Mohammed Arabey's Reviews > The Lightning Thief
The Lightning Thief (Percy Jackson and the Olympians, #1)
by
by
One of the Greatest Urban Fantasy's Beginning I've ever read.

Now as I join Hogwarts every September to May, I'll spend my Summers in Half Blood Camps.

And Believe me if you didn't read it..you missed a real great series..
Very well written, well paced, amazing bunch of characters & funny sarcastic tone that you'll love no matter you're twelve or thirty three.
And creepy atmosphere and nightmarish scenes, interwoven with huge honest references of the Greek myth that serves as crazy urban fantasy theories related to our real life..
All that in a very hell of very thrilling real roller coaster plot, that takes you across the United States, and back again..
A story that serve for one complete story for 'Book One', and leaves you longing for the next ones that promising of even bigger plot.
Now, if you're still want me to talk about why you should start reading this series, heres the above's ..
ANALYSE ▪▪
Very Well Written. (4.75)
-------------------
Smoothly you step into the character, Percy, the narrator.. His life, bits about his past, then bit by bit into the conflict(s), then the Greek Mythology … then the Quest(s)..
Finding the Lighting Thief... which is not as easy as it seem..

ups and down with thriller and chilling and creepy and even funny parts. Everything smooth and well explained with what serve book one -with hints that sure will serve later books-
Well Paced. (4.99)
------------
See above. I truly rarely felt like that with most new YAs… always there's this boring slow parts that show up every now and then.
here everything measured , not too heavy boring flashbacks nor prolonged scene full of rant as many action YAs... it's like the amazing Harry Potter pace if u know what I mean.
Amazing Bunch of Characters (4.5)
--------------------------
I loved Percy, really. May be because everything smoothly introduced. And he just keep in character, I mean for 12 years old kid, would you believe he'd go to the dangerous underworld to retrieve the Lighting weapon from The Lighting Thief? Just because some gods will do wars for it? “Blaa-ha-ha!”.
Well... when you read his reason and motivation you'll find that it's more believable and true to the character.
And I love that.
Also having Attention Defucit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) and Dyslexia as well as it served an important point of making the high fantasy of the Greek Myth into our real world-urban- fantasy, it also a good touch to encourage any kid who suffers that -which is bit more than you may think- anyone can be hero.. just don't make it stops you. Percy didn't stop trying to read the whole book.. -kinda-
Annabith also was a fun to read. So smart. Groover... also this good "strange" friend..
And I also loved the mother and her love of Blue food. that reminds me..So long no photo, here's some blue food.

Also all the other characters are very well introduced.. just as every thing.
Funny Sarcastic Tone (4.5)
--------------------
Very easy lines, smart, wit, not just for the young age but really for all. -unlike my previous encounter with Magnus.- It's so funny here and in the point.
Creepy Atmosphere and Nightmarish Scenes (5)
---------------------------------------
It's not supposed to be a horror story. But it has a lot of creepy places the friends visit.. Like this "Ever after" Las Vegas Casino...or Medusa's Shop for statues.

And also the way Rick Riordan writes the nightmare scenes is really full of horror and creepy symbols.
And speaking of symbols ;
Relating Greek Myth to our Real World. (5)
--------------------------------
I am NOT a fan of Fantasy, I just prefer, rather adore URBAN FANTASY -Which is why I didn't like Magnus for some serious violation to the real world-
But this one really smartly written, with real references to actual myths or work of art and literature work.

I loved how Mr. Rick connect the prosperity of the ancient Greek myth and civilisation with the current American one.
His theory here is so smart..and convenient enough to fall in love and immerse into his well crafted world..
And if you're, like me, not feeling well about the gods concept.. he also have a convenient idea here ;

So, as I said, it's the amazing blending of the myth with real life in America is what makes it an excellent Urban Fantasy..
And speaking of America.
A Thrilling real Roller Coaster Plot (4.5)
that Takes you Across the United States (4.99)
and back again..
----------------------------------
Although the first story for Percy supposed to be just an "introduction" to this world, but you find yourself gotten into a hell of adventure full of crazy chase and creepy places hidden in real world..
There's this great concept of "the Mist", that surrounding the myth creatures among us as the story goes..
This theme of mist repeated in a good measure to keep the illusion that it's real story happening in our real world in a real famous places along the US.

And I loved visiting about 3 or 4 states and important places there through the first adventure only...and I believe more is coming in this Adventure Packed series..

