Taryn's Reviews > Born a Crime: Stories from a South African Childhood
Born a Crime: Stories from a South African Childhood
by
by
Taryn's review
bookshelves: received-from-publisher, netgalley, biographies-and-memoirs
Nov 02, 2016
bookshelves: received-from-publisher, netgalley, biographies-and-memoirs
Trevor Noah is a South African comedian who currently hosts The Daily Show on Comedy Central. Born a Crime is about growing up in South Africa: living under apartheid when his existence was evidence of a crime, life after apartheid, the deep bond between a mother and son, the unique challenges of growing up mixed race, and living with an abusive stepfather. It's filled with humor and biting social commentary, but the main words that describe this book are insightful and heartfelt. I was already a casual fan, but this book can be read by anyone since his career is barely mentioned.
Born a Crime is a collection of stories from Trevor's life with a generally linear timeline. There was a tiny bit of jumpiness-- occasionally there would be something mentioned that would be elaborated on in another story. Overall, I really liked the format because there was no filler. Each chapter worked on its own and had a clear lesson, so I viewed them each individually. Trevor was always getting into trouble growing up and some of the chapters are about his antics. While these stories are hilarious on their own, he also places these anecdotes within a wider social context.
I've read a few books by South African authors this year and I wish I would've read this one first! Of all I've read and seen on the topic, this is the one that made the history 'click' the most. Each chapter is preceded by either historical or personal context. He also puts everything in perspective for outsiders: "In America you had the forced removal of the native onto reservations coupled with slavery followed by segregation. Imagine all three of those things happening to the same group of people at the same time. That was apartheid." It's a good reminder of the similarities between cultures and institutions, even though the specifics may vary.
Trevor was born to a black mother and a white father during a time when sexual relations between the two were strictly forbidden by law. He couldn't even walk beside his parents in public. It was interesting to read how he interpreted these events as a child. He describes the complicated rules enacted to keep an illogical system functioning and trying to find his place in a world with such defined boundaries.
His close relationship with his mother was one of my favorite parts of the book. He describes his mother as a rebel and I loved reading about how she subverted the system! She raised Trevor to know that there was no limit to what he could accomplish: “Even if he never leaves the ghetto, he will know that the ghetto is not the world. If that is all I accomplish, I’ve done enough.” He reveals the wisdom she imparted that made him the man he is today. Like his mom, he has a remarkable ability to adapt. I could also see where he gets his sense of humor! Even in one of the most tragic moments of the story, she's able to joke around. Though his father isn’t in the book as much, the chapter about him and the gift of being chosen is one of the parts that hit me the hardest.
Born a Crime is an insightful memoir that strikes the perfect balance of historical and personal. I learned a lot and it gave me a better context for what I already knew. It made me laugh and cry. I know I love a book when I'm giving everyone around me daily updates! If you are interested in the subjects addressed in this book, you might be interested in the short article Inner City by Lauren Beukes. Her short story collection Slipping is coming out in November, which features some stories about South African culture.
____________
I received this book for free from NetGalley and Spiegel & Grau in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review. The publication date is November 15, 2016.
People are willing to accept you if they see you as an outsider trying to assimilate into their world. But when they see you as a fellow tribe member attempting to disavow the tribe, that is something they will never forgive.
Born a Crime is a collection of stories from Trevor's life with a generally linear timeline. There was a tiny bit of jumpiness-- occasionally there would be something mentioned that would be elaborated on in another story. Overall, I really liked the format because there was no filler. Each chapter worked on its own and had a clear lesson, so I viewed them each individually. Trevor was always getting into trouble growing up and some of the chapters are about his antics. While these stories are hilarious on their own, he also places these anecdotes within a wider social context.
I've read a few books by South African authors this year and I wish I would've read this one first! Of all I've read and seen on the topic, this is the one that made the history 'click' the most. Each chapter is preceded by either historical or personal context. He also puts everything in perspective for outsiders: "In America you had the forced removal of the native onto reservations coupled with slavery followed by segregation. Imagine all three of those things happening to the same group of people at the same time. That was apartheid." It's a good reminder of the similarities between cultures and institutions, even though the specifics may vary.
