turbulent family life: His mother remained single by choice until Noah was around 10, then she married a man with a violent temper and he lost touch with his birth father.
It’s not all bleak, though. Some of the stories are just about the hi-jinks that a teenaged Noah got into with his friends. It should not surprise you to know that he was a bit of a troublemaker and a hustler in his youth.
But even when he’s describing some unimaginable difficulties, Noah managed to make me laugh SO MUCH. His solution to his fear of using an outhouse shared by several other families in his grandmother’s neighborhood? Ridiculous. The time that he didn’t realize that his date to the school dance didn’t speak the same language as him? Hilarious. His response to his mother throwing him out of a moving vehicle because she was afraid that the driver of the minibus was going to kill them? Shouldn’t be funny, but it was.
But, the story that killed me was the one where he realized just how problematic his friend Hitler’s name is.
This is the kind of book that knocked my worldview around a little bit. I always knew that, yes, life under apartheid was hard, but Noah showed me just how hard, in a very visceral and personal way. He also showed how the shadow of apartheid lingered long after Nelson Mandela walked free, something that’s easy to forget. But what he really does so well here is demonstrate the power of human resilience. He gives so much credit to his mother, which seems to phenomenally deserved. But as amazing a portrait as he paints of her, I’m left with a newfound respect for Trevor’s own ability to overcome and succeed against the odds. And to do so with a straight head and an amazingly funny sense of humor? Blows my mind. I gotta start watching The Daily Show every night again.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Born a Crime.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
December 21, 2016
– Shelved
January 3, 2017
–
Started Reading
January 4, 2017
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-15 of 15 (15 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Malia
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Jan 04, 2017 12:24PM
Loved this one! I'm glad you enjoyed it, too:-)
reply
|
flag
*
Jennifer, I can't listen to audiobooks. I don't know how to make myself focus on them, and I will go for half an hour then realize I have no idea what is happening. But I found myself wishing I had gotten this one on audio.
Awesome review, Jessica! I felt the same way about Trevor's version of The Daily Show, but getting to know him better through his stories has completely changed my viewpoint. The story about his friend named Hitler was one of my favorites too!
So glad you see the error of your ways re the continued importance of The Daily Show. I think Noah is priceless.
Thanks, Taryn. I am telling everyone that story in the hopes of encouraging them to read this. I feel a little silly, Trish. It's a combination of less time for watching any kind of TV at all, so it felt like less of a priority, and the feeling like when he started he didn't have the same kind of authority that Stewart had. But I'd still catch clips here and there, occasionally a full episode, and I always enjoyed it. Now I feel like I need to prioritize the show again, especially given how hard it is to digest any kind of news at all these days. :-/
Ahhh, I have this on my 2017 books-to-read mental list! I don't watch him regularly, but from what I've seen, I like him.
Jessica wrote: "But I'd still catch clips here and there, occasionally a full episode, and I always enjoyed it. Now I feel like I need to prioritize the show again..."Yes, I totally understand how it can get off your schedule. But the thing that I found so fascinating this year especially were his insights into the racial violence we have been experiencing. He could stand outside and point to things that someone more invested in the process might miss.
For instance, Trevor Noah did an amazing interview with Tomie Lahren, I think that's her name, she's a darling of the Far Right, in the last month or six weeks that is really something to see. If you can, watch the full 20 minute version of it. Jessica, great review! If you want to read another take on modern South Africa, with a fantasy- twist look for Zoo City by Lauren Buekes.
Julia wrote: "For instance, Trevor Noah did an amazing interview with Tomie Lahren, I think that's her name, she's a darling of the Far Right, in the last month or six weeks that is really something to see. If y..."I saw that one, Julia, and wonder what it is about that interview that you liked so much. I know some thought it was a kind of miracle two people who do not agree would speak to one another, but what I noticed is that she didn't answer questions but turned them into some other questions, which is something her party and like-minded thinkers do all the time. As a result, talking with them on camera is just another platform for their hate talk.
What it showed to me is that she had no answers for the tough questions, but Trevor Noah was calm, he kept asking the questions, so we could see her for who she is.
Our Diversity in All Forms book Club is reading this for March. We’d love to have you join the discussion on it. :)https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
While I like Trevor Noah, I think the Daily Show has gone downhill because most of John Stewart’s best writers went with Samantha Bee when she left. You can tell.
Good review, I bought the audiobook based off your review. I JUST started listening and it bated me immediately. I'm still at the very beginning so I haven't gotten to any humorous parts. I honestly think Trevor Noah is only a little funny on the daily show. I think you can be a smart talented funny well spoken person without being a brilliant comedian. I mean we can only have so much haha. I almost never watch his show. I mean it's absolutely mildly amusing, but let's be real, John Stewart is funnier. At least when it comes to the news/stand up type material. He's got sharper wit. Perhaps Trevor Noah is better at telling funny stories and writing brilliant books. He's good looking and incredibly likable too. I still won't start watching the daily show every day. I like it when I can't handle regular news shows haha. It softens the blow to hear the news in that format. Like when Trump first got into office.



