Amanda's Reviews > Hidden Figures: The American Dream and the Untold Story of the Black Women Mathematicians Who Helped Win the Space Race
Hidden Figures: The American Dream and the Untold Story of the Black Women Mathematicians Who Helped Win the Space Race
by Margot Lee Shetterly (Goodreads Author)
by Margot Lee Shetterly (Goodreads Author)
This was such an extraordinary, exhilarating and important story to tell, but the writing was so dry, repetitive and full of platitudes that it began to dull the edges of this sharp tale. I really hope that the author was able to get through some revisions to work out some of the weaknesses in the writing because the story is so important -- it's about African-American women in the South who, because of the war, are temporarily able to secure jobs as 'human computers' at NACA -- which later becomes NASA. The convergence / overlap of the lives of these women with the collective dreams of the nation and its obsessive space race are fraught with contradiction and celebration. It's really exciting to see how the Langley Research Institute continues to grow and expand over the arch of the story, and to see how the laws transform during the course of these women's careers. Yet the tone is at times so flowery and glib that the women become caricatured heroes as opposed to complex women in extraordinary times. I wish the writing was more creative, narrative-driven and sensory to give us a real sense of who they really were as opposed to casting them as emblematic symbols of a people and a nation. I am actually excited in this case that there's a major motion picture b/c I think it'll bring the narrative structure into clearer relief -- the lives of the main characters -- Dorothy, Katherine and Mary -- are so intertwined and overlapping that it's hard to keep track of whose story is being told at any given moment. The author bounces around and, combined with the intensive technical language, whole passages are muddled with confusion. Still, it's a fascinating moment in US history and these women's stories are truly remarkable.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Hidden Figures.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
| 08/15/2016 | marked as: | read | ||
Comments (showing 1-10 of 10) (10 new)
date
newest »
newest »
FYI, the book changed A LOT between the advance reader copy and the final pub. If you found it too technical it still has a lot of info (though a bit less), but the concepts are more clearly explained. To beat the movie the edits of the book were rushed, meaning an unusual number of changes between the reader copy and the final draft.
Oh! That's great news, Aran! Thanks for the insight, I am excited to see the film. And the story is MESMERIZING and very important! I am glad I read it!
I read the final version, not the advanced copy, and had the same reaction. Very interesting information, but painfully dry at times.
I am reading it now and am having trouble staying awake. Interesting topic but unbearably dry writing.
Lynn wrote: "I am reading it now and am having trouble staying awake. Interesting topic but unbearably dry writing."Stick with it -- it's worth learning the history and the writing does get more interesting. I hear you, though!
I'm finding it really confusingly laid out. I'm halfway through and only just figured out that Katherine golbe IS Katherine Johnson. It jumps around so much that it wasn't apparent they were the same person until Jim Johnson was mentioned. The information is great, I just really wish it was better organized.
I read the final version and felt the same way. I found it disappointing overall. I'm looking forward to seeing the movie though.


Hi Jabreel -- I read an Advanced Reader copy that I received from the Chicago Humanities Festival. I believe the book is out next month, September 2016 and the film release is January 2017. It's pretty amazing, intense, and full of technical details as well as personal stories. Enjoy!