Love is a creative act. When you love someone you create a new world for them. My mother did that for me, and with the progress I made and the things I learned, I came back and created a new world and a new understanding for her.
Trevor was born to a black mother and a white father during a time when sexual relations between the two were strictly forbidden by law. He couldn't even walk beside his parents in public. It was interesting to read how he interpreted these events as a child. He describes the complicated rules enacted to keep an illogical system functioning and trying to find his place in a world with such defined boundaries.
His close relationship with his mother was one of my favorite parts of the book. He describes his mother as a rebel and I loved reading about how she subverted the system! She raised Trevor to know that there was no limit to what he could accomplish: “Even if he never leaves the ghetto, he will know that the ghetto is not the world. If that is all I accomplish, I’ve done enough.” He reveals the wisdom she imparted that made him the man he is today. Like his mom, he has a remarkable ability to adapt. I could also see where he gets his sense of humor! Even in one of the most tragic moments of the story, she's able to joke around. Though his father isn’t in the book as much, the chapter about him and the gift of being chosen is one of the parts that hit me the hardest.
We live in a world where we don’t see the ramifications of what we do to others, because we don’t live with them. If we could see one another’s pain and empathize with one another, it would never be worth it to us to commit the crimes in the first place.
Born a Crime is an insightful memoir that strikes the perfect balance of historical and personal. I learned a lot and it gave me a better context for what I already knew. It made me laugh and cry. I know I love a book when I'm giving everyone around me daily updates! If you are interested in the subjects addressed in this book, you might be interested in the short article Inner City by Lauren Beukes. Her short story collection Slipping is coming out in November, which features some stories about South African culture.
People love to say, “Give a man a fish, and he’ll eat for a day. Teach a man to fish, and he’ll eat for a lifetime.” What they don’t say is, “And it would be nice if you gave him a fishing rod.”
____________
I received this book for free from NetGalley and Spiegel & Grau in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review. The publication date is November 15, 2016.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Born a Crime.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Comments Showing 1-38 of 38 (38 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Jennifer
(new)
-
added it
Nov 03, 2016 12:23PM
Great review!
reply
|
flag
*
Jennifer wrote: "Great review!"Thanks, Jennifer! I was only aware of Trevor Noah through his hosting, so it was nice to get to "know" him a little better!
Joy wrote: "I am in the middle of this one right now and loving it!"Joy - It's so good! I liked every story, which is rare. It's one of my favorites of the year.
Wondeful review, Taryn! Still miss Jon Stewart-he was my hero-wish he would run for Pres. LOL-except I'm serious
debra wrote: "Wondeful review, Taryn! Still miss Jon Stewart-he was my hero-wish he would run for Pres. LOL-except I'm serious"Thanks, Debra! Laughing, because my husband and I always 'joke' that we would vote for Jon as president too! That's high praise from my husband who doesn't compliment anyone! (He's a lot like Ron Swanson, if you've ever watched Parks&Rec.) We've enjoyed watching Trevor's version of the show too. This book made me appreciate him even more!
Taryn wrote: "debra wrote: "Wondeful review, Taryn! Still miss Jon Stewart-he was my hero-wish he would run for Pres. LOL-except I'm serious"Thanks, Debra! Laughing, because my husband and I always 'joke' that..."
Think we married the same man
This is a great review, Taryn. I ended up rating it 3 stars because the time jumping / light editing bothered me, and I would have liked more narrative cohesion. But you're 100% on the money about the sentiments and heartfelt nature of the read, and the history is well done too. Appreciate your take!
Esil wrote: "Excellent review Taryn. I wasn't sure about this one but you've sold me."Thanks, Esil! I hope you enjoy it too. I learned much more from this book than the standard celebrity memoir. I'm around the same age as Trevor, but our lives were so completely different.