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
So, finally... if you're a Harry Potter fan..or any newer YA fantasy fan... or if you're old school mythology fan, you'll love to join us the Half Blood Camp.. trust me.
A special thanks to my half blood friends who encouraged me repeatedly on starting this amazing series -why you didn't push me even harder :), kidding-, thanks again truly I'd never read it without your recommendation -felt I was too old to join another huge,full of books and many series.
but Rick Riordant really worth the read. He got his style,, may be reminded me with Harry Potter's first book structure..but wasn't it the greatest structure ever?
The point that he used it creating a whole new exciting crazy myth/modern adventure..
Mohammed Arabey
With the Olympians from 3 Nov. 2016
To 9 Nov. 2016

Now as I join Hogwarts every September to May, I'll spend my Summers in Half Blood Camps.
It's awfully late for me, I know. But I was stubborn enough to not listen to 2 of my best half blood friends here on Goodreads to visit the Olympians.

“Gods—the forces you call the Greek gods—are very much alive.”I can't believe it's just Mr. Rick Riordan’s first novel.
And Believe me if you didn't read it..you missed a real great series..
Very well written, well paced, amazing bunch of characters & funny sarcastic tone that you'll love no matter you're twelve or thirty three.
And creepy atmosphere and nightmarish scenes, interwoven with huge honest references of the Greek myth that serves as crazy urban fantasy theories related to our real life..
All that in a very hell of very thrilling real roller coaster plot, that takes you across the United States, and back again..
A story that serve for one complete story for 'Book One', and leaves you longing for the next ones that promising of even bigger plot.
Now, if you're still want me to talk about why you should start reading this series, heres the above's ..
ANALYSE ▪▪
Very Well Written. (4.75)
-------------------
Smoothly you step into the character, Percy, the narrator.. His life, bits about his past, then bit by bit into the conflict(s), then the Greek Mythology … then the Quest(s)..
Finding the Lighting Thief... which is not as easy as it seem..

ups and down with thriller and chilling and creepy and even funny parts. Everything smooth and well explained with what serve book one -with hints that sure will serve later books-
Well Paced. (4.99)
------------
See above. I truly rarely felt like that with most new YAs… always there's this boring slow parts that show up every now and then.
here everything measured , not too heavy boring flashbacks nor prolonged scene full of rant as many action YAs... it's like the amazing Harry Potter pace if u know what I mean.
Amazing Bunch of Characters (4.5)
--------------------------
I loved Percy, really. May be because everything smoothly introduced. And he just keep in character, I mean for 12 years old kid, would you believe he'd go to the dangerous underworld to retrieve the Lighting weapon from The Lighting Thief? Just because some gods will do wars for it? “Blaa-ha-ha!”.
Well... when you read his reason and motivation you'll find that it's more believable and true to the character.
And I love that.
Also having Attention Defucit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) and Dyslexia as well as it served an important point of making the high fantasy of the Greek Myth into our real world-urban- fantasy, it also a good touch to encourage any kid who suffers that -which is bit more than you may think- anyone can be hero.. just don't make it stops you. Percy didn't stop trying to read the whole book.. -kinda-
“Or maybe they’d realized I got my essay on Tom Sawyer from the Internet without ever reading the book and now they were going to take away my grade. Or worse, they were going to make me read the book. ”
Annabith also was a fun to read. So smart. Groover... also this good "strange" friend..
And I also loved the mother and her love of Blue food. that reminds me..So long no photo, here's some blue food.

Also all the other characters are very well introduced.. just as every thing.
Funny Sarcastic Tone (4.5)
--------------------
Very easy lines, smart, wit, not just for the young age but really for all. -unlike my previous encounter with Magnus.- It's so funny here and in the point.
Creepy Atmosphere and Nightmarish Scenes (5)
---------------------------------------
It's not supposed to be a horror story. But it has a lot of creepy places the friends visit.. Like this "Ever after" Las Vegas Casino...or Medusa's Shop for statues.

And also the way Rick Riordan writes the nightmare scenes is really full of horror and creepy symbols.
And speaking of symbols ;
Relating Greek Myth to our Real World. (5)
--------------------------------
I am NOT a fan of Fantasy, I just prefer, rather adore URBAN FANTASY -Which is why I didn't like Magnus for some serious violation to the real world-
But this one really smartly written, with real references to actual myths or work of art and literature work.

I loved how Mr. Rick connect the prosperity of the ancient Greek myth and civilisation with the current American one.
His theory here is so smart..and convenient enough to fall in love and immerse into his well crafted world..
And if you're, like me, not feeling well about the gods concept.. he also have a convenient idea here ;
“Well, now,” Chiron said. “God—capital G, God. That’s a different matter altogether. We shan’t deal with the metaphysical.”
“Metaphysical? But you were just talking about—”
“Ah, gods, plural, as in, great beings that control the forces of nature and human endeavors: the immortal gods of Olympus. That’s a smaller matter.”

So, as I said, it's the amazing blending of the myth with real life in America is what makes it an excellent Urban Fantasy..
And speaking of America.
A Thrilling real Roller Coaster Plot (4.5)
that Takes you Across the United States (4.99)
and back again..
----------------------------------
Although the first story for Percy supposed to be just an "introduction" to this world, but you find yourself gotten into a hell of adventure full of crazy chase and creepy places hidden in real world..
There's this great concept of "the Mist", that surrounding the myth creatures among us as the story goes..
“It's funny how humans can wrap their mind around things and fit them into their version of reality.”
This theme of mist repeated in a good measure to keep the illusion that it's real story happening in our real world in a real famous places along the US.

And I loved visiting about 3 or 4 states and important places there through the first adventure only...and I believe more is coming in this Adventure Packed series..

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
So, finally... if you're a Harry Potter fan..or any newer YA fantasy fan... or if you're old school mythology fan, you'll love to join us the Half Blood Camp.. trust me.
A special thanks to my half blood friends who encouraged me repeatedly on starting this amazing series -why you didn't push me even harder :), kidding-, thanks again truly I'd never read it without your recommendation -felt I was too old to join another huge,full of books and many series.
but Rick Riordant really worth the read. He got his style,, may be reminded me with Harry Potter's first book structure..but wasn't it the greatest structure ever?
The point that he used it creating a whole new exciting crazy myth/modern adventure..
Mohammed Arabey
With the Olympians from 3 Nov. 2016
To 9 Nov. 2016
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
The Lightning Thief.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
November 3, 2016
–
Started Reading
November 3, 2016
– Shelved
November 3, 2016
– Shelved as:
to-read
November 3, 2016
–
13.73%
"Wow, How I kept in ignorance of the half bloods all these years.\nDon't Judge A Book by its Movie.\nIt really grabbed my attention.. very good urban fantasy so far.\nAnd it's easy introduction to the Greek Myth.\n\nThank you Malak & Raoofa... 2 half bloods who really encouraged me joining this camp,\nThank you, I was really wrong to keep delaying that."
page
56
November 4, 2016
–
26.23%
"Oh God. & all gods or rather, forces.\nRick Riordan really making a very great concept for the Greek 'then Rome' 's gods & their location through ages.\n\nSo perfect Urban Fantasy. Not like the wild beginning of his newer series of the Norse gods.\n\nThe pace is perfect so far, the writing is fun. And I am so happy spending with Percy his first day at the Half Blood Camp.\n\nAnd so grateful for my half bloods friends ;)"
page
107
November 5, 2016
–
40.93%
"More Urban Fantasy elements.\nThe Demigods were fighting -and reason- of WWII, I love how he put it.\nThe Greek myth references are rich. \nAnd if you Potterhead you'll notice how brilliant Rowling mixed every myth references hidden in her Masterpiece saga-\n\nAnd the story start to clear up more, a Quest , a hard one is set for the 12 years old PJ, and his 2 friends.\nAnd what a bomb voyage to start it."
page
167
November 6, 2016
–
64.95%
"Now this story is really getting more layers than I expected.\nThe encounter with Medusa is so creepy. And with Ares is super cool.\nThe cross the road is fun, the visit to the Arch.\n\nThe dreams are so creepy, but you know what's really even more creepy;\nThe creepy hotel in Las Vegas. God that was nightmarish.\nSpecially with the pressure of how much time you wasted & it's just one day left to complete impossible Quest"
page
265
November 7, 2016
–
78.43%
"The Journey to the Underworld.. and House of Hades.\nVery bizarre and chaotic, I didn't fully imagine it. But then it's really exciting and the twist is very well written.\n\nAnd there's apparently something that will be for later books.\nIt's an Epic really. And as well as based on Greek myth, it's very American. And I love it.\n\nTomorrow will be end of Book One,\nThanks again for my half blood friends."
page
320
November 8, 2016
–
91.91%
"Now I'm officially a fan of Mr. Rick.\nThe last chapters were really amazingly written twist. Way better than this unfaithful movie.\n\nA very good conclusion for book one and all the characters. A hard choice to make.\nAnd although it's a proper ending, Iam really glad I have the rest of the books already.\n\nI loved everything here, characters, plot, myth, pace, even sarcasm was fun and not like this Magnus' book.\nTHANKS"
page
375
November 9, 2016
–
91.91%