Sam wrote: "This is a great review, Taryn. I ended up rating it 3 stars because the time jumping / light editing bothered me, and I would have liked more narrative cohesion. But you're 100% on the money about ..."Thank you so much, Sam! This is one of those I still get excited about a month after reading, hence the five stars! There are a few times where the time jumping bothered me: the stepfather mentions before the last story and the time where he was given a piece of equipment to grow his business with hints of a larger story.* I'm not sure why the format didn't bother me more. I read a memoir last year with a similar structure (all over the place time-wise, but generally going from childhood to adulthood) and it completely ruined my reading experience!
*For anyone who hasn't read it: He does elaborate in a later story!
Taryn, you were one up on me, at least! I only knew who he was when he made an appearance on some show, probably Stephen Colbert, to promote his book, and I didn't listen to all of that. I'd heard his name mentioned prior to seeing him for maybe a minute or two. He seemed very personable and charming in that brief time, though. Loved your review! Still debating this one.
Cheri wrote: "Taryn, you were one up on me, at least! I only knew who he was when he made an appearance on some show, probably Stephen Colbert, to promote his book, and I didn't listen to all of that. I'd heard ..."Thanks, Cheri! I don't get to watch The Daily Show as much as I did in the Jon Stewart days because we don't have cable service anymore, but I've been making more of an effort to seek out clips since I read this book. The "personable and charming" personality comes out really strong in his writing. I bet it will be great on audio, but I don't regret reading the print version since I could "hear" his voice while I was reading.
Deanna wrote: "Great review!"Thank you, Deanna! I've been lucky to read many wonderful memoirs this year!
i just picked this up from the library - which i was already excited about, and reading your review made me even more excited! thanks!
Season wrote: "i just picked this up from the library - which i was already excited about, and reading your review made me even more excited! thanks!"Thank you, Season! I hope you enjoy reading it as much as I did!
Malia wrote: "Great review! I'm seeing him speak this weekend! So excited to get my hands on a copy of this book"Thanks, Malia! It's so awesome that you're going to see him in person! He has so many interesting stories to tell!
Is there a way I can access it online? Because I believe have not yet reached our third world:-kenya
Mohamed wrote: "Is there a way I can access it online? Because I believe have not yet reached our third world:-kenya"Hi, Mohamed! I don't know about any online sources. I think it will probably be hard to find, because it was just published a few days ago. I hope you are able to find a copy!
Malia wrote: "Great review! I just saw him speak yesterday, and it was excellent! Can't wait to read the book:-)"Malia - I'm so happy to hear the event went well! I hope you enjoy the book! His voice comes through strongly in his writing!
Jennifer! Thank you! It's definitely on my top list. In a way, he's helped me keep my sanity over the past few weeks, so I'm glad I got this chance to "know" him better.
"... an insightful memoir that strikes the perfect balance of historical and personal", a perfect way to describe this memoir.Fantastic review Taryn, I think we had a similar experience with this compelling memoir.
Jennifer wrote: "Great review, Taryn. This was one of my favorites of the year."Hi, Jennifer Did you get this on audio from audible?All best
Iris wrote: ""... an insightful memoir that strikes the perfect balance of historical and personal", a perfect way to describe this memoir.Thank you, Iris! I was so impressed with this book and Trevor! I enjoy him on The Daily Show even more now that I know more about his background.
I'd missed this one while we were moving house... Just started the audiobook today and loving it. Even more excited now I've seen your views.
PatsyPoo wrote: "I'd missed this one while we were moving house... Just started the audiobook today and loving it. Even more excited now I've seen your views. "I bet the audiobook is amazing! I still want to listen to it, even though I already read the book! I hope you are still enjoying it and I look forward to your thoughts!
Great review! I'm a casual fan too. This has been on my To-Read list for awhile and my book club just chose it for our June read :).