"I used to finish the whole book, bad habit.\nI read 16 pages preview of Kane Chronicles, and I must buy this trilogy now\n\nAnd 8 pages preview of Percy Jackson's Book Two, and man, shame I wasted the whole year without giving this series a try, I'd be finishing it by now\n\nIt's one great cheerful read in a serious bad time I face in my work. Makes a great escape for a while.\n\nThere's also Doctor Strange, but talks later"
page
375
November 9, 2016
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-36 of 36 (36 new)
date
newest »
newest »
Raoofa wrote: "I'm really happy that you enjoyed the book and I guarantee to you that the rest of the series will exceed your expectation (except book 2 I didn't like it a lot)and I hope your hard days will pas..."
I'm sorry it's not a good review, just whatever in my mind now to just not forget why I loved this one that much.
Kane by the wayl looks so thrilling.
And for book two, I read 8 pages preview in the same book. And I have one sarcastic line I can't help but tease it in the review of it.
But don't worry, I always hate book twos -Chamber of Secrets almost made me stop following the young wizard anymore :)
I love immediate reviews. .excellent. .passionate review. .I'm glad you found a book you may compare it to Potter ..It seems that 2016 can't have enough..hope your dark days ends tomorrow. .you deserve better :))
Mohammed wrote: "Raoofa wrote: "I'm really happy that you enjoyed the book and I guarantee to you that the rest of the series will exceed your expectation (except book 2 I didn't like it a lot)and I hope your har..."
I already have Kane but I want to read Heroes of Olympus first but I'm waiting for black friday because the local book store make sale on the series :/
Nayra.Hassan wrote: "I love immediate reviews. .excellent. .passionate review. .I'm glad you found a book you may compare it to Potter ..It seems that 2016 can't have enough..hope your dark days ends tomorrow. .you de..."
Thank you so much , I loved the series unexpectedly so much .and can't wait to read more of it.
It's really strange stressful days, anyway it'll be better ان شاء الله
I'm very happy that you enjoyed it, kane is better, much better, here i'm pushing you to read it so you don't say that we didn't push you hard enough :) Raoofa recommend it to you??? :(
Raoofa wrote: "Mohammed wrote: "Raoofa wrote: "I'm really happy that you enjoyed the book and I guarantee to you that the rest of the series will exceed your expectation (except book 2 I didn't like it a lot)an..."
Really? You didn't read Heroes of Olympus after all this time?
Good luck in the BF day, well we have black everyday now in Egypt . Lol
Malak wrote: "I'm very happy that you enjoyed it, kane is better, much better, here i'm pushing you to read it so you don't say that we didn't push you hard enough :) Raoofa recommend it to you??? :("
First of all, really you did push me hard, and to be honest. I was sure I'll rate it 4 just for you cause I felt it'll be 3.5 ... but man, how wrong I was!
Brilliant really, and I can't thank you enough cause I swear I'd never even buy -and bile as usual- the series if not for your great enthusiastic recommendation.
Okay okay, wallahy I went through my mail to check who I add here first, and wallahy you two kept asking me more than some new authors asking to read their own novels -I wish you try by the way:)-
And yes, sometimes Raoofa would say , Malak asked me when will you start Percy
As I said, I will split it the whole series and I'll add you for the final one.
Oh and Death Cure, just I wish I like it.
And thank you. I already ordered Kane box set.
You two are real great Olympian Friends :)
Beety's Books wrote: "I'm really excited to read this! Another positive review, I'm so behind on those good books!!"That was my place too. I never would touch a book I'm 3 sequel series are already following, with huge fandom and really not encouraging movie At All.
And Gods? ,I hate high fantasy.
Well if not for my 2 friends here I would miss a really amazing Urban Fantasy here.
And since you're from our Wizarding World -not a muggle since you rated all 7 of HP 5 stars, and rated at least one companion book- trust me, Percy Jackson is one excellent read for you.
Mohammed wrote: "Raoofa wrote: "Mohammed wrote: "Raoofa wrote: "I'm really happy that you enjoyed the book and I guarantee to you that the rest of the series will exceed your expectation (except book 2 I didn't lik..."well it's really expensive .. series paperback=72$ and the hardcovers=100$ .. that's why I'm delaying it
Raoofa wrote: "well it's really expensive .. series paperback=72$ and the hardcovers=100$ .. that's why I'm delaying it ..."Oh that's too much, I thought you bought everyone in real time. , curious to know, which edition will you got?
PS: now I wish I had bought the hardcover box set of PJ before our Egyptian Pound get to half its value.
Dina wrote: "You're starting a very amazing journey and still have a long way ahead, which is great :D :D enjoy"O thank you so much, I'm already in love with the series now that I finished book 2 as well.
Did u try Heroes of the Olympes series as well?
Yeah, i think it gets better and bigger with the add of the roman mythology and new great characters. I think of both sagas one big continous story.
I enjoyed reading your review .. about the characters: first I noticed that u always love the protagonist :3, second Annabeth is one of my fav. character in this series but in book 4 you'll know her more about ADHD, did u know that Rick's son has ADHD so he purposely wrote that the hero-demi god- has ADHD so he'll know that his illness is an indication for a hero gene
Dina wrote: "Yeah, i think it gets better and bigger with the add of the roman mythology and new great characters. I think of both sagas one big continous story."I guess I'm going really to try as best to finish the 5 books this year..to read the second series ASAP.
it's really seems amazing too.
Raoofa wrote: "I enjoyed reading your review .. about the characters: first I noticed that u always love the protagonist :3, second Annabeth is one of my fav. character in this series but in book 4 you'll know he..."Thank u so so much :) I'm so glad u liked it.. I felt like I wanna talk about the experience as whole not just the first story - kinda as make mends after the Sword of Summer's review-
And yes,, when the story is as well told, I become as one with the protagonist ... but Annabeth is amazing and smart and rich as well. I'm more exciting for her more than the Groover.
Oh and about the ADHD ...that's sweet trivia.. and that's really nice from him.
Bayan wrote: "Have you seen the movie ?"Oh yes yes did I forget to mention, that Specially in Percy's case, NEVER JUDGE THE BOOK BY ITS MOVIE,,,it's totally different , the book way much better.
Well, I always wanted to read the books but the movies are just so lame so I was afraid that it would turn to be a waste of time .. Now you encouraged me to read them ..
Thanks
Bayan wrote: "Well, I always wanted to read the books but the movies are just so lame so I was afraid that it would turn to be a waste of time .. Now you encouraged me to read them ..
Thanks "
totally same feeling here..
He just build a perfect good world in the book, the characters are interesting and the story is bigger than the movie.
hope u like it, and will wait ur opinion ISA
I really like how you enrich your reviews with pictures I'm all new in the reviewing thing so I'm kind of learning from you I want to know your opinion about my review to the cursed child I was thinking in starting this series and you've encouraged me
Esraa wrote: "I really like how you enrich your reviews with pictures I'm all new in the reviewing thing so I'm kind of learning from you I want to know your opinion about my review to the cursed child I was th..."
Thank you a million really appreciate this comment, I loved ur 'from-heart' review of the cursed child, I believe I laughed as crazy with " اقتلي عمو يا حبيبتي' , u wrote it in English but I heard it through ur lines in arabic as simple as "تف علي عمو ياحبيبي"
Go on... read more, read reviews and do much better and u will.
Thank u a million.
thank you very much i read the harry potter series too many times and you always encouraged me to reread in English but I am just waiting to finish my exams
and when i wrote kill your uncle baby that was exactly what I was thinking of
Esraa wrote: "thank you very much i read the harry potter series too many times and you always encouraged me to reread in English but I am just waiting to finish my exams
and when i wrote kill your uncle baby ..."
I pray you do well in exams inshaAllah and trust me ur re-read in English you'll find out u missed 10% of book two and three, and over 25% of book four. I find my experience in reading Potter a life changing event really, I'd never read any serious books or even real good ones if not started with the English version.
Midoo86 wrote: "عايز اخد رأيك.السلسلة دي للأطفال ولا مناسبة للكبار في التلاتينات ؟"بص هي اقل شوية من هاري بوتر كفئة عمرية مقدمة لها لكنها ممتعة عاما بالنسبة لي كمتخطي الثلاثينات لكني عاما بحب القصة المكتوبة حلو حتي لو
Middle Grade
ودي عاملة مزيج حلو بين الميثولوجي الاغريقي والعالم المعاصر
جربها مش حتندم بجد انا شفت قراءتنا المشتركة ببروفايلك والتقييمات قريبة افتكر ان دي حتعجبك ان شاء الله
Midoo86 wrote: "تمام.خلاص يا باشا انا بثق برضه في ذوقك و هجربها"حستني رايك فيها ان شاء الله ، رحلة عجيبة ممتعة
I finished it a couple of days ago for the first time and it was really amazing! The movies were so bad.
Sarah wrote: "I finished it a couple of days ago for the first time and it was really amazing! The movies were so bad."So glad that u loved it... I loved the story so much too and glad I forget the movie, it almost made me skip reading the whole series.




and I hope your hard days will pass :